7 ms·
Top curling teams say they won't use high-tech brooms
- amelius 11y ago> We don't want the teams with the best technology and whoever sponsors who to win I applaud this, but I guess ultimately, either directly or indirectly, the sponsors still decide who is on a team. Or in other words, teams with more money will still be better teams.
- TheCapn 11y agoCurling is typically different in that regard I think. Every team I've known personally to go to national or world tournaments were lifelong friends. They grew as a team and there were no "trades" to suit a roster.
- colomon 11y agoWould the 2006 Gushue Olympic team be an exception to that? I'm sure Gushue knew Howard before Howard joined up, but they were from different generations and different provinces. (Not that, to the best of my knowledge, a sponsor had anything to do with that.)
- thefifthsetpin 11y agoThat's going to be a hard question to answer unless Gushue or Howard weigh in personally. I can say as a curler that the curling world is very small. If you want to curl against high-level players often, you need to travel regularly to high-level bonspiels where you meet a lot of the same curlers over and over again. It seems perfectly plausible to me that through curling they'd have gotten to know each other reasonably well.
- datapolitical 11y agoEntertainingly, I ended up at this match after watching the trials during a trip to Canada. Chatted with the team after the win. Had to look it up (http://www.amazon.com/Hurry-Hard-Russ-Howard-Story/dp/0470839554 http://www.amazon.com/Hurry-Hard-Russ-Howard-Story/dp/047083...) but in here Russ mentions how he got pulled in by the guys to help advise on shots. It was an unusual arrangement to say the least. They went through their lawyer, made a list of the top guys in Canada who could help, and Russ was at the top. The lawyer called, and he accepted.
- thefifthsetpin 11y agoThat doesn't hold in curling. Sponsors aren't putting together teams. Teams are self-assembling. Some of those teams then look for sponsors to offset their costs, but others don't even look for sponsors; the $ amounts are just so very small....
- rpledge 11y agoSo they're going to go back to corn husk brooms? Where do they draw the line?
- TheCraiggers 11y ago>Where do they draw the line? I'd say they just did. They're sticking with what they have now, and not using the newer, better technology. In most sports, there is an intersection of skill and technology. In order to keep things interesting, you typically want to increase the amount of skill required, and lower the amount of technology. However, there are times when that may sway one direction or the other- safety is an obvious exception to the above. There is no reason to insert fallacies; this is normal and has been going on as long as sports have existed. The only interesting thing here is that the top teams are taking a stand before the ruling body makes a declaration. That will still need to happen, but this will likely sway the decision made.
- igrekel 11y agoThere is that plus the fact that they say it seriously affects the ice for subsequent shots. Curlers are a bit obsessive about the ice, but then again it plays a big role.
- makomk 11y agoIf I'm reading the article correctly, they say that a version of the technology produced as a demo by a competing curling broom manufacturer that doesn't want it in the sport seriously affected the ice for subsequent shots. I don't think anyone's had that problem with the icePad version, which is the one that's actually for sale.
- rpledge 11y agoMy point about drawing a line is that it needs to be defined (i.e. you can't use a broom with coefficient of friction greater than X (for example, I claim not scientific basis on this)). Having top teams indicate they don't like a change is a good signal to the governing body that sets rules but other teams will use the technology if it is better. They can't just add a rule that says you can't use Brand X equipment - it has to declare limits on what the equipment is.
- pnut 11y agoIf it's allowed in the regulations, and they want to win, they will use it, end of story.
- drdeca 11y agoIf they want to win /more/ than they want to not use it.
- OldSchoolJohnny 11y agoYou clearly didn't read the story then.
- brudgers 11y agoThis seems a bit like wooden tennis rackets a few decades ago, though with a less mainstream sport the rules body may have more pull than manufacturers. But the bottom line is that sports change over time or die. Changes simply mean that a different set of skills come to the fore and others become less valuable.
- Retra 11y ago> sports change over time or die Why do you believe this?
- brudgers 11y agoBecause only things that no one cares about stay the same.
- Sanddancer 11y agoI can see where the OP is coming from, given that pretty much every sport has had rule changes like this. Baseball's changed the rules of the playing field, and rules of player behavior over time -- they've lowered the pitchers mound fairly steadily over the years as the average pitcher gets better, they set up rules for switch pitchers due to the first one hitting the bigs, etc. Soccer, they've changed offsides rules several time due to things like the offsides trap. Basketball, they added the three point shot, the shot clock, and changed the size of the key to get the game moving and keep it from turning into a slam dunk contest. Cricket has probably changed the least over the years, but even there, the types of matches that are played most often are a lot different than the kinds played nowadays.
- brudgers 11y agoEven cricket uses video replay extensively for officiating...at least at higher levels. The reason it is accepted is that it is consistent with the game's higher order values. What changes is mostly just an implementation detail that exists for historical reasons.
- jccalhoun 11y agoThere are a couple things going on with this story: One is the role of technology in sports which is really interesting. In other sports there is a lot of debate over what technology is allowed and what isn't. I would be really interested to see some things like how far someone could hit a golf ball if there were no restrictions on the club or ball or how fast a person could swim if there were no restrictions on the swimsuits. The second thing, however, is that the text of the story and the video have different focuses. The text focuses on telling the story of how this is a grassroots movement by some athletes. The video, however, seems to have a more pronounced undercurrent that this might really be about one company, BalancePlus, trying to put pressure against an upstart competitor, icePad, who is eating into their market share. I think it is really interesting that the text doesn't emphasize this as much as the video does.
- Someone 11y ago"or how fast a person could swim if there were no restrictions on the swimsuits." Define swim. If you don't, people will end up wearing a boat (the suits banned a few years ago started looking like them by providing floatation and being somewhat rigid) and having gloves on their legs and arms that resemble fins or paddles.
- mentat 11y agoThat is exactly the point. You're implying that the current definition (as interpreted by you) is the only possible meaningful definition. History shows this doesn't work out for all definitions.
- austenallred 11y agoI don't think he/she was. He/she was trying to explain how the technology is so advanced that it almost changes the very nature of what "swimming" is.
- mentat 11y agoDoes swimming have a nature? This may be a topic too deep for HN based on current down voting but there are substantial philosophical arguments not withstanding the historical one that such things do not have natures. The historical argument I think is pretty basic. Would people from a century ago recognize competitive swimming as swimming? How about 2 centuries ago? A millennium? When does the nature of swimming get fixed?
- mjpuser 11y agoWho gives a shit. This game blows.
- FatalLogic 11y agoThis can be seen as the incumbents uniting to keep out a disruptive technology that threatens to devalue their huge investment in skills.
- stevenheidel 11y agoFor those of you in the bay area who'd like to try out curling, we actually have a number of different leagues: bayareacurling.com
- willhsiung 11y agoOr anywhere in the US, check http://www.teamusa.org/usa-curling/clubs/find-a-club http://www.teamusa.org/usa-curling/clubs/find-a-club to find the nearest club to try the sport.