3 ms·
Then it seems that MPs might need to start deploying and using crypto in their everyday work All MPs official business should be a matter of open, transparent
by onion2k 11y ago
Then it seems that MPs might need to start deploying and using crypto in their everyday work
All MPs official business should be a matter of open, transparent public record. Nothing they do as part of their every day work should be encrypted or private. The singular exception should be matters of national security, and even then their communications should be recorded in a secure manner with full accountability under the law if there's any suspicion of wrongdoing (e.g. lying to parliament about another countries WMDs).
Public office should be public.
- rmc 11y agoImagine you are a whistleblower and want to leak data to the public. UK Libel and defamation law doesn't apply to things MPs say in the House, and MPs can much easier get press attention than some random blogger. Hence it makes sense to work with a sympatheic MP to get the information into the public sphere. In this sense, the MP is acting more like a journalist with a source. The source should be protected.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoWhy the convention is that constituents have the same privacy they would with their lawyer / doctor. Would you raise issues with your representative if the tabloid press could harvest it and selectively quote you to monster you.
- onion2k 11y agoYou're suggesting that MPs should be able to conduct business in secret in case the tabloid press lie about someone. Have you ever heard the phrase '2 wrongs don't make a right'?
- JupiterMoon 11y agoNo she's stating that there is a long-standing convention that constituents are able to contact their MP in confidence and that this communication should be kept private to protect the constituent rather than the MP.
- rwmj 11y agoThere's a big difference between the power of a newspaper and the power of a constituent.
- vidarh 11y agoNo, he's suggesting that MPs should be able to conduct business in secret because portions of the public have concerns that they have good reason to raise with an MP yet where even the mere knowledge of the basics of the conversation might negatively affect their lives. E.g. lets say a drug addict who has successfully managed hid their addiction wants to offer their perspective of new drug legislation to their MP. Or a paedophile who wants to gather support for promising treatment option. Or someone with family or community ties to extremists of some shade or the other wants to propose ways of reducing their influence. There are a multitude of situations where there might be bad fallout from public knowledge about what a persons raises with their MP even if what they raised is positive for the wider community. Yes, secrecy also allows for negative effects, but it's not nearly as simple as just writing off the benefits of being able to guarantee privacy.
- astazangasta 11y agoAnonymity does not require secrecy. See Reddit, 4chan, etc: open, anonymous communication.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoErr this is about a constituant talking to their MP you can not not anonymously lobby and MP
- astazangasta 11y agoWhy not? Lobby your MP, have identifying details removed from the public record. We do it with all sorts of records with confidential or secret details.
- JupiterMoon 11y agoPartly because of the rule that MPs are only supposed to deal with their own constituents. Therefore they require your name and address on communications...
- 11y ago
- pjc50 11y agoPolitical parties need to have their own private communications in order to function; it's impossible to do strategy if you can't conceal your hand even slightly. Treatment of constituents issues needs to be private as these are often sensitive and personal (housing, family law and benefits issues). Official business should be on the record. In part the Alistair Carmichael trial is about the boundary between political and official.
- unethical_ban 11y agoAbsolutely not. Things that one may argue should be public: Financial backing of legislators, minutes of official meetings and hearings, votes, legal arguments for spying, and so on. But the conversations occurring behind the scenes which ALWAYS facilitate dealmaking will never be public. It wil happen in backrooms of pubs if you insist they communicate via telnet.
- derefr 11y agoWhat will happen if you insist they wear a 24hr body-cam? (Not that this would ever go through, but imagine it.)