5 ms·
In practice, other than being burdensome for foreigners, does it have consequential effects on ordinary Japanese, in their view? I mean family registries are f
by mc32 11y ago
In practice, other than being burdensome for foreigners, does it have consequential effects on ordinary Japanese, in their view?
I mean family registries are fascinating. In some places people are obliged to register people coming in and out of a household etc, like a living census. And for some jobs people have to provide family histories and professions, etc., but nevertheless the people I've spoken to aren't much bothered by as much as I seem to. For many, if not most or all, it just is. And, anthropologically it's fascinating.
- zyxley 11y ago> does it have consequential effects on ordinary Japanese To quote the article: > Though generally considered offensive, the term Eta is still in use today. One of the letters received at the abattoir expresses sympathy for the animals being killed "as they're being killed by Eta." > "Nowadays it's still a well-known fact that people are buying this information, but rather than corporations, it's individuals buying it to check on future in-laws ahead of marriage. That's one of the biggest examples of discrimination that we frequently face." > "I remember once when my wife and I were visiting with some of her father's relatives. When I told them what I did, they stopped pouring me beer."
- patio11 11y agoTangent, but it actually happened, and I'm doing my best to recollect the conversation: I once met a young lady for coffee. (It wasn't quite a date, but a situation which could eventually lead to being retconned as a date.) She asked me, in a fashion which struck me as out-of-the-blue, "Do I strike you as a typical Japanese girl?" I figured that she was fishing for a compliment (thought process: "Who would want to be as-sent-by-central-casting?") , so I said "Oh no, you strike me as different." She immediately burst out crying, and asked "How did you know?" "I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry. I didn't mean it to be taken that way. I thought you wanted me to say that you were a unique person." "No no I want nothing other than to be a typical Japanese girl." "What does that... OH GOD. I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry no it is absolutely not possible that anybody could guess that you're ethnically Korean." (The word in Japanese is "zainichi", for 在日韓国人, the literal translation of which is "A Korean who lives in Japan.") "... Wait you know about us?" "I studied a variety of esoteric things in college." "So you don't think less of me for being... you know..." "NO NO NO NO." Cue about an hour of talking about it. She said that none of her friends knew. I said that 2007 was a very different time than e.g. 1970 and they'd probably be understanding. "Maybe, but I can't unring that bell. What if one of them hates Koreans? What if all of them hate Koreans? What if I told? I'd never get my life back." Tangent over. Do you believe a piece of paper which says "My grandfather is named Kim" fails to have a consequential effect on this young lady? (Controversial opinion for Japan incoming: She's Japanese, not Korean, under all the laws of earth and heaven. She was born in Japan, she speaks no language but Japanese, she carries a Japanese passport, she carries no other passport nor desires one, she is entirely culturally Japanese, she feels no feelings of belonging to Korea, actual Koreans would not treat her as being Korean, etc etc ad nauseum, but there exists a not-tiny contingent of her fellow countrymen who would immediately fire-in-the-eyes hate her if they somehow came to believe she was Korean.)
- dennisgorelik 11y ago> hate her if they somehow came to believe she was Korean Why would they hate her for having Korean ancestry?
- Mz 11y agoRacism? It takes different forms in different countries, but it is alive and well.
- dennisgorelik 11y agoWhy is racism still alive and well? Does it help in anything?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- notjoedimaggio 11y agoOne theory would be that humans have a biological sense of other. In-group, out-group, etc. People fight for the same resources, preferentially for their genetically similar groups. If there are 10 people at a table about to starve to death, and only 5 of them are related, it helps their genetic lineage to prefer to feed relatives. Racism, as an outgrowth of us-versus-them, most likely helped with keeping a lineage alive.
- Natsu 11y agoIt's self-perpetuating. People do mean things to other people because other people have done mean things to them or their group because of that group and the cycle continues. It doesn't help that people often fail to recognize the fundamental attribution error in play, either.
- e12e 11y ago> Does it help in anything? Many argue that an arbitrary division among the disenfranchised and poor is an effective barrier for them to rise up against the minority that hoard the resources for themselves. So one could argue that it does help someone.