10 ms·
The theory that deflation is bad for an economy doesn't say "but only when that economy is over a certain size". It is an absolute theory that claims to apply e
by mike_hearn 11y ago
The theory that deflation is bad for an economy doesn't say "but only when that economy is over a certain size". It is an absolute theory that claims to apply everywhere.
I've been saying this theory is bunk for years, so it's nice to finally see the view start to surface in mainstream publications. You only have to review the data to discover that there's no empirical link between deflation and depression. For instance, take this paper, written by economists at the Minneapolis Fed:
https://www.minneapolisfed.org/research/sr/sr331.pdf https://www.minneapolisfed.org/research/sr/sr331.pdf
Abstract:
Are deflation and depression empirically linked? No, concludes a broad historical study of inflation and real output growth rates. Deflation and depression do seem to have been linked during the 1930s. But in the rest of the data for 17 countries and more than 100 years, there is virtually no evidence of such a link.
But you don't really need data to convince yourself that the 2%-inflation-is-best theory is nonsense. Basic common sense should be good enough. The entire thing rests on the assumption that there's a class of investments that people would refuse to invest in if left to their own devices, but which suddenly become attractive only if their savings are shrivelled by a few percent a year. Such a class of investments certainly does exist: they're called bad investments!
- djur 11y ago> The theory that deflation is bad for an economy doesn't say "but only when that economy is over a certain size". It is an absolute theory that claims to apply everywhere. Please cite an economist saying that.
- nickff 11y agoHere you go.[1] [1] http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/08/02/why-is-deflation-bad/?_r=0 http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/08/02/why-is-deflation...
- djur 11y ago> If the economy is doing well, all this can be offset by just keeping interest rates low There's your condition; there can be others that don't fit into a single blog post aimed at American readers. Various deflationary measures are also recommended by orthodox economists in cases of hyperinflation.
- nickff 11y agoI cited an economist who never mentioned anything about the size of an economy when talking the evils of deflation. You are moving the goalposts. What is your new demand? That I prove a negative? That I have to quote an economist who says "deflation is bad, no matter the size of the economy"? The post you responded to said: "The theory that deflation is bad for an economy doesn't say "but only when that economy is over a certain size". It is an absolute theory that claims to apply everywhere.", not that deflation hawks said economy size doesn't matter (it is implied through omission). Please accept that your curt and dismissive comment was falsified by a random commenter on HN who spent literally 30 seconds on Google, and typed in "Krugman deflation<CR>".
- djur 11y agoI am looking for a claim that "deflation is bad... is an absolute theory that [applies] everywhere." 'Size of economy' is just one possible exception that would belie an absolute theory that applies everywhere. By the way, I have not been insulting to you, and I would appreciate the same consideration.
- thescriptkiddie 11y ago> The entire thing rests on the assumption that there's a class of investments that people would refuse to invest in if left to their own devices, but which suddenly become attractive only if their savings are shrivelled by a few percent a year. Such a class of investments certainly does exist: they're called bad investments! That makes so much sense. The main argument against inflation is that if people see the value of their money increase, they will stop spending it and instead hold onto with the expectation that the value will rise further. That's certainly true of investors, who tend to panic sell anything that fails to outperform the dollar. But most people don't see their money as a commodity - they will only notice that the price of consumer goods is falling, and use that as a justification to spend more. So deflation is only really bad for Wall Street. Inflation subsidizes the stock market.
- eric_h 11y ago> The main argument against inflation is that if people see the value of their money increase this is the main argument against DEflation, is it not?
- Mikeb85 11y agoOne problem with deflation is that it means wages go down too. Even if price levels go down (which, as you said, should spur demand), lower wages cause consumers to hoard money, which causes the value of money to go up, which causes more hoarding, which causes prices to go down, etc... It's not called a deflationary spiral for nothing. There are many reasons why inflation is a good thing - wages go up (people like that), the value of investments goes up (people like that), and while it doesn't always correlate to inflation, the money supply needs to increase over time as the population increases, otherwise you'll have some major demographic issues...
- hectormalot 11y agoI don't think deflation has to drive wages down actually. Deflation simply means that your dollar (or CHF) can buy more tomorrow than today, and hence unless you can invest in something that appreciates faster than that rate, you would keep the money in cash rather than spending it, unless your expense is really necessary (say food). Inflation then of course means that your money is worth more today than tomorrow, and therefore you are more likely to spend it (and more investments become attractive, as long as they perform better than the currency). Will wages come down, over time in a purely deflationary economy probably yes. But unlike most inflationary economies where it is usual to have a x% salary growth y/y, I think the barrier to sign a contract that says: "your salary is X, and will decrease by z% per year" is a lot higher. So, if a country has only mild deflation - like Switzerland - the real value is actually likely to go up. > wages go up (people like that) That's also not a given, its likely to have a raise in contracts, but if I promise you a 2% yearly raise with inflation of 3% you are not really getting a great deal, are you? > [..] major demographic issues True, I see inflation as a great way to equally tax 'old money', and in a way that is almost impossible to escape. In the end inflation is good for those with debt (governments/corporations are first in line), deflation is great for those with cash (but not necessarily other assets, those will probably adjust to the new price level).
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> The theory that deflation is bad for an economy doesn't say "but only when that economy is over a certain size". It is an absolute theory that claims to apply everywhere. But having an economy that uses currency X, but does much of its trade in currency Y, changes the dynamic compared to considering an economy in isolation, doesn't it? > But you don't really need data to convince yourself that the 2%-inflation-is-best theory is nonsense. Basic common sense should be good enough. The entire thing rests on the assumption that there's a class of investments that people would refuse to invest in if left to their own devices, but which suddenly become attractive only if their savings are shrivelled by a few percent a year. Such a class of investments certainly does exist: they're called bad investments! I think you're missing the basis for the 2%-inflation-is-best theory. Let's start with this: When is deflation bad? Deflation is bad when it's sustained enough that your salary goes down, and you owe money. And if there are enough people in that circumstance, it's bad for the economy as a whole, because a bunch of people default on their debts, which tends to cause a depression. A mild deflation that doesn't lead to lower wages, on the other hand, is probably good for the economy as a whole. But here's the thing: When deflation is bad for the economy, it tends to be really bad. The central bank would prefer to avoid that situation. 2% inflation leaves them a bit of room before they run into that circumstance, so that they can try to maneuver to avoid it.
- nerfhammer 11y agoDeflation is bad because - you earn a rate of return on simply sitting on money. Doing nothing competes with investing. If deflation is 5%, why bother making an investment that could return 5%? Why does a rich person deserve to earn a rate of return on their wealth for nothing? - deflation incentivizes non-spending. People will delay purchases if they expect prices to decrease in the future. - deflation necessitates nominal pay cuts. People are psychologically unwilling to accept pay cuts. This leads to layoffs, strikes, labor unrest. - deflation necessitates a decrease in nominal aggregate income. Your savings growing by 2% sounds nice, but most people's cash savings is a tiny fraction of their future income. Your income will go down. Own any stocks? Those could decrease in value every year. - deflation increases the cost of debt. How would you like it if your credit card debt or student loan debt grew by 2% every year?
- mc32 11y agoSo, how do we explain Japan? It's been deflationary for decades and the economy hasn't improved in real or relative terms. Is their deflation different, to borrow a phrase, or is CH's deflation a bit unique? I'd love to see a contrast btwn CH and JP in this regard. Or, how could Japan stop worrying and love deflation, Swiss style.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI'd chip in several thousand dollars to have a study commissioned to answer these questions. I've believed all of the above for years (RE Japen), but would be interested if my beliefs intersect with data and facts.
- Mikeb85 11y agoSwitzerland's deflation is unique in that it's the result of their currency drastically gaining value on the currency of their neighbors. It's more of a price adjustment and doesn't really show the signs of a deflationary spiral... Domestic goods still increased in price, as did housing, but imported goods brought down basket prices.
- saosebastiao 11y agoAt its peak of the Japanese Asset Bubble, the Imperial Palace of Japan was valued higher than the sum of all real estate in the state of California. Simply put, the Japanese Asset Bubble was the worst asset bubble in the history of asset bubbles. In order to stabilize the collapse of the asset bubble, they have been playing loosey-goosey with interest rates for two decades now. But in order to stabilize the fall in asset prices using monetary policy (a blunt instrument if there ever was one), they essentially have been inflating everything else. So while they have nominally had deflation in aggregate, they have had inflation levels in consumables (which is about 70% of the cost of living) that are bordering, if not surpassed, what most economists would call HyperInflation.
- eloff 11y agoI find the factoid about the imperial palace hard to believe. Can you point me at some source/supporting evidence?
- skywhopper 11y agoInflation/deflation is just one of many factors that affect the health of an economy, sure. But on a micro level, deflation is very bad for anyone with debt in the deflating currency. In countries where that class includes a large portion of the population, deflation is bad for the economy as a whole.