7 ms·
Their branding is horrifying. YouTube Red, Music Key, Google Android Play Music All Access Subscription, etc. Don't get me wrong, the actual service they prov
by Someone1234 11y ago
Their branding is horrifying.
YouTube Red, Music Key, Google Android Play Music All Access Subscription, etc.
Don't get me wrong, the actual service they provide is good, and Music Key (advert free YouTube music videos) was a nice value add. This too will only expand Music Key into other videos.
I do worry a little bit that long term Google Music subscribers will wind up seeing price increases to pay for YouTube Red. If all I want is JUST Google Music, then all I should have to pay for is JUST Google Music, and that is fine today as there are no price increases, but ask me again when the first price rise is announced a few months from now.
- abraham 11y agoWas horrifying. Now it's just YouTube Red and Google Play Music subscription.
- DominikR 11y agoBut aren't both the same?
- abraham 11y agoEssentially they are the same. Technically they are different but they include the other.
- mehta 11y agoWhy not make it simple for people and just use one name? How does the "technically different" part affect people?
- IshKebab 11y agoI suppose because it's clear what you get with those names.
- Someone1234 11y agoBut it isn't clear because "YouTube Red" is meaningless.
- giancarlostoro 11y agoWeren't they trying to divide YouTube from "Google" as well, this kind of doesn't help, but I would either have gone with YouTube Plus or Play Plus, seeing as others pointed out "Red" and "Tube" sounding awful together.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Weren't they trying to divide YouTube from "Google" as well, this kind of doesn't help It might, in the long term. The next step after expanding the services offered under Google Play Music subscription and adding a new name for it (without immediately disrupting anything) might well be retiring the old name, moving the whole audio/video streaming product area under the YouTube brand.
- abraham 11y agoSo was "Google" until they built up brand awareness.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Why not make it simple for people and just use one name? Because YouTube Red is a brand targeted at people who are using YouTube now and want it to be ad free. Google Play Music All Access is a side benefit for that audience. (Conversely, Google Play Music All Access is an existing product targeting people who want unlimited music streaming -- while the music use of YouTube is somewhat relevant to that audience, ad free YouTube viewing isn't a core benefit to that audience; so with the YouTube Red coming on board and including, and being included by, Google Play Music All Access, you've got one substantive product with two different brands targeted at different audiences.)
- kllrnohj 11y agoNo? YouTube Red is ad-free videos on youtube.com along with music videos. Play Music subscription is all access to music in play music. Also plenty of people don't realize/know/care that youtube is owned by Google. They are still a pretty independent brand from a consumer perspective.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> No? YouTube Red is ad-free videos on youtube.com along with music videos. Play Music subscription is all access to music in play music. "And as a special bonus - YouTube Red works with Google Play Music, so subscribe to one and automatically get access to the other." http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2015/10/red.html http://youtube-global.blogspot.com/2015/10/red.html So, they're different, but as each includes the other and they have the same $9.99 price, the difference is essentially purely academic.
- giarc 11y agoWhen I see YouTube Red, I think Bono is somehow involved.
- backwardm 11y agoI thought it was "red" for red band trailers.
- gaius 11y agoI thought they'd bought Redtube.
- audi100quattro 11y agoYep, maybe Bono has a trademark he can enforce? Seems like it was definitely a differentiated brand a while back which (YouTube)RED is now trying to piggyback on.
- bookwormAT 11y agoI agree with your point, but "Google Android Play Music All Access Subscription" is an exaggeration. It's "just" Google Play Music All Access.
- pfooti 11y agoGoogle Play Music All Access I'm Feeling Lucky Radio, on the other hand, is a thing. A thing to which I am listening right now, I should add.
- mtgx 11y agoAlso, if Youtube Red wants to become some kind of Netflix competitor down the line, expect even more draconian "anti-piracy" moves from Youtube/Google to please the MPAA (which you just know they are going to ask for them before they make any deal).
- SippinLean 11y agoI still can't get over Google Play Books
- FatalErrorr 11y agoWhat happened?
- Artistry121 11y agoI think this refers to the branding. Is google making an app for football and baseball teams to collaborate on playbooks?
- on_and_off 11y agoGoogle decided to rename Android Market to Google Play and along the way decided to rename the siblings apps as well : Google Play Movies Google Play Games Google Play Books
- eco 11y agoSimilarly, I can't believe the iOS App Store is still heavily under the iTunes umbrella (at least online, I don't really use iOS enough to know what the device experience is like).
- Synaesthesia 11y agoEh you can use an idevice without ever needing to launch iTunes on a PC.
- eco 11y agoReally I was speaking more of the website than iTunes itself. If you browse the App Store online it's all under the iTunes website (with plenty of iTunes branding thrown in). It makes no sense.
- HanyouHottie 11y agoThere's even worse now: Google Play For Work: https://support.google.com/googleplay/work/answer/6137711?hl=en https://support.google.com/googleplay/work/answer/6137711?hl...
- xbryanx 11y agoFor sure...when I think "video" and "red" I think of these guys: http://www.red.com/ http://www.red.com/
- biggc 11y agoWhen I think of "tube" and "red" the association is more unfortunate.
- markcerqueira 11y ago( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
- partiallypro 11y agoThat's almost more confusing than the old Microsoft's naming conventions. Which they still struggle with on somethings...but they are getting better.
- giancarlostoro 11y agoI still feel like I'm the only one who thinks Surface Book sounds awful. Microsoft could of done one of those things where they just call it what it is and put "Microsoft" in front of it, Microsoft Book, but Microsoft Surface Book, even just Surface Book sounds weird to me. Maybe it's just me though.
- toxican 11y agoOkay, I'll say it. When I see "Red" and "Tube" so close together, my mind jumps to the porn site, RedTube. They can't possibly have been ignorant of this
- thieving_magpie 11y agoWho's gonna be the one to bring that up in the branding meeting? "And we're thinking we'll call it Youtube Red" "Uh........... yknow that's... it's... i heard once that... nevermind".
- vinceguidry 11y agoI don't know how many marketers you know, but the ones I know would be perfectly comfortable bringing this up. It's kinda their job to know about this sort of thing.
- zipwitch 11y agoIt won't be a problem - Alphabet will just "make them an offer they can't refuse" and within a year, RedTube will re-direct to Youtube Red. (The offer being, let us buy your domain name for a reasonable price, or we'll sue you out of existence.)
- doingmyting 11y agoIf I go to Redtube and redirects me to youtube, you better know I am still doing my thing to all them videos. All of them haha!
- toxican 11y agolol on what grounds could Google possibly sue RedTube? They don't own the word "tube", which has been a reference to television since the beginning. I don't think you know what you're talking about.
- pen2l 11y agoMatt Cutts' wife used to pass out "porn cookies" if anyone found porn with safe settings on. Google's culture is very permitting, so I don't think it's much of a problem.
- kyrra 11y agoI believe Music Key at this point is dead (Youtube Red replaces it). Music Key was only ever in beta and not ever fully launched (as it was invite only). So as far as I'm aware there are only 2 music/video subscriptions now: Youtube Red and Google Play Music. * The opinions stated here are my own, not necessarily those of my company.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I believe Music Key at this point is dead (Youtube Red replaces it). Music Key was only ever in beta and not ever fully launched (as it was invite only). So as far as I'm aware there are only 2 music/video subscriptions now: Youtube Red and Google Play Music. Substantively, it seems that their is just one, with two different names: the announcement indicates that YouTube Red will include Google Play Music subscription, and vice versa, and the pricing is the same, so essentially there is one audio/video subscription service.
- guelo 11y agoDifferent websites on different urls with different giant Javascript application, also different mobile apps, and built by different Google business units. So two services.
- darklajid 11y agoYou mean like these Amazon Prime ("No shipping, please") subscribers that ended up either paying for ~other stuff~ or cancelling, like I did? I guess it makes sense to merge offers into one big 'You probably want some of this' bucket - for the company.
- sgustard 11y agoTubeRed also looks like it should be pronounced "toob-ered".
- vinceyuan 11y agoI still can't believe Google chose Play as the name of app market.