6 ms·
Mission Motors didn't close because of Apple
- Animats 11y agoImagine what Steve Jobs would have done if someone "poached" three key engineers from the iPhone team before it shipped.
- ninv 11y agoThermonuclear War!!
- archmikhail 11y agoThis article is saying that was not the case. The company was failing already and so understandably the top talent went elsewhere, such as Apple.
- cwyers 11y agoProbably nothing nice. But I am not obligated to share Steve Jobs' ethics when judging Apple's actions here, and I really don't like the notion that an employee "belongs" to a company that isn't covered in that employee's contract (and even some contracts I think overstep what's legally permissable, not to mention "right.") If you want to keep an employee, you do it by valuing that employee properly, not by shaming competing offers for that employee.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoWouldn't that have been in the days of the 'no-poaching' regime?
- archmikhail 11y agoSo now who do you trust? This guy (whom I know nothing about) or the several media articles (whose writers and sources I know nothing about)? This is the problem with how news is delivered in our age. Back in the day, you primarily just knew the news of your town, and to verify the claims you could walk over to the subjects and ask them.
- kevinchen 11y agoNow that the cost of publishing has gone to nothing, you trust that someone who knows what they're talking about (e.g. Asphalt & Rubber) will eventually see a popular but incorrect story and write a correction. https://stratechery.com/2015/in-defense-of-the-new-york-times/ https://stratechery.com/2015/in-defense-of-the-new-york-time...
- ksherlock 11y agoYou should do some critical thinking and trust yourself.
- aresant 11y agoThe article author qualifies himself pretty well - he has broken multiple stories about Mission and was the first journalist to ever ride their prototype.
- hartator 11y agoI am pretty sure we have better access to information now than before.
- jkestner 11y agoMore signal, more noise.
- austenallred 11y agoThe problem is this: The person who wrote that article for Reuters didn't know anything about Mission Motors. The reporter had to hit her quota by mostly packaging up and rewording Apple press releases because she has to pump out n articles per day. Otherwise Reuters starts to lose money on her and she gets fired. Expertise and research take time, and therefore are expensive. Reuters can't afford to pay someone to have deep expertise. So she gets pitched on something and pushes it out without much thought, it gets some clicks, and no one cares. Almost every time I read a piece in the mainstream media about something I understand really well I'm baffled at how badly the press machine we've set up (and inexplicably trust) can butcher it. Then I think about that experience the next time I read about something I don't know much about. In the age of the Internet (with the monetization of the Internet) the structure of traditional news is fundamentally flawed.
- archmikhail 11y agoThis is exactly right. I had detailed knowledge of an acquisition and all media articles about it were so completely wrong that it was offensive.
- snowwrestler 11y agoIn the good old days, there were just a few news operations. Each had the resources and time to do thorough vetting and deep reporting of each story. Today, there has been an explosion of news outlets, but each one has little time or resources to do deep reporting. But because there are so many, they are highly incentivized to attack each other's stories, to gain traffic. I'm not sure that one way is worse than the other, from the audience perspective. Today's news cycle is in some ways more transparent--the first take goes public, then the fact check goes public, then the second take goes public, then the second fact check, etc. And it's all discussed in detail between anyone who's interested--like here on HN, or on Facebook, Twitter, blogs, etc. Let's call it a transition from a monolithic "wait until correct" model to a distributed "eventually correct" model. That said, it may be corrosive to the reputation of news operations in general, because they are so frequently publicly challenged and wrong.
- 11y ago
- yalogin 11y agoDoes it matter even if it closed down because of Apple? If a company is so weak that it cannot operate on losing a few employees, then isn't it the company's fault? It's even more a problem with the company given that it's a bull market for startups and funding.
- ghshephard 11y agoAlmost every great company has been in a position where losing just a few key employees would have killed it before it became large enough to sustain itself. I have a theory that a lot of companies become great because of the output of those absolutely superb (but not necessarily self-promoting) employees who create 95%+ of the intellectual output of the startup, while all the the credit goes to those who promote themselves. Snag those great employees, kill the company.