5 ms·
Saw the headline assumed that it was an overstatement and that reading the article would show that someone just give someone else a little shove or something.
by MBCook 11y ago
Saw the headline assumed that it was an overstatement and that reading the article would show that someone just give someone else a little shove or something. After all this is on Teslas website, so you'd expect them to portray the situation the way they want it to be seen.
Turns out the title isn't sensational, it probably should be something like "newspaper employees attempt to run over Tesla security guards". They actually UNDERPLAYED it.
Did this make any kind of national news? Seems like a pretty good store that you'd expect the media to be repeating.
Wow.
- thoman23 11y agoWow indeed. Not once, but twice, intentionally ramming their Jeep into some poor employee. That's sociopathic.
- kafkaesq 11y agoThere's no evidence the ramming was intentional.
- Natsu 11y agoThat's not quite accurate: there were two separate instances where they hit someone with their jeep. Neither account disputes that part of the story. We can reasonably say that the credibility of the accident theory goes down the more accidents one has in a short period of time. That's not to say it couldn't have been an accident, but the very fact that there were two separate incidents is weak evidence against the claim of it being an accident. The bigger problem, though, is that the driver used deadly force to attempt to escape and nobody alleges that Tesla's guards caused any injuries at all to the reporters. The closest allegation is that there was damage to their jeep.
- ethbro 11y agoFrom the RGJ story (http://www.rgj.com/story/news/2015/10/09/rgj-photographer-arrested-after-altercation-withtesla-security-guards/73693850/ http://www.rgj.com/story/news/2015/10/09/rgj-photographer-ar...): "The newspaper’s vehicle was damaged in the altercation. A rock had been used to shatter the driver’s-side window and the driver’s-side seat belt had been cut in half. [Storey County Sheriff] Antinoro said he couldn’t confirm how that damage occurred." To be fair, if I tried to run over someone, I'd expect them to be less than pleased...
- ps4fanboy 11y agoIf the rock and seat belt incident had happened before you would expect RGJ to be saying as much as it would make them look less culpable so it stands to reason it happened after.
- TheCowboy 11y agoIt also stands to reason that they do not know, and no other papers have been able to confirm it that I could find. I'd expect it to make the most legal sense for Tesla to avoid posting this, if it is in fact true, until the case has been prosecuted. (I am not a lawyer.) While I like Tesla, it seems like one of those situations where it is best to take a statement like this with a grain of salt until more information is released by a party other than Tesla. I do find it surprising that most people here aren't more skeptical since it feels like something is missing.
- resu_nimda 11y agoIt's at least partly because Tesla has built up a reputation for being pretty honest and accurate, and not wildly misrepresenting the facts. Tesla has a lot more to lose here than the RGJ, boldly making false accusations seems like the kind of thing that would turn a minor blip into a PR disaster, and that's not really their style (but of course that's just speculation). I would expect the RGJ to defend themselves and their guy a bit more, if they had reason to (since the Tesla post is pretty damning), but perhaps they are waiting for more information. Time will tell.
- MBCook 11y ago> I'd expect it to make the most legal sense for Tesla to avoid posting this, If they only include basic data that's in the police report I imagine it can't be too bad. You've got to imagine they've got this all on CCTV anyway.
- kafkaesq 11y agoIt probably should be something like "newspaper employees attempt to run over Tesla security guards". "Run over"? The Tesla statement asserts they "accelerated into" the victims in both cases. Which is pretty nasty, but quite different from "running them over." You can't even infer that it was an "attempt" to run over the persons who were struck, from the information given. Most likely the driver simply panicked, and was trying to make some crazy Y turn to get the hell out of there -- without of course slowing down to look at who might have been in front of, or behind him. Not that that's any excuse. The driver's actions appear to have been highly reckless, to say the least. But there's no point in playing this episode up into something that it wasn't.
- Natsu 11y agoThey did injure at least two people with a car and one of them was while reversing. Because you normally don't accelerate while reversing, I think it will be hard for them to call this an accident if the physical evidence corroborates Tesla's version of the story. If it were just one person, I'd be more inclined to claim it was purely accidental. Once there were two separate incidents where they hit someone, the claim of it being an accident gets less credible. I can believe that they might have been afraid, but attacking someone with a car is deadly force (as is confirmed by the charges). So, at minimum, they'd have to show that the Tesla guards were trying to kill them or inflict grievous bodily harm. The fact that they did not allege any injury to themselves is going to really hurt their case unless they have some kind of evidence that they reasonably feared for their lives. I'll reserve judgement until we hear more facts, but the uncontested parts of the story currently indicate that the driver is in big trouble. If new facts or evidence do not come to light, I would reasonable expect them to go to prison, barring a plea deal. The passenger is probably ok, though, other than trespass.
- kafkaesq 11y agoTo address your responses collectively: (1) "You normally don't accelerate while reversing" sounds odd to my ears: from my understanding of physics, one has to accelerate in the initial stages of moving either forward or backward. (2) The first person was struck while recording the the car's license number (i.e. from behind the car); this increases the chance that the driver didn't see them. The second person was struck while "approaching" the car; also increasing the chance that the driver didn't see him. (As opposed to say: standing ahead and at a safe distance from the car, firmly and without moving, gesturing the driver to stop). (3) "At minimum, they'd have to show that the Tesla guards were trying to kill them or inflict grievous bodily harm." -- No, they just have to say "We thought we'd be caught, and our careers would be ruined -- so we panicked. We beg our victims for forgiveness, and we beg the court for forbearance and mercy." (4) I'm certainly not positing that this was an "accident" (let alone "purely accidental"). My reading is that it was most likely an incident of reckless driving, triggered by the fact that the reporters knew they were caught red-handed, and were desperate to escape (and quite likely simply panicking). And one can easily imagine scenarios where (in their haste) they simply didn't see either of the 2 persons -- one of whom was approaching the car; the other who was standing behind; both perhaps from skew angles. We both agree that the driver's behavior was at least criminally negligent. I just don't see a need to introduce a narrative in which the driver intentionally or even knowingly struck either of the victims -- when the facts at hand do not, beyond a reasonable degree of doubt, support such an interpretation.
- Steko 11y agoI think Tesla's entire account sounded like the truth washed with as much bias and bullshit as their legal department could get away with. I'm not trying to excuse the actions of the RGJ employees here, they should be prosecuted appropriately for both crimes. > As the Tesla employee attempted to record the license plate number on the rear bumper, the driver put it in reverse and accelerated into the Tesla employee I'd suggest it's more likely that reversing out was required to leave and the security officer moved behind primarily to stop them from leaving. Again it's still illegal to drive over human beings but it can also be a nearly simultaneous thing not necessarily a premeditated and psychotic choice on the part of the driver. > As the RGJ employees fled the scene, their Jeep struck the ATV that carried the two safety managers. Wait I thought he was on the ground bleeding out from his multiple 2-3" lacerations? Is it also possible that the ATV struck the jeep or drove in front on the jeep and caused the collision because the security wanted to detain them? Perhaps the ATV catching up to a fleeing jeep was not engaging in the safest behavior? > When one of the safety managers dismounted the ATV and approached the Jeep, the driver of the Jeep accelerated into him, striking him in the waist. I'm sorry this reminds me too much of dozens of police reports of "driver tried to run over officer, officer forced to use his gun" which is sometimes true but it far too many cases turns out to be complete bullshit. Again I don't want to apologize for the illegal and dangerous actions of the RGJ employees here but (1) this isn't the whole story and (2) I think it's absolutely ridiculous that Tesla has their secur-- err "safety" staff heading people off at the pass in ATV's and risking their lives over some illegal photos. It's also possible that my skepticism is misplaced and Tesla is not exaggerating here and RGJ employees engaged in exactly the behavior described.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago>> As the RGJ employees fled the scene, their Jeep struck the ATV that carried the two safety managers. > Wait I thought he was on the ground bleeding out from his multiple 2-3" lacerations? How about: one officer down, other inside the ATV which was parked, maybe or maybe not blocking off the jeep? > I'm sorry this reminds me too much of dozens of police reports of "driver tried to run over officer, officer forced to use his gun". Except here it's the officers who got hurt. Damage was pretty one-directional. I guess I trust Tesla on this one so far - they have pretty much a perfect record of being honest-to-God and fair, which is quite unusual as companies go. Definitely not trusting the journalists though. Ultimately, we'll see how this plays out in court. Also, I wonder what Elon has to say about it. He also has a track record of being honest, so this would be a good data point.