5 ms·
http://cr.yp.to/im2000.html http://cr.yp.to/im2000.html Internet Mail 2000 IM2000 is a project to design a new Internet mail infrastructure around the followin
by nabla9 11y ago
http://cr.yp.to/im2000.html http://cr.yp.to/im2000.html
Internet Mail 2000
IM2000 is a project to design a new Internet mail infrastructure around the following concept: Mail storage is the sender's responsibility.
- ams6110 11y agoBecause spammers can't afford a couple of TB of disk space?
- tracker1 11y agoWhat do you mean? A single message/template sent to a million people would be a couple KB... only the ongoing operational costs of hosting the server... Beyond that, blacklisting would be more affective if there was a pull based email model.
- redahs 11y agoIf storage is the sender's responsibility, then there would most likely be no reason for recipients to ever bother downloading unsolicited messages from addresses originating outside of their web of trust in the first place. You could push spam blocking to the end user and client, and simply let them not download messages originating from unknown origins (similar to phone + Caller ID), without having to worry about dealing with spam in a centralized manner.
- jodrellblank 11y agoIf storage is the sender's responsibility, then not only can they potentially get some of your attention, but also your location, what kind of device(s) you use to get email, when you're active, and precisely what kind of content is enticing you to click and what isn't. A very tight feedback loop for generating content that will trick you, and hosting it for just long enough to see if it works.
- jwatte 11y agoThe problem is not the few kilobytes of body. The problem is the slot that the notification takes up in my inbox and attention, which IM2000 does nothing to solve.
- redahs 11y agoWell none of this is happening unless we are using a new mail protocol, and if we are using a new protocol we might as well throw in the kitchen sink and give you a new mail transfer agent and mail client application as well. And in the new application: Address == Public Key, Address book == web of trust. Your mail agent probably doesn't even bother to check or propagate incoming message notifications from addresses you haven't manually added to your address book (100% trust), or addresses within a certain number of hops from someone you manually added to your address book (friends of friend, boss's employees, etc.). And the mail client could further hide and ignore all of the notifications from below a certain user customizable trust score as well.
- nabla9 11y agoSpammers using botnets could not use hit and run tactics. Spammer would need reliable server that stays up long time and receive requests. One way to fight spam would be to actually retrieve it and throw it into trash. It would be equal to DOS-attack. There would be more time to determine if the message is spam. If enough people mark it as spam and site is blacklisted or taken down, spam would be removed from everyone.
- lsc 11y agoBernstein is an incredibly smart guy. But he's also an example of how the social stuff matters. His software would run the internet if he put a little more effort into the social/political side of things. The big problem with IM2000 is that it doesn't solve the real problems. It's focused on the economics of storage of mail, which, yeah, are a thing for a few mail administrators, but generally is considered less important than the spam-filtering problem in general. I mean, I'm not willing to pay for infinite storage, but I certainly would be willing to pay the cost of receiving 100x my current monthly spam load if I didn't have to read any of it. Maybe even 1000x. The major benefit of the IM2000 standard is that if you can squash the spammer's mail servers, you squash the mail in question, which actually could change things, because it would mean that spammers would need to control the servers they use to send for longer than they do now.
- staunch 11y ago> ... because it would mean that spammers would need to control the servers they use to send for longer than they do now. This is the reason IM2000 is exciting. Spammers only survive using hit and run tactics. We might see a 99% reduction in total generated spam.
- lsc 11y agoReally? More than 99% of the junk email in my box is from "legitimate" senders who use their own mailservers. The truth of the matter is that it's already pretty easy to block the hit and run spammers. Most of the junk that gets through is sent by people with the resources to bully the spamfilters into accepting it.
- staunch 11y agoSpam is viagra ads and the like (unsolicited commercial email). Promotional emails from companies you have a relationship with are a different thing. Users should be able to easily filter and ignore promotional email, but email hosting companies should never block it as spam. SMTP is not where email organization should happen. That's what email clients are for. Blocking DoS attacks and spam makes sense. Blocking Amazon Kindle promotions does not.
- rndn 11y agoIn wich ways is this different and superior to a fee?
- username223 11y agoPeople have tried and failed with fee-based email before (e.g. HashCash). I do wonder if the postal service could do something here: every citizen has an address, people pay some pittance to deliver mail to that address, and it's a federal crime to tamper with that email. Physical junk mail is annoying, but nowhere near as bad as spam.
- redahs 11y agoIf mail storage is the sender's responsibility, then perhaps senders should be allowed to seed their outgoing messages directly from their personal and home devices, and rely on others who have included their identity in their web-of-trust\address-book to propagate notifications of changes to their outbox, without relying on their ISP to do so. If the sender did not have at least one personal device connected to the internet 24/7, then they can perhaps purchase storage and bandwidth from a competitive online market, similar to the seedbox market for torrents, without surrendering their online identity or address to a commercial entity.
- david_ar 11y agoIt would probably be possible to build a system like this on top of https://ipfs.io/ https://ipfs.io/, see https://github.com/ipfs/apps/issues/10 https://github.com/ipfs/apps/issues/10 for example
- kodablah 11y agoThis is also the crux of the streams concept [1][2] posted here a few months back. I have even started an implementation as a side project. 1 - http://tonsky.me/blog/streams/ http://tonsky.me/blog/streams/ 2 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9829614 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9829614
- brongondwana 11y agoAnything which loses immutability loses in my book. Once I get an email it's my own copy, and it never goes away. How I'm reading im2000, the sender can retract or change the message, because they have the copy. I guess if I marked every message as "keep a copy for me" as soon as I read it, it would be OK - hard to do that while not having to read spam just in case I want to keep a copy though.
- Too 11y agoDetecting moifications can be solved with a hash or signature of the message that is sent out and always kept by the recipient. Doesn't solve the retracting though, or the social aspects of what to do if you actually detect a hash mismatch.
- qznc 11y agoIM2000 is a good idea. However, I would propose at least one additional idea [0]: Linked attachments. That should drastically reduce storage space in a corporate environment. [0] http://beza1e1.tuxen.de/articles/better_email.html http://beza1e1.tuxen.de/articles/better_email.html