9 ms·
'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch
- wmt 11y ago*while illuminated by a bright laser. By dimming the laser the quantum behaviour returned, and you watching the atoms or not had no effect on the phenomenon. Despite the misleading title, I imagine affecting the quantum behaviour of atoms with lasers has all kinds of nice use cases!
- stephengillie 11y agoOne of the key points of the article is that measurement is necessary to freeze the state. Where do you see watching the atoms or not had no effect on the phenomenon?
- rubidium 11y agoAffecting the quantum behavior of atoms with lasers is pretty much the entire field of ultracold quantum gases :) A handful of Nobel prizes have been awarded for it.
- sjclemmy 11y ago'In the quantum world, the folk wisdom really is true: “A watched pot never boils.”'
- TeMPOraL 11y agoMaybe that folk wisdom originates from demons and the Nephilim, back from before the Deluge - that is, from our highly advanced ancestors who could manipulate energy and matter much better than we do before their planetary-scale hydroengineering project turned into a disaster?
- pistle 11y agoAnd yet it does boil. The folk wisdom is wrong, so is the experiment wrong as well?
- pmontra 11y agoMany measurements == little change? It sounds vaguely familiar of overloaded computing systems. Maybe we'll run timing attacks on whatever the quantum world is.
- bitJericho 11y agoI hope we can hack the universe at some point. I think it would be very beneficial for humanity if we could break out of our universe.
- bandrami 11y ago"emergent classicality" is my new favorite phrase.
- signa11 11y agowhat i really don't quite get (amongst a large number of other things as well), is how you could have observed an atom without disrupting it's quantum state...
- ajuc 11y agome neither. doesn't it break "no cloning" rule?
- oceanofsolaris 11y agoThe Zeno effect is basically due to disruption of the quantum state. You measure repeatedly in some basis and this basically pins the state down (in this basis representation) even though it would not stay in this state if you did not interact with it.
- jlebrech 11y agocould you freeze someone/something in time by watching all those atoms?
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoYou really should read the rest of the article. The imaging laser does nothing to impede normal movement, only quantum tunneling, which only happens frequently/reliably at near-absolute-zero temperatures anyway.
- Strilanc 11y agoIf I understand correctly, what's going on is... Suppose you have a system rotating between state |0> and state |1>, like f(t) = cos(t) |0> + sin(t) |1>. If you measure at time t, you get |0> with probability cos(t)^2. After measuring, the system starts rotating again, but reset to |0> (assuming you measured that). If you measure n times per rotation period, the chance of measuring the state |0> every time (i.e. of effectively keeping the system in the |0> state) is (cos(τ/n)^2)^n per period. That converges to 100% as n gets large. So, by measuring more and more frequently, you can effectively stop a system like that from transitioning between states. It's an interesting example of measurement unavoidably affecting quantum systems, where the problem clearly isn't due to kicking or perturbing the state.
- tomp 11y agoSo, imagine you have a ball and a slope o __/\__ (ball should be on top in the middle). The ball will slowly start rolling down one or the other side of the slope (because gravity). You have a robot hand that keeps checking if the ball is still on top by grabbing it and then releasing it right in the middle. There is some leeway when the hand grabs the ball but none when it releases it. __|__ _|_ | o | => |o| So effectively, if you do this fast enough, you keep "resetting" the ball on top of the slope. Is this a good analogy?
- Strilanc 11y agoNot really. A minor problem is that it fails to capture the fact that this process will also hold the qubit stable in the |1> state. More importantly, it fails to capture the limiting behavior of the success rate; it should move smoothly towards 100% as the measurement frequency increases but the ball-and-slope would instead jump discontinuously from not working to working as the hand went from being too-slow to fast-enough. A better example might be... a series of polarizing filters? If you have a series of polarizers but skip all the way from vertical to horizontal with nothing in between, no light gets through. If you put a diagonal polarizer between the horizontal and vertical, some light gets through. If you have a big long series of very gradual steps from vertical polarizer to horizontal polarizer, almost all the light gets through. More frequent measurements causing the zeno effect is like to adding more gradations of polarizer direction causing the all-light-gets-through effect.
- buzzdenver 11y agoLayman question: what constitutes observation in the world of quantum physics ? The article suggests that stronger light means less quantum effects, but isn't observation a binary thing, so something is either watched or not.
- ars 11y agoObservation means interaction. So a stronger light means it interacts more extensively with something else. It does NOT mean a human. It can interact with anything, another particle even.
- gpvos 11y agoObviously it is not about observation by a human; I don't think anyone on here thinks we are special magical creatures when it comes to quantum physics. However, not all interactions with another particle count as an observation, and I think the poster asked for a more precise description of the boundary, and why it would not be a boundary but actually appears to be a continuum.
- gnaritas 11y ago> I don't think anyone on here thinks we are special magical creatures when it comes to quantum physics. The general public does, most explanations of the double slit experiment you can find lead people to believe that mind affects reality because the word observation confuses people into thinking consciousnesses is involved.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoHumans observe smells through quantum physics.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Strilanc 11y agoAny effect that is conditional on the state and thermodynamically irreversible counts as a measurement. One way to do a partial measurement is to make the conditional effects less orthogonal to each other, e.g. cause a target qubit to conditionally rotate by 22 degrees instead of a full 180 degrees. Another possible concept for a partial measurement is not distinguishing between all of the cases. For example, if a system can be in the x=-1, x=0, or x=1 cases then it's possible to do a measurement that distinguishes x=-1 from x in {0,1} without collapsing all the way down to x=0 or x=1.
- fsiefken 11y agoWould there be a difference in result when only the computer looked at the individual positions, logged the measurements, determined them and noted the level of quantum behaviour to test this hypothesis? I read this thread on the physics stackexchange http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/110488/consciousness-causes-collapse-interpretation-or-free-will-excluded-by-quantum http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/110488/consciousn... ..and it is said most professional physicists don't believe in this 'consciousness (human or otherwise) causes collapse' Neumann-Wigner interpretation (and that of John Wheeler and Henri Stapps) and most amateurs do, but has it been tested in this way also by ruling out far out psi effects like retropsychokinesis by deleting or encrypting the data in such a way it can only be verified by a 'team' of independent artificial scientists (networked statistical software)?
- ars 11y ago"Looking" means "interacting". It does not mean a human is looking, it means the particle is doing something with another particle.
- Confusion 11y agoI was convinced this was already known and verified long ago. I've certainly told people this was True.
- kintamanimatt 11y agoYou're thinking of the double slit experiment
- Confusion 11y agoNo, I'm definitely thinking of the fact that observation inhibits change in a quantum system. I'm fairly certain I was taught this was the case and was experimentally verified. 'Long ago' here means ~20 years ago.
- igravious 11y agoIt says at the start of the article that it has already been experimentally confirmed for spin, this experiment confirms with respect to motion. I don't know when the spin one was done, maybe someone can provide more info. What I don't know is if the different quantum properties are independent of each other. If they are then presumably one would have to verify this Zeno effect on each property of a quantum particle. So maybe we can now say that the Zeno effect has been experimentally verified for two quantum properties now. Looked at this way you were both correct and incorrect. If spin and momentum are 'connected' in that if you experimentally verify some meta-property about one it verifies it for the other (such as, in this case, observing a property of a quantum particle freezes that particle) then this has been proved True and you were correct. Does this make sense? IANAQP.
- oceanofsolaris 11y agoYou can do this e.g. with photon polarization. Measuring here is very simple since it is achieved by sending your light through a linear polarizer. If you send light through a chiral medium, the orientation of the polarization would normally rotate. However if you measure the polarization often enough (by putting enough polar filters that are all oriented in the same direction in between), this rotation will not occur. This experiment is rather simple since you only need a standard optical bench and not any low temperature setup.
- hauget 11y agoSo I guess it's safe to hypothesize (for now) that when we're not conscious, we are in a quantum superposition?
- hauget 11y agoWhy the downvotes? Has no one read about the quantum mind theory? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_mind https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_mind
- yoha 11y agoDownvotes are sometimes harsh on HN. I think the majority of HNers perceives the Quantum Mind theory as described in this article: http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Quantum_consciousness http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Quantum_consciousness .
- hauget 11y agoYeah, also some people can't take a joke...
- _ZeD_ 11y agodon't blink
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoI really wish more science writers would explain what "observation" actually means. This article is better than most, but generally one leaves quantum-effect discussions with the impression that atoms can literally tell when a human brain is perceiving them, presumably through magic science brain waves.
- javert 11y agoWhen writing in English, unless the writer specifies otherwise, the word "observation" means what the dictionary says it does. The writer of this article is saying that the particles behave differently after being observed. Perhaps that is a lie. My point is, if it's a lie, let's call it a lie, not bad writing.
- criddell 11y agoI guess it depends on the presumed audience. As a layman, observation is a passive event. After reading through some of the comments, I can see that physicists have a different meaning for that word.
- fauigerzigerk 11y agoSometimes I feel that people writing about physics are having great fun with deliberately confusing people by making stuff sound magical and illogical. This particular effect has nothing to do with whether or not anyone is looking at an object. It's the methods of making it visible that cause the effect.
- gus_massa 11y agoI agree. I think that a big part of the problem is trying to make the new more layman friendly removing all the math. Quantum mechanics is unintuitive but the math is very clear, so "anyone" can get the same correct result for an experiment. When you remove the math, you keep only the unintuitive part. Another part of the problem is linkbait, making slightly wrong interpretations make more interesting articles. Sometimes there are a few articles from different news sites about some subject, and it's very common that the more misleading gets more attention here. Sadly, my rule of thumb is https://xkcd.com/1240/ https://xkcd.com/1240/ For an interesting explanation of what is happening here, I like the stack of slightly rotated polarizers. (See this comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10437289 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10437289 ) The math is equivalent, but the result is not linkbaity. You can even try it at home! If you think enough about it, it's completely weird, but the calculation are pretty straightforward.
- DyslexicAtheist 11y agocould swear I've had some debugging / system testing sessions where the effect of me looking into it changed its state :-)
- rybosome 11y agoWe call those "heisenbugs" - one of the most terrifying and maddening things you can encounter prior to a launch. I'm almost positive that I remember reading a sort from a game dev who ran into one of these right before a release, where printing some variable caused it to have the correct value; in this case, it was left in the game.
- 11y ago
- flak48 11y agoI'm curious as to how the scientists confirmed that tunneling was taking place when the atoms were not being illuminated. Does anyone know how this is typically done?
- gus_massa 11y agoI hope I understood your question correctly. It's very very very difficult to take a photograph to catch the atom while tunneling. The atoms in this experiment form a lattice, and the lattice acts a trap, so the atoms can be only in some fixed spots. To go from one spot to another spot, it has to have some minimal energy, so it's equivalent to climbing a hill to go from one valley to another valley. The atom usually get that energy by random movements, but in this experiment they are very cold, to avoid this possibility, so they are trapped in one of those spots. By quantum mechanics, they can travel from one spot to another spot without enough energy. This is equivalent to going from one valley to another valley without energy to climb the hill, so the tunneling nickname. The probability is something like exp(- distance * energy_difference * constants) so it's harder to go to a spot far away and it harder to pass a tall hill (I must be missing a the time variable there, look at Wikipedia for the exact expression.) And it's exponentially harder, not jut harder. To answer your question. It's very very very difficult to take a photographs of the atoms while tunneling. If you turn off the laser and you take a photograph from time to time, you see that some atoms jump randomly from one spot to another between photos while "no one" is watching :). If you turn on the laser, the "laser" is watching, so the atoms don't move between photographs. But don't expect to get a photograph of the atoms while tunneling. EDIT: after a coffee and a shower, I changed "impossible" to "very very very difficult"
- flak48 11y agoI re-read the article, and combined with your answer, it makes much more sense now. What was originally confusing me, was how the scientists were confirming the presence of tunneling when the laser was off. I was mistakenly assuming that they were using some special method to infer that tunneling was taking place. But of course they don't need to, like you said. The tunneling can be inferred from the change in positions of atoms in different photographs. They don't actually need to see the actual tunneling in-progress (even if it were somehow possible/not very difficult to do so). Makes sense. Thanks for that answer, it's very helpful for someone like me whose last brush with quantum physics was the physics/chemistry courses in year 1 of engineering. Cheers
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- laotzu 11y agoIs this not basically saying the same thing that is shown in the double slit experiment? Short video on the double slit experiment for the layman: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DfPeprQ7oGc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DfPeprQ7oGc
- ankurdhama 11y agoNatural languages have evolved around the human scale of things and humans actions on those things. When you try to describe nature using these concepts you will always get weird and unintuitive explanations.
- thesz 11y agoI guess that measurement introduces energy into the system and that is what keeps atoms in places. I haven't seen refutation of this in the article.