7 ms·
What boyfriends and girlfriends search for on Google
- btilly 17y agoI thought the obvious next version was interesting as well. It doesn't exactly paint a very nice picture of men. How can I get my husband to ...fall in love with me again ...be more affectionate ...love me again ...help around the house ...want me ...be more romantic ...lose weight ...talk to me ...leave the house ...stop drinking How can I get my wife to ...love me again ...swing ...lose weight ...shave ...trust me again ...love me ...shut up I assume that I got more common completions for the first than the second because women are more likely to use Google to seek advice.
- mrcharles 17y agoIf you pair the questions together, they solve themselves!
- btilly 17y agoI thought this was just a cute flippant answer until I went back and re-read both lists. The pairing isn't perfect, but it is surprisingly good.
- mrcharles 17y agoI'll admit, it's a tad sexist, but it's still good for a laugh.
- btilly 17y agoIt is hard to say anything true about relations between the sexes without being somewhat sexist. I think that's because nobody really likes the naked truth on that topic.
- joe_the_user 17y agoHow would you back up that assertion? Is true to say "most relationships could be improved by both people listening better?" Is it sexist?
- rw 17y agoWhat if they are not improved by doing that? What if women actually respond "better" to not being listened to? If that's (empirically) true, is that acceptable? I think the parents are asking how we can go about wrangling with gender roles, when maybe we're just programmed to be shitty to each other. It's not a secret that our social interactions are still hierarchical, as disgusting as that is.
- DomesticMouse 17y agoI believe the question is sexist. Boys like talking about things, girls like talking about people. So the "listening better" actually becomes "understanding an alien mindset." I feel that this fact actually makes the above question sexist, because the two sexes involved interpret the action "listening" to mean two completely different things.
- btilly 17y agoHere is a good example. Let me observe that both men and women don't just want to find someone of the opposite sex, they would like to be with someone who is as good as possible. When you are with a person who is as good as is possible for you to land, that person will be someone you have difficulty getting to be interested in you like you're interested in them. So, for instance, a man who dares say something moderately insulting to a woman early on establishes that he thinks that he could do better. If he does not offend her too badly and turns around and gives her some hope, that gives her the message that he's someone she has a chance at but has to work for. If she believes that message, she'll think of him as a good potential catch. Going the other way, a woman who doesn't feel compelled to return a man's calls promptly, puts off sex, and who insists from the start on time for herself is demonstrating that she believes she is a reach for him. If he believes her, then he is more likely to work to establish the relationship, including making the commitment to take care of her and help raise their children. (Which is what marriage is.) No man likes those games, but most of us respond to them. These parallel pieces of advice are both effective and offensive. You'll find the advice for men as part of the standard repertoire in virtually any guide for pickup artists. It is standard because experience shows that it helps get women in bed. Conversely the advice for women is straight from http://www.amazon.com/Rules-TM-Time-Tested-Secrets-Capturing/dp/0446518131/ref=pd_sim_b_3 http://www.amazon.com/Rules-TM-Time-Tested-Secrets-Capturing.... That is sort of a female counterpart to the pickup artists guide and is about how to land a man who will commit. The polarization of the reviews is evidence of both offensiveness and the gratitude of women who found the advice effective. (Read the reviews and you can verify the reasons for the votes.) So there is a concrete example for you. Landing someone of the opposite sex and getting them to do what we want them to do is of interest to the vast majority of us. (Yes, some people are gay or asexual, but the vast majority are straight heterosexuals.) Yet advice that is effective for that is quite offensive. And, of course, when we're offended by advice about the sexes, we usually call it sexist.
- nostrademons 17y agoThere's an opportunity here for an Answers-like service...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- louislouis 17y agowow, the unborn baby one is just wrong.
- acangiano 17y agoSorry louislouis, I deleted my comment before seeing your reply (I thought my comment wasn't adding too much to the discussion). The link he is referring to was this: http://grab.by/grabs/429941810f908a076dfd5a3a712f45fb.png http://grab.by/grabs/429941810f908a076dfd5a3a712f45fb.png
- ugh 17y agoExcept for the Sim and the cat the only one on the list that is legal. Just sayin’.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- leelin 17y agoIf you intersect the two sets, everyone wants to get back together or scheme up a George Costanza-like plan to have the partner be the one to initiate a breakup.
- pavel 17y agoThis is an amazing visualization which does the same exact thing http://hint.fm/seer/ http://hint.fm/seer/
- est 17y agodefault search results from French Google I guess?
- binarycheese 17y agohttp://i49.tinypic.com/nogciv.png http://i49.tinypic.com/nogciv.png
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- mahmud 17y agoYou know, this is the second story about Google auto-completion this week. The behavioural economists have jumped on the Ajaxian/ReadWriteWeb/SmashingMag bandwagon memes.
- telemachos 17y agoIs it me or is anyone else surprised that people use Google this way? I don't mean the content, I mean the kind of query. I generally type specific words or phrases (often with a 'site:' prefix when I know where I'm looking). I never type full questions (i.e., sentences) into Google. Edit: My wife reminded me that there was a New York Times article in December about how children search this way automatically: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/26/technology/internet/26kidsearch.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/26/technology/internet/26kids...
- sev 17y agoI've ran into the general public way too much to be surprised by such queries.
- shaddi 17y agoFirst, some people just search this way on a regular basis. Strange, but I've met several who do. Bless their hearts. Second, often for queries of this type I'd expect to find hits on advice sites, Yahoo Answers, etc, where the question is actually in the text of the page. Also, I would have trouble boiling down most of these questions to keywords...
- telemachos 17y ago> Also, I would have trouble boiling down most of these questions to keywords... Right, and fair enough. But to me that's a clue to the real answer: don't ask a search engine to solve your romantic issues.
- btilly 17y agoThe search engine won't solve them for you, but it likely gives non-specific advice that is better than what most of your friends will manage.
- dstorrs 17y agoThey [the people typing these questions] aren't. They are asking a search engine to connect them to people who have been in similar situations and might have advice.
- ugh 17y agoHey, works across cultures! The results in German are pretty much an exact mirror image. That would be cool if it weren’t so depressing.
- DrJokepu 17y agoI don't find it depressing at all. Men want a more active / interesting sexual life with their partner. Women want more bonding with their partner / want their partner to do stuff for them. It's nothing we haven't known for many millenia. Clearly there are a lot more into relationships but these are the most common "entry-level" problems and there's nothing wrong with that. People who have enough experience at human relationships (because they're old enough) won't use Google to solve their problems, don't you think?
- cakesy 17y agoAgree, this is not depressing at all. Maybe these people who think it is depressing should get out of their fantasy world, and start reading up on some biology.
- joe_the_user 17y agoActually, both partners want both. Perhaps there's a little more emphasis with women on the partner side but "last longer in bed" was also among the choices.
- ugh 17y agoNo, not depressing because of that. Depressing because my estimation of my fellow males is so far off. I always thought more highly of us :)
- ptn 17y agoYou can get a couple more if you drop the "to": How can I get my gf and How can I get my bf
- slig 17y agoHow can I get my parents works too.
- nostrademons 17y agoI had it autocomplete [how can i get my par] and most of them were sensible suggestions, until it got to [how can i get my parakeet to eat my diarrhea]. WTF?
- chris123 17y ago"Everyone thinks of changing the world [his or her girlfriend or buyfriend], but no one thinks of changing himself." --Leo Tolstoy
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- djb_hackernews 17y agobuyfriend? intentional, mistake, or Freudian?
- chris123 17y agoMistake, Freudian, or my dyslexia :)
- berlinbrown 17y agoTry wife and husband ... "how can i get my wife to shut up"
- silentbicycle 17y agoI'm guessing that one pairs with, "how can I get my husband to stop drinking"...
- joe-mccann 17y agoReading "Predictably Irrational" now and it is a truly fascinating book. This is a good laugh, but the book offers more useful data and insight.
- almost 17y agoIs anyone else a little disturbed that this has 121 points and is at the top of the HN frontpage? Maybe I'm just being grumpy but it seems like total fluff that's of no use to anyone. I'm surprised it hasn't been killed, are there no mods around today?
- kiba 17y agoWhy do you think it is fluff that is of no use to anyone. It is not like HNers aren't interested in girls.
- almost 17y agoSo you think it provides some insight into something or other? Not just a cheap laugh? It seems to me to be quite a long way from "anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity".
- Mz 17y agoThe article itself is fluff but it seems to have generated good discussion of how people search. If I upvote it, it will be to find the discussion again, not to give applause for the article. (Of course now that I have commented, I don't have to upvote it to find it. I can get to it via my comments. :) )
- smokinjuan 17y agoI just got an account today after lurking a few months and read the FAQ just after reading the "Built By Google" story. To poke fun at the FAQ "OMG HN is turning into reddit!!1!" It all ties together nicely from an AI standpoint though. Granted the material is generated by users, but isn't there a hint of AI to it? Look past what the user typed and rather how they're using the service. It's tech and it's a "hack."
- almost 17y agoI'm not sure I understand what you're saying in this comment.
- bdr 17y agoNote that this doesn't directly tell you what people want. It tells you what people want and aren't getting. For example, the fact that boyfriends don't search for "...love me" doesn't mean that they don't want to be loved; maybe they want to be loved but are loved enough.
- Herring 17y agoOr sex is generally how love is expressed for guys. for more sad/hilarious results, look up "how can i get my wife/husband.."
- jvdh 17y agoHilarious indeed, number 10 on the "How can I get my wife" list is "s facebook password"
- joe_the_user 17y agoActually, when I went to the Google box myself, "...love me" was on it.
- netcan 17y agoHow would you like it if poets coded, huh? http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/leonardcohen/youhavelovedenough.html http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/leonardcohen/youhavelovedenou...
- eof 17y agoI think it's fair to say if you have something, then you can't want it.
- PanMan 17y agoNice post, but I get different results: For the boys (girlfriends) : http://skitch.com/panman/nq5d5/google http://skitch.com/panman/nq5d5/google For the girls (boyfriends) : http://skitch.com/panman/nq5d2/google http://skitch.com/panman/nq5d2/google Seem to be bore in sync..
- j_baker 17y agoI'm surprised no one's pointed out the obvious. It's difficult to pull any interpretations out of this based on gender. Remember, there are girls who have girlfriends and boys who have boyfriends too.
- swombat 17y agoI wonder why the font on the middle line is slightly off... http://skitch.com/swombat/nqhn8 http://skitch.com/swombat/nqhn8
- timb 17y agoBecause OS X tries to compress letter spacing before cutting the line off. http://imgur.com/cyTjS.png http://imgur.com/cyTjS.png See what happens when I resize this window? The text gets squished before it gives up and shows the "..."
- swombat 17y agoWow, very interesting. Thanks for the explanation!
- binarycheese 17y agohttp://i49.tinypic.com/nogciv.png http://i49.tinypic.com/nogciv.png