4 ms·
For years I've wondered why North America doesn't have more diesels like the majority of the rest of the world. Then articles like this come along, and it's ha
by grecy 11y ago
For years I've wondered why North America doesn't have more diesels like the majority of the rest of the world.
Then articles like this come along, and it's hard for me not to think there is a coordinated smear campaign against diesel.
I have to imagine big money is involved, though I don't know. Does anyone else feel the same way or have any input?
- kosmic_k 11y agoNo. The air quality of paris for example is notoriously terrible, with many instances of worse air quality than Beijing. For a environmentally conscious and highly regulated nation that is an absolute disaster. Diesel has been linked to producing more byproducts that are responsible for smog than gasoline. If anything this has all been a long well funded war by european car manufactures to push locally produced diesel vehicles which appear to have better efficiency than gasoline. France was swept by the trend and now is regretting the fact that >60% of their cars are diesel powered. Simply put this was all a tragedy of choosing wrong metrics. Europe chose CO2 levels as the important metric to try to reduce. By optimizing for CO2 they allowed vehicles that produced 4 times more NO2 and up to 22 times more other fine particulates which are significantly worse for human health. Gasoline or Diesel, we still are damaging our environment. It's just with Diesel we see more of that damage done on ourselves. Edit: And just as a final point, the US alone has spent $51 million for "green diesel" VW cars. Now we know.
- srtjstjsj 11y ago$51million or $51billion? $51million isn't worth mentioning.
- hokkos 11y agoYour comment about Paris / Beijing air quality is misleading, here is an article and graphs about that : http://www.francetvinfo.fr/monde/asie/pollution-en-chine/pollution-jeudi-l-air-de-paris-etait-plus-pollue-que-celui-de-pekin_552085.html http://www.francetvinfo.fr/monde/asie/pollution-en-chine/pol... It is a one time event where the worst air quality passed over Beijing's when it was at its best.
- pjc50 11y agoBig money is involved, but in the other direction: it seems that diesel was promoted on the basis of overstated environmental benefits.
- digi_owl 11y agoThe talk was that you could make diesel out of just about anything, the classic example being old cooking oil. That, in combo with the lower fuel consumption, was presented as a way to ween the world off oil. Then came the whole NOx issue...
- Nelson69 11y agoIt's not a simple trade off. That's the problem, it's multi-dimensional. Diesel tends to be better at providing a satisfying driving experience with really high mileage. Better mileage means less CO2. Diesel also tends to emit particulates and trace elements in the oil that it combusts. That means more smog, "acid rain," etc.. If you have to pick one axis, "acid rain" is out of vogue and CO2 isn't and diesel looks like a clear winner and you wonder why every car isn't one. If you pay attention to both axis then diesel starts to dramatically lose its advantage and you really have to use some exotic cleanup technologies just to keep it in the same league as gas engines. I really don't know if there is big money involved, so much as just too simple a view of the problems. It's not like "clean coal" they both use effectively the same fuel that's just refined differently.
- burnte 11y agoI haven't driven diesels much, but have driven gasoline cars all of my life. How is the diesel "driving experience" better?
- mikestew 11y agoI take it to mean that for a high MPG vehicle, a diesel offers the better driving experience. A 50 MPG gas car won't get out of its own way. Take fuel mileage out of the equation, though, and IMO diesels suck to drive. You drive one strictly for the mileage benefit (or arguably torque if you're towing something).
- digi_owl 11y agoMy parents picked up a diesel years back after having driven gasoline only for decades. Their first road trip to a destination we visit regularly surprised us all. While with a gasoline car we would need at least one refueling stop each way, the diesel managed both direction, and a bit of back and forth while there, on a single tank.
- grecy 11y ago> IMO diesels suck to drive Have you driven a new one in the last 5ish years? Driving anything coming out of Germany that is less than 5 years old is a massive improvement over a gasoline car. Sit on 70mph, uphill, still in top gear doing low rpm and you can easily accelerate past all the gas cars that are dropping down gears, revving through the roof and slowing down. Off the line, you are pushed back in your seat right off idle, rather than waiting until you're up above 3k rpm in a gasoline car.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoIn America, diesel is traditionally for trucks. And wrt ( pickup ) trucks, my uncles ran farms, and unless they were hauling something, they'd take the car to town. That was like putting on a clean shirt. People were too poor to have cars but they needed a pickup to work the farm. So if you had a car...
- car 11y agoThe strict Diesel emissions standards for passenger vehicles in North America are presumably an anti-competitive measure. US car makers have been notoriously behind in Diesel technology.
- happyscrappy 11y agoEuropeans will deny anything is wrong with diesels right up until their air pollution crisis forces action.