3 ms·
>England annexed Wales, so there must have been a country to annex. // I don't think that's true, the premise is false. There wasn't a country to annex, there
by pbhjpbhj 11y ago
>England annexed Wales, so there must have been a country to annex. //
I don't think that's true, the premise is false.
There wasn't a country to annex, there was a loose amalgamation of forces fighting under Gwynedd (from what I can tell), because Gwynedd had recently subdued those areas by force. Those areas hadn't been annexed in to a collective country with a single ruler, just like Gwynedd when it paid fealty to the English crown wasn't yet annexed. Alongside that some regions were already in effective possession of the English crown, and some few maybe were neither under Llywellyn's nor John's boot yet [I've not figured that out quite yet in my research].
[...cut for size...]
>So, the question is in fact: Wales was once a country, got gobbled up and is slowly regaining some independence. //
I think this is a nationalist misdirection. To recapitulate - Deheurbath and Gwynedd always seemed to be at odds, never united in to a common cause or stably under a common leader, nor common rule of law after the Romans, until they both came under the English Crown (just as it was in [the rest of] England). Wales was arguably a country - a single kingdom - for a very brief time but the people of the different kingdoms went their separate ways at the earliest opportunity. These separate kingdoms then got gobbled up, just like the separate Anglo-Saxon kingdoms were gobbled up by Wessex. Unless you consider Kent to have been a country in 1900, say, I can't see how you can consider Wales to have been one then either.
I think you're right that since the WAG was established Wales has had some claim to being a "country" but there seems a stronger claim that it's counties, like those of the rest of England are still a part of the country that is the dominion of the English Crown.
There has certainly been an effort in the last 80 years or so, since the Council for Wales was created, to make a new country: I'm certainly happy to go along with the WAG being a strong weight in favour of calling Wales a country.
It's strange to me that in the UK we had a great Welsh ruler of an historic Welsh line who ruled over all over England [aka "England and Wales"] as a unit, yet many in Wales instead want to look back to the time when the Wales was critically divided between two great powers and when it was most common for Cymry to be killing one another; a brief period that ended with Welsh killing their "own" king [Gruffydd ap Llewellyn].
It strikes me that had Henry VIII chosen a new name for the "land of the Angles", perhaps Cymru, then those who imagine they descend from the Celtic Cymry would have no complaint and would take full part in being citizens of that country. I wonder how getting access to genetic markers will, in the near future, change people's ideas of national identity - if people discover they descend from the invading Irish, Scots, Vikings, Romans, Angles, Jutes or some other group rather than the "native" Celts will they consider themselves less Welsh? More British?
Thanks for challenging my arguments and for walking through this with me, happy to get more responses to this if you have them.