2 ms·
The anecdote is a bit unfortunate (it's easy to confidently declare that someone is incompetent after they've made a huge mistake), but the point is basically v
by timr 17y ago
The anecdote is a bit unfortunate (it's easy to confidently declare that someone is incompetent after they've made a huge mistake), but the point is basically valid: a small percentage of people have good taste that should be trusted above all else.
The problem is that most people don't have good taste, and those people nearly always have an inflated estimation of their own discriminatory ability. So at the end of the day, knowing that some teeny-tiny percentage of people is exceptionally gifted with good taste doesn't really help you much, because you can't reliably select for them in a group environment. And in my experience, the people with bad taste are almost certain to dominate any discussion, just by virtue of their overwhelming number.
I think the real lesson here is just one of those sad facts of life: if you work on a team that you haven't hand-selected, some of the people you work with are going to seem (or be) incompetent. Traditionally unspoken corollary: even if you selected the team, you might be incompetent.