6 ms·
You can look at this from a slightly different angle: "...It is often said that “Youth is wasted on the young”. Based on my little spare time study, in this co
by ThomPete 11y ago
You can look at this from a slightly different angle:
"...It is often said that “Youth is wasted on the young”. Based on my little spare time study, in this context, it seems truer than ever.
The youth have all the energy and time to spend, no obligations and no financial worries. But they have very little life experience and exposure to these hidden problems. So what they end up solving are the kind of problems primarily young people have. This certainly makes for some very amazing products, but I can’t help feeling a little disillusioned. The amount of time and energy that goes into fun, but ultimately useless ideas, rather than fixing some of these hidden problems is mind-numbing.
On the other hand, the older generations are exposed (aware or unaware) to a lot of these hidden problems. They have experience on how to solve them because they understand them. Yet by that time, most of them have to provide for a family, pay of their mortgage, tuition fees, healthcare, yearly vacations and the 3 cars. They also often lack the imagination on how to solve things in a new technological paradigm.
So I now realized that there is a potential goldmine of problems we simply don’t know of, because the people who are exposed to them aren’t connected with the people who have the opportunity and creativity and energy to solve them. Which begs the question:
Are the old and young generations wildly underutilizing each other as resources?
..."
http://000fff.org/the-problem-with-problems http://000fff.org/the-problem-with-problems
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThat's... a pretty insightful observation. I suppose if you'd create a company that tried to exploit the comparative advantages of young and old staff, you'd face problems of leadership - who should run the show? The young, or the old? But I think it could be worth trying out in Hackerspace context. I'm adding to my TODO list to try and encourage some 50+ people to hang out in our space; maybe they could contribute some important problems and good insights that the regular young crowd could tackle with the energy we have. Thank you for sharing that quote.
- ThomPete 11y agoThanks. And yes there is all sorts of issues that could arise for sure. I have been thinking about ways to force out these hidden problems from people with more experience. Perhaps just doing a bunch of interviews and writing a book/blog about them. Another idea I have is to try make a podcast where we invite people in with experience from industries and then try and figure out what problems hide inside the organizations that we are not aware of. It all came from an ASK HN i did a while back where I asked "What problem in your industry is a potential startup" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9799007 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9799007 The answers there were mind-numbing to me cause it showed me how much insight is actually needed not just to solve a problem but also to find it to begin with.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> It all came from an ASK HN i did a while back where I asked "What problem in your industry is a potential startup" Oh, that was your thread. Then thanks again, for posting that. I remember it because I found it somehow only few days ago, and bookmarked after reading through. The anwser there were not what I expected, and they revealed a whole world of problems that are not obvious but very important and in need of solving. They reminded me of this old edw519's classic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1724198 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1724198 (Also check out http://static.v25media.com/edw519_mod.html http://static.v25media.com/edw519_mod.html if you haven't seen it before; edw519 has posted some incredibly insightful stuff over the years; one of the best programming reads I've ever seen.)
- ThomPete 11y agoYes it was quite amazing to get all that great feedback. I tried it on both Reddit and Quora but it didn't go so well could be timing could be that it's lacking the incredible varied backgrounds that HN after all have. And yes Ed519 always have some incredible insightful comments on of my favorite commenters.
- vkjv 11y agoI agreed with this up until this sentence. > They also often lack the imagination on how to solve things in a new technological paradigm. I think that they absolutely have the imagination, as well as the skill and experience, to solve these problems. What they lack is tolerance for risk.
- ThomPete 11y agoYeah I could have worded that better. The point I was just trying to make is that older generation might be caught up in certain ways of solving things, where as younger generations might come into it with a different paradigm in mind. I was trying to make a very specific point but I did that I guess poorly.
- wavefunction 11y agoThe young will often times "reinvent the wheel" not knowing that not only does the concept of a wheel exist, but many wheels before them have been manufactured. I know I have done this and as I have gotten to middle age I have seen younger developers do this as well.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoWheel reinvention is often futile but sometimes leads to brilliant new inventions. Also, their is an old adage about young scientists sometimes making major discoveries because they don't yet know what is impossible.
- wiremine 11y ago> exposure to these hidden problems I think this is a key to experience. I spent a large part of my 20s diving into problems and totally screwing up the solution. I learned a ton from this. On the flip side, maybe 50% of those problems don't exist anymore, because new technology or methodologies have solved them. Knowing how to use CVS or SVN doesn't really count for much in a world dominated by git. I think that's where I value a deep understanding of CS and core engineering practices, regardless of age. Understanding pointers, how to debug, and the difference of the heap vs. the stack hasn't changed much over the years.
- ThomPete 11y agoYeah the hidden problems I am talking about are less specific. Some of them are problems like workers unions standing in the way of automation of some shipping procedure or that people never thought about it as a problem but rather the cost of doing business. Technology definitely removes a lot of those barriers over time as you say. But there are still plenty of problems that aren't technological and perhaps those are the most interesting.
- wiremine 11y ago> But there are still plenty of problems that aren't technological and perhaps those are the most interesting. 100% agree. A lot of problems involve navigating a particular business domain or learning how to work with people.
- snomad 11y ago> Knowing how to use CVS or SVN doesn't really count for much in a world dominated by git. I don't understand the point you are tying to make. What has git so fundamentally changed that SVN/CVS don't count as knowledge / experience?
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoAdditionally, who says git is dominating? Here, on this forum, it has popularity. In industry its almost unknown. And guess which is the larger part of the world?
- MIKarlsen 11y agoI can agree with this on so many levels. As a student in a somewhat challenged branch of it, I often feel like me and my fellow students are "wasting" time on merely explaining theories, when in reality, a lot of us are very eager to get our hands dirty with something real. Universities have a limited amount of ressources which means that you're pretty much left alone to figure your entire study-plan out to yourself, including picking partners and/or cases for examns. While this is not at all impossible, I know for a fact that a lot of students around me are eager to participate in something that weighs a little heavier than their own interest in social media or gaming.
- ThomPete 11y agoYes thats my experience with a lot of young people too. So the question is whether there is some way to channel the experience of hacknat's father (see his comment) and make it available in a way that make sense to younger generations? Is it even possible to bridge or are we just left with the cold hard facts that these things only happens when they happens.
- hacknat 11y agoTo piggy-back of off this. The hidden problems aren't just extensions of old-age experience vs young-age experience (i.e. social-network vs hospice placement). It's often domain expertise vs none. There are so many older folks out there who have had decades of experience in one domain that none of us have even heard of, or are only, maybe, vaguely aware of. They are aware of that domain's problems, know most of the key players, etc. My father is a Director-level exec at a Fortune 100 company, and I've talked to him, ad nauseam, about the problems he wishes the enterprise line-of-business crapware his company keeps purchasing would actually solve. I keep trying to convince him to strike out and do something, and have even offered to go in on something with him, but he's just too comfortable. He has more than enough money, and he's decided to retire early if he doesn't get the next promotion he's gunning for. He was recently honored by the trade association of the domain he's an executive in (I guess there's no harm in saying it's logistics). I'm sure the contacts he has would send a startup hurtling into the stratosphere within a few years. How many people are like him out there, who are going to waste all their domain expertise on retirement or the next promotion? I feel like someone needs to write a manifesto to the older and successful among us about how they owe it to themselves and the younger generation to disrupt the industries they've been leading for so long. These fat-cat, lazy ass, companies just get to skate by on pure inertia.
- ThomPete 11y agoExactly! But they don't even need to be successful. Just the fact that they have spent years dabbling with something. A slightly absurd example of a way to surface this would be to do a kind of "retirement interview".
- basseq 11y agoIf he retires early, that's the perfect time to pull him into something entrepreneurial. When the viable alternative is "play golf", a stab in the dark looks a) more interesting and b) low risk (because you can always go play golf).
- dougmany 11y agoI think the role of fortune 100 companies is more to keep the lights on then disrupt. Disruption and new direction rely on a foundation of the current state. Yes that foundation will be replace, but only by the best of ten disruption that survived while its peers perished.