3 ms·
Another negative side effect is it discourages good teachers. A neighbor told me how he wanted to be a science teacher in highschool. He shadowed one of the ol
by rdtsc 11y ago
Another negative side effect is it discourages good teachers. A neighbor told me how he wanted to be a science teacher in highschool. He shadowed one of the older science teachers and was basically discouraged by what he found out from them -- the advice was "you don't get to actaully teach much fun or interesting stuff, just teach to the test"
Or put it another way, think about the people who would choose to teach knowing that they'll just be drilling tests all day every day. Think about personalities that process will select for. And those will be people teaching your kids.
- Goronmon 11y agoYup, I am close friends/family with 4 teachers. One is pretty much done after this year. Another has been seriously considering leaving for the last couple. Both basically for the same reasons. One summed up the problem as all the time and effort spent on standardized testing actually means that the system focuses almost exclusively on evaluating teachers (and whether they are following the prescribed teaching materials close enough) and could really care less about the individual students and the quality of the education.
- matwood 11y agoI think it is important to remember why testing came about. Bad schools were doing so bad that kids were graduating HS without the ability to read or do basic math. In order to fix a problem this bad, first measurements have to be taken. My biggest problem with testing is that it can hold back gifted students.
- rdtsc 11y agoBut why are most schools spending almost all their time teaching to the test so to speak. Were all of them miserable failures before? Why couldn't they just focus on underperforming school and investigagte what is happening there (probably poverty, crime, bad home environments if I had to guess...). I also don't understand the idea of relating budgets to test scores. It is like they want schools to fail on purpose -- "Looks like you are struggling here with teaching these kids, ok, well we'll cut your budget, that should help..."
- matwood 11y ago> But why are most schools spending almost all their time teaching to the test so to speak. Is this really problem if when taught the test someone can do general math and reading comprehension? At that point, teaching the test is teaching the basic skills we expect a member of society to have. The only problem I have with teaching the test is it gives a disincentive to push gifted students beyond the test material. > "Looks like you are struggling here with teaching these kids, ok, well we'll cut your budget, that should help..." Welcome to the perverse federal government. States handle education so they could simply tell the feds no, but the feds use tax dollars to twist the states arms. This is also how highway speeds get set. The federal government takes a bunch of tax money from the states and then holds it hostage unless the states implement what the federal government wants. This is one of the big reasons for people wanting smaller/less federal government.
- analog31 11y agoIs that really true? My recollection is that standardized testing came about because of a fad to improve education by making it more "accountable" and "managed like a business." It was the educational version of stack ranking.