3 ms·
Come on; all of the world is 'solar powered' by that stretch. Oil came from algae which grew from sunlight. The point is valid: the density of solar exposure a
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Come on; all of the world is 'solar powered' by that stretch. Oil came from algae which grew from sunlight.
The point is valid: the density of solar exposure at the surface of earth, times the capture/conversion rate to chemical energy, is too low to support animal life. As demonstrated by billions of years of evolution.
- mikeash 11y agoOil involves collecting solar power for billions of years, then using that collected energy over tens or hundreds of years. Animals eating plants, on the other hand, involves collecting solar power for weeks or months, then using that collected energy over weeks or months. Animals eating other animals might involve collecting solar power for years, or a decade or two at most, but no more. Global solar flux is clearly sufficient to sustain all animal life on the planet because that's exactly what it does, while it's clearly insufficient to sustain current oil usage because we're using it orders of magnitude faster than it was produced.
- teraflop 11y agoThat makes no sense. Animals don't consume oil; they consume plant matter (directly or indirectly) which derived its energy from sunlight fairly recently (days to months). The total amount of energy in and out balances, over evolutionarily short timescales. Where do you think animals are getting their energy from, if not from the sun?
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoHighly concentrated sources of calories (originally sun energy) that they burn at a far greater rate than they could possibly collect themselves.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Come on; all of the world is 'solar powered' by that stretch. Much, but not all. > Oil came from algae which grew from sunlight. Sure, oil is indirect solar power. The problem with oil is that's rapid consumption of a stockpile accumulated over a much longer time, which produces sustainability and carbon-balance problems. > The point is valid: the density of solar exposure at the surface of earth, times the capture/conversion rate to chemical energy, is too low to support animal life. As demonstrated by billions of years of evolution. Er, no, it does support animal life. IF it was too low to support animal life, than animal life could only exist by the equivalent of burning oil; e.g., it could only evolve with an accumulated stockpile of stored energy which it is burning down. That's not the case, so the negation of your conclusion is, in fact, proven by nature. (And even evolution hadn't produced a mechanism that did that -- in which case we wouldn't be having this discussion -- that wouldn't prove it was impossible. Otherwise, all the technologies that we have developed for which there are no biological analogs produced by evolution would be impossible, which is clearly not the case.)
- Dylan16807 11y agoYou're misinterpreting. The amount of light that hits the animal is not enough, it takes a much larger area covered with plants.
- jules 11y agoNuclear power isn't solar power even by that definition.
- zardo 11y agoIt ultimately comes from a star, but not Sol.