8 ms·
Except that cows are pretty environmentally-unfriendly too. Sigh. There is no getting around the elephant in the living room: population. Either we control i
by lisper 11y ago
Except that cows are pretty environmentally-unfriendly too.
Sigh. There is no getting around the elephant in the living room: population. Either we control it, or the laws of physics will do it for us.
- bostonpete 11y ago> Except that cows are pretty environmentally-unfriendly too. Well, you can milk anything with nipples.
- alexggordon 11y agoI'd love to have an anatomy lesson on Almonds.
- gxs 11y agoI am by no means a mod or a anything, but what exactly do you think you were contributing to this conversation with this comment? I am genuinely curious. Was it an attempt at humor? Did you think it would be well received in a forum where conversation tends to be more serious and informative? Are you aware of the rules and just don't care? Or did you think this comment was especially funny and warranted an exception? Not trying to troll, and I know I'm putting you on the spot so to speak, but figured if it would be worth it if you answered the question seriously. And yes, I am aware of the irony that my post isn't especially contributing either.
- lmartel 11y agoIt's a real contribution. The parent poster is (humorously) making the point that if we really wanted to, we could switch to e.g. goat's milk because farming cows is particularly damaging to the environment. I understand where the pearl-clutching is coming from but I think you've overreacted to the word "nipple."
- bostonpete 11y ago> Did you think it would be well received in a forum where conversation tends to be more serious and informative? Yes, I guess I thought my light-hearted comment might be received the way it was intended. Even in a serious/informative setting it's OK to inject a little humor here or there. I really don't think HN is on the brink of devolving into pun threads if that's your concern. If people think a comment is an unwelcome addition to the conversation, downvotes will certainly get that point across. > Are you aware of the rules and just don't care? Yes, I'm familiar with the comment guidelines (which certainly don't ban humor) and I'm aware of the "unwritten" rule that HN will usually tolerate only a small amount of levity in comments.
- happyscrappy 11y agoI've got nipples Faulker.
- moonchrome 11y agoI hate this sort of regressive thinking. We can just come up with more reliable ways of producing food. I expect food production to see a huge revolution in 10-20 years - think something like genetically modified simple organisms that are designed to produce specific nutrients - like specific protein or sugar or fat. If you can design them to be energy efficient and work in low amount of space in a controlled environment (say a shallow pool of water + UV lamps or something like that) you can have huge factories that stack these "ponds" on top of each other working 24/7 pumping out nutrients. Then it's just a matter of combining them in to food.
- mathiasben 11y agoand after these advances have been outpaced by population growth what happens then?
- moonchrome 11y agoYou have even more people to deal with the new problems ? In general this entire mindset that there is "limited resources that we can't go beyond" is completely bogus and proven false over and over again - resources are just things that our knowledge/technology allows us to use to solve particular problems as we create new technology we grow potential resources. Oil was used as a folk remedy until we learned how to refine it. Earth becomes physically overpopulated - that's so far in to the future that you can count on realistically colonizing space by then. A realistic concern is if we can reach innovation fast enough to avoid "rough patches" but long term it's incredibly unlikely that we can't solve technical problems.
- Daishiman 11y agoUmm, no. I would like a planet that still has a semblance of uninhabited environments that are mostly unperturbed. Look at any satellite images of the amount of land that is being used by farming in the world. Those places used to be natural ecosystems that no longer exist. We have already started a mass extinction event from which the level of biodiversity we used to have is essentially unrecoverable.
- merah 11y agoThis. Having studied environmental and social science for 11 years, published and achieved multiple "degrees of knowledge" for a solid career base; it was so very sad and frustrating that everyone seemingly persisted to "talk" around the elephant. It drove me bonkers and was labelled a pessimist by my peers. I left academia 3 years ago and now travel the world, programming and documenting tropical flora and fauna. Best decision I ever made, pity it cost me £20,000 to arrive at it though.
- posnet 11y agoNeat, I bet you have some amazing photos.
- merah 11y agoI have a lot of really bad ones too :)
- Skunkleton 11y ago> travel the world, programming and documenting tropical flora and fauna. That is damned cool. Tell us more.
- merah 11y agoI stumbled into a niche that somehow combines both my passions: programming and nature. Started with a linux server I built in a jungle that ran off of an off-grid power source serving over wifi. Many, many months later (and after losing two laptops, two smartphones, two DSLRs and three GPS units to Zeus and a crocodile)... it's a platform that runs across three continents and some days I double-take what I've built (I have no CS qualifications). I do have to remind myself that it is indeed cool, as some days I just want to pack it all in as I often feel out of my depth. A few months ago I was pulling 20-hour days to "get shit done". I'm not adverse to partnering with the right person to take the strain, in fact I'd welcome it now, alas I'm yet to find someone with similar passions who's also comfortable slumming it in tropics and is confident in high-risk foreign areas. Waking up to a Tapir in a tropical monsoon is cool, gettin robbed at gun point by narcos whilst rebooting your VM, less so. Tequila and some venezuelan narcos, those were some good times.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> There is no getting around the elephant in the living room: population. Either we control it Fine, lets not talk around it. Bluntly, experience has shown that "population control" boils down to one of two things: (1) Strong and effective social security networks, which shift incentives and produce declines (often to negative levels) in natural population increase, or (2) Brutal authoritarian repression, extending (among other things) to either including or incentivizing outright slaughter.
- randyrand 11y agoWhat are you on about? How does social security reduce population? Citation very needed. I think you mean to say first world countries empirically grow slower. And why does population control need to be brutal? You don't need to kill living people, just don't birth unborn people. Have tax paid contraceptives, tax paid abortion for those that mess up, and tax/fine/jail people that have 3+ babies (having 2 babies per couple is sustainable). Maybe also have a baby making approval process. My home remodel needs to be approved, but I can make a new person without any approval whatsoever? That does't make sense. If you ignore the law, you go to jail. Your child will be adopted or raised in a foster home. Not killed.
- lisper 11y agoActually, making birth control readily available is extraordinarily effective. If people (particularly women) are given the means to control their reproduction they tend to take advantage of it.