10 ms·
Kilogram conflict resolved at last
- MarcusP 11y agoAre metric measurements all derived from the value 1kg? If so, does this mean that the entire metric weight range can now be officially based on mathematics?
- markild 11y agoThere are seven so called "base units" defined in the SI; meter, second, mol, ampere, kelvin, candela and kilogram [1]. Of these, mole and kilogram are dependent of the kilogram. edit: this is a good, if maybe a bit misleading, illustration: http://www.nist.gov/pml/wmd/metric/upload/SI_Diagram_Color_April_2008-2.pdf http://www.nist.gov/pml/wmd/metric/upload/SI_Diagram_Color_A... [1]: http://www.nist.gov/pml/wmd/metric/si-units.cfm http://www.nist.gov/pml/wmd/metric/si-units.cfm
- delecti 11y ago> Of these, mole and kilogram are dependent of the kilogram. Did you make a typo? While it's technically true that the kilogram is defined by the definition of the kilogram, I just wanted to make sure.
- markild 11y agoNot a typo, but maybe a bit vague. I meant to say that the SI units both are dependant on the real world kilogram object.
- jessaustin 11y agoThe NIST chart is interesting. I'm surprised that charge is defined in terms of current, rather than the other way around.
- tomp 11y agoNo, at least second and meter are defined with math and elementary physics (e.g. second is the time it takes for a specific atom to oscilate a specific number of times).
- fanf2 11y agoNot the atom, the electromagnetic radiation emitted by a specific quantum transition of the atom. (Cs 133 and 9192631770 Hz)
- sklogic 11y agoIn a (much more rational than SI) system "h=c=1" there is only one fundamental unit left - kg (or ev, which still depend on a kg definition). So getting rid of kilogram is absolutely essential.
- dalke 11y agoMore completely, ħ = c = G = kB = ke = 1. That system is mostly irrelevant for cultural and legal purposes. Even in the specific philosophical framework where getting rid of the kilogram 'absolutely essential', the current importance of the kilogram would simply migrate to the importance of the specific conversion factor to traditional units.
- pantalaimon 11y agofor everyday applications you can assume that 1kg = 1l H2O = 1dm³ if that's what you mean.
- smegger001 11y agoWouldn't that change though based upon the isotopes of the atoms in it? For example H2O made with Deuterium (1 proton 1 neutron and 1 electron) or Tritium (1 proton 2 neutrons and one electron) vs Protium (1 proton 1 neutrons and 1 electron), could all give different weights, not to mention different isotopes of oxygen 16 17 and 18 for the most common/long lived.
- 78666cdc 11y agoHence "everyday applications."
- tinkerdol 11y agoReminds me of this movie: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5dPnFO_JCdc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5dPnFO_JCdc (haven't seen it, but it looks interesting)
- jakeogh 11y agosilicon-28 sphere(s?): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMByI4s-D-Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMByI4s-D-Y (yep, they let him palm it) watt balance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VlJSwb4i_uQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VlJSwb4i_uQ
- jahnu 11y agoSurprised that the cotton gloves or particles that might float onto them or be coughed or breathed onto them aren't abrasive.
- unwind 11y agoDuplicate, very close in time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10385743 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10385743.
- Asbostos 11y agoThe best part about this batch of changes is they push the mole and Avogadro's constant out on their own where the belong, not linked to any other units. Now we'll have only a single mass unit (kg) instead of two (kg and unified atomic mass unit) that we do now. This will knock carbon 12 of its perch as the definition of the "other" mass unit that's been essential to use SI's mole but was not actually SI itself.
- tomp 11y agoBut wouldn't the most straightforward definition of a base mass unit (kg) be linked to the mass of an atom?
- dalke 11y agoYes. I believe Asbostos is commenting that they currently are not linked. ("Yes", with the proviso that the proposed silicon atom definition is a more obviously direct link than the watt balance.)
- tomp 11y agoWhat I mean is, the proposed new definition defines kilogramm using a relationship to Planck constant. Instead, I think that a more intuitive definition would be something like "the mass of {huge number} of C or Si atoms".
- marcosdumay 11y agoThe proposal is to define all fundamental physics constants, and derive all the units from them. The Avogadro number isn't a fundamental physics constant, it's just a unit conversion constant, and thus, didn't get to define any basic unit.
- tomp 11y ago> The Avogadro number isn't a fundamental physics constant That's a pretty arbitrary assertion. Who defines what "fundamental" is? The number of periods of <something> of Caesium atoms used to define the duration of one second doesn't sound very fundamental either.
- mtgx 11y agoNow even the U.S. can adopt it.
- dtech 11y agoUnfortunately, this is not the reason the US isn't adopting SI.
- k__ 11y agoWhat is?
- _ak 11y agoAmerican exceptionalism.
- howeyc 11y agoApathy
- theandrewbailey 11y agoInertia and the fact that alternatives are "good enough".
- anonymfus 11y agoRonald Reagan
- anonymfus 11y agoThat's from Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metrication_in_the_United_States#20th_century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metrication_in_the_United_Stat... >In 1981, the USMB reported to Congress that it lacked the clear Congressional mandate necessary to bring about national conversion. Because of this ineffectiveness and an effort of the Reagan administration — particularly from Lyn Nofziger's efforts (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03/28/AR2006032802142.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03... ) as a White House advisor to the Reagan administration, to reduce federal spending — the USMB was disbanded in the autumn of 1982. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Metric_Board https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Metric_Board >The metrification assessment board existed from 1975 to 1982, ending when President Ronald Reagan abolished it, largely on the recommendation of Frank Mankiewicz and Lyn Nofziger. Overall, it made little impact on implementing the metric system in the United States. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Mankiewicz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Mankiewicz >According to Mankiewicz, he prompted Lyn Nofziger's efforts to halt the 1970s U.S. metrication effort, who convinced President Ronald Reagan to shut down the United States Metric Board http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03/28/AR2006032802142.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03... > So, during that first year of Reagan's presidency, I sent Lyn another copy of a column I had written a few years before, attacking and satirizing the attempt by some organized do-gooders to inflict the metric system on Americans, a view of mine Lyn had enthusiastically endorsed. So, in 1981, when I reminded him that a commission actually existed to further the adoption of the metric system and the damage we both felt this could wreak on our country, Lyn went to work with material provided by each of us. He was able, he told me, to prevail on the president to dissolve the commission and make sure that, at least in the Reagan presidency, there would be no further effort to sell metric. >It was a signal victory, but one which we recognized would have to be shared only between the two of us, lest public opinion once again began to head toward metrification.
- Aoyagi 11y agoHere I thought a kilogram was defined by water... oh well, looks like that definition is slightly outdated. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Litre#Rough_conversions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Litre#Rough_conversions
- fredley 11y agoThe used to be defined as one kg of water, but it is not an official SI unit (it is part of the SI accepted metric system, which does not require such rigorous definitions).
- bartvbl 11y agoI wonder: the article states that the SI unit for Kg up to this point was defined using a single object. Doesn't this definition also involve the fact that it's placed on earth, thus requiring two objects for its definition?
- dtech 11y agoNothing prevents you from measuring it on Mars.
- tomp 11y agoNope. Mass != weight. The weight of 1kg on Earth is about 10N (and varies by location). The weight of the same 1kg object on the moon would be much less, but the mass remains the same.
- rtkwe 11y agoMass is constant across all gravitational fields (and anywhere there isn't) for any given object. People interchangeably use lbs <-> kg but the actual equivalence is lbs <-> newton (N). The difference doesn't matter in the average person's life since we're all down here where gravity is homogeneous enough for most applications and people.
- dfc 11y agoThe kilogram is still the only base unit that contains an SI prefix in the base unit's name.
- dkbrk 11y agoYeah, that's still a bit wierd. There's also the [centimetre-gram-second](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centimetre%E2%80%93gram%E2%80%93second_system_of_units https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centimetre%E2%80%93gram%E2%80%...) system that's used in some areas that has the prefix on the length unit. On a related note, tonne (i.e metric tonne) is widely used, though not generally in the scientific arena. This is partly for historical reasons, but I think there's an element of it being a little awkward to apply prefixes to the kilogram, as one must multiply the "kilo". Nonetheless, we should exploit the full power of SI prefixes and use "megagram" instead. With two short syllables rather than one long syllable it takes about the same amount of time to say and is far less ambiguous. This works well elsewhere; Fat Man wasn't 21 kilotonnes of TNT, it was 21 gigagrams.
- fluxquanta 11y agoAs a student in physics, I always used to joke about how we should say "3 megadollars" and "5 gigadollars" instead of "3 million dollars" and "5 billion dollars".
- SamReidHughes 11y agoThere's a backup service that lists its pricing in picodollars per byte (or byte-month).
- mmastrac 11y agohttp://www.tarsnap.com/picoUSD-why.html http://www.tarsnap.com/picoUSD-why.html There are three major reasons why Tarsnap pricing is defined in terms of picodollars per byte rather than dollars per gigabyte: Tarsnap's author is a geek. Applying SI prefixes to non-SI units is a geeky thing to do. If prices were listed in dollars per GB instead of picodollars per byte, it would be harder to avoid the what-is-a-GB confusion (a GB is 10^9 bytes, but some people don't understand SI prefixes). Picodollars are perfectly clear — nobody is going to think that a picodollar is 2^(-40) dollars. Specifying prices in picodollars reinforces the point that if you have very small backups, you can pay very small amounts. Unlike some people, I don't believe in rounding up to $0.01 — the Tarsnap accounting code keeps track of everything in attodollars and when it internally converts storage prices from picodollars per month to attodollars per day it rounds the prices down.
- LoSboccacc 11y agoso the proposed definition was set by fixing the numerical value of the Planck constant to 6.62606X×10−34 s−1·m2·kg and the conundrum was that they still needed to have a precise enough measurement of that constant because it's an experimental measurement. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proposed_redefinition_of_SI_base_units#Kilogram https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proposed_redefinition_of_SI_ba... https://www.quora.com/How-is-Plancks-constant-derived https://www.quora.com/How-is-Plancks-constant-derived
- TomGullen 11y agoLived next door to a PHD NPL physist who was working on this a few years ago. I think they ended up handing the project over to Canada or somewhere like that IIRC. Fascinating project and guy.
- spydum 11y agoi was hoping this was going to explain the kg differences between the original and the copies. instead it just resolves it by changing the standard. good for science i guess, sad for my curiosity
- sanxiyn 11y agoWe actually know why. Check the paper series "Stability of reference masses" published in Metrologia. Summary: mercury contamination.
- michaelhoffman 11y agoBefore I was disturbed by the change in apparent mass without explanation. Now I'm disturbed that the people working in these laboratories were exposed to mercury themselves. Nasty stuff.
- zb 11y agoI was amused to read this: "They never found the cause for the disagreement, but in late 2014 the NIST team achieved a match with the other two" at a time when this story, also from Nature, is also on the front page: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10383984 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10383984
- rubidium 11y agoI was a bit more concerned then amused. Having worked with some folks who do these high precision measurements, it's concerning that they never found the cause for disagreement. Pinning down systemic error is really, really, really hard. As Feynmann pointed out in reference to the oil drop experiment(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_drop_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_drop_experiment): "We have learned a lot from experience about how to handle some of the ways we fool ourselves. One example: Millikan measured the charge on an electron by an experiment with falling oil drops, and got an answer which we now know not to be quite right. It's a little bit off because he had the incorrect value for the viscosity of air. It's interesting to look at the history of measurements of the charge of an electron, after Millikan. If you plot them as a function of time, you find that one is a little bit bigger than Millikan's, and the next one's a little bit bigger than that, and the next one's a little bit bigger than that, until finally they settle down to a number which is higher. Why didn't they discover the new number was higher right away? It's a thing that scientists are ashamed of—this history—because it's apparent that people did things like this: When they got a number that was too high above Millikan's, they thought something must be wrong—and they would look for and find a reason why something might be wrong. When they got a number close to Millikan's value they didn't look so hard. And so they eliminated the numbers that were too far off, and did other things like that..."
- dtparr 11y agoRegarding the Feynmann quote, I suspect that behavior itself is intrinsic to humans. Few people want to be the guy coming up with a wildly different answer from a consensus/authoritative answer. We see the same thing in election polling results exhibiting 'herding'. If a pollster has a result wildly off from the polling average (especially, near the election when the variance is expected to be lower), they'll sometimes 'put a thumb on the scale' as fivethirtyeight[0] put it. This makes some sense, from a CYA perspective even if not from a scientific one. If they publish an outlier and are wrong, they look bad. If they publish close to the average and are wrong, well, at least everyone else missed it too. [0] - http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/heres-proof-some-pollsters-are-putting-a-thumb-on-the-scale/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/heres-proof-some-pollste...
- acqq 11y agoI didn't understand what then will be used: the Si sphere or the Watt balance?
- seanc 11y agoThat's the beauty of it! Since they are now yielding the same result you can (in theory) use whichever one you want.
- acqq 11y agoI can't imagine the result of the different methods will always be the same even if they are getting "close enough" now? It's an advance in measurements, as far as I understand, but measurements always have some range, and how can they know the ranges for different methods won't change as the experiments advance?
- mannykannot 11y agoYou could say the same about multiple measurements using a single method. In the event that we do find the results by different methods diverging, that is a better situation to be in than having picked one method and not being aware that the results are drifting. However, as the methods are based on very well-established physics, there is good reason to expect that, as more measurements are made and any discrepancies are investigated, the results will continue to converge.
- seanc 11y ago(forgive me if this is unnecessary review. hazard of message board communication) My understanding is that up until now they've been using a reference kilogram (Si sphere or, for the watt balance, a reference object) to measure Planck's Constant. Now that they are getting repeatable, converging results for Planck's constant they can turn the process around; define Planck's constant and then use the apparatus to generate a reference kilogram. And so the beauty of it is that any sufficiently motivated team could assemble the equipment (either apparatus!) and manufacture a reference kilogram that would be just as good as anyone else's. Unlike the present state of affairs, where no matter how hard anyone wants to try, they simply can't manufacture a reference kilogram better than the one in Paris.
- castratikron 11y agoStrange to see Planck's constant used that way, defining a kilogram. Planck's constant usually only shows up when you're doing quantum mechanics and the things you're working with are really small.
- castratikron 11y agoReally? A downvote?
- pervycreeper 11y agoWhat is the level of accuracy they are aiming for? If it entails have some uncertainty over the precise number of atoms in the silicon sphere, then how did they choose this level of accuracy?
- jessriedel 11y agoI don't know what fundamentally sets the accuracy, but it's definitely a lot coarser than the number of atoms in the silicon sphere. G is known to 4 or 5 significant digits, while atomic accuracy would be 26 significant digits.
- sanxiyn 11y agoG doesn't matter if you use dual-pan balances, and they do.
- sanxiyn 11y agoThe possible accuracy is limited by uncertainty over mass of IPK(International Prototype Kilogram), which is 20 ppb. You cannot measure the number of atoms in a kilogram of silicon better than that, because a kilogram is defined by IPK. 20 ppb translates to uncertainty of about 10000 trillion atoms. The number will be set to a round number, because any number within trillions is compatible with the legacy standard.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- justhw 11y agoThere's a good Radiolab episode related to this . http://www.radiolab.org/story/kg/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/kg/
- tantalor 11y agoThat site is terribly broken until Flash is enabled. There's no obvious way to play the episode, just a tiny "stream" button that doesn't stream. Why does it have to use Flash anyway?
- thieving_magpie 11y agoA planet money podcast from a few years ago on the kilogram: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=112003322 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1120033...
- novaleaf 11y agoIf you are interested in hearing more expert commentary, NPR Science Friday did a piece on this in July: http://www.sciencefriday.com/segment/07/17/2015/redefining-the-kilogram.html http://www.sciencefriday.com/segment/07/17/2015/redefining-t...
- Animats 11y agoAh, they went with the "electric kilogram". The other plan was to build up a regular structure with a known number of silicon atoms. That idea was to make a perfect crystal and count the number of atoms on each face. Apparently that's almost possible, although hard to do.
- rcthompson 11y agoThe article says they did that, too. (Actually, it says they used silicon spheres, but close enough.)
- hugh4 11y agoSilicon will oxidise the moment you put it in air, were they going to keep it in ultra-high vacuum or just deal with the oxidisation?
- copsarebastards 11y agoUltra-high vacuum is way harder to maintain than simply keeping it in nitrogen.
- hugh4 11y agoWas that the plan then? You'd need to have one hundred percent purity nitrogen with no oxygen and no water, is it really possible to keep it at the level of purity you need?
- copsarebastards 11y agoI don't know, I was just presenting an alternative solution to the problem you were talking about. I imagine that the sides of the encasement would have to be pretty impermeable to keep oxygen out, but it's probably harder if the oxygen-containing air is pushing in and nothing is pushing out. Playing around with the chemistry more, it might be possible to use a gas that oxidizes more readily than silicon, so that if any oxygen does get in it will be neutralized before it gets anywhere near the silicon. I'm not sure if that's possible to do with a gas, though.
- lifeformed 11y agoPreviously, why didn't they have a reference gram instead of a kilogram? Seems like it'd be easier to create and maintain, and transport.
- Aloha 11y agoThe base measure for the KG was originally the gram, wiki has a good explanation why it was changed.