5 ms·
If we could get rid of copyright there'd be much less resistance toward embedding information about who created the work. I'd very much like that we could abol
by scotty79 11y ago
If we could get rid of copyright there'd be much less resistance toward embedding information about who created the work.
I'd very much like that we could abolish fines for copying but keep fines for stripping author signature from work, or not propagating original author signature to works that are derived.
This way you could have a trail to reach actual author of the part of work that you find awesome to commission some new work from him.
This could be much more valuable for way more people than current copyright schemes that only seem to benefit fatcats.
- atom_enger 11y agoBut your proposal doesn't help the archaic business models stay afloat. They're fighting us and the progression of technology to stay relevant :(. Great idea though.
- graeme 11y agoI write books. I publish the contents for free online, too. But I still want copyright. If there were none, someone else could take my work, attribute it, put it on some SEO'd site and outrank me. What recourse would I have? Very few people are going to find the original source, search it, get past the SEO and find my site. And zero readers have commissioned a work. I make money, but not that way. Trust me, copyright isn't just for fatcats. Though I suspect it's mostly fatcats who propose unreasonable applications of copyright.
- anonymfus 11y agoFor public domain content first search results are usually non-profit online libraries like Wikibooks and Project Gutenberg. In Russia where illegal book sharing is widespread most popular piracy libraries now are non-profits like Flibusta and Library Genesis.
- graeme 11y agoHow does that help the original author monetize their work? I don't care whether the first result is non-profit or not. I care whether it's me. If I can't monetize works, I won't make them, I'll do something else. Are their Russian authors making money with working business models under their system of non-enforced copyright?
- anonymfus 11y agoI incorrectly thought that your problem was that somebody else could monetize your work. Copyright is enforced here, sites are banned and people go to jail for installing unlicensed software. Piracy is widespread because of many cultural, historical and economical reasons. There are 3 main business models Russian authors use: crowdfunding (there are few platforms specialised on books), appealing to audience without internet access, and receiving support from the government.
- throwawaymaroon 11y agoIt's bizarre how you think people would stop making art if they didn't get paid for it. It's the kind of warped perspective that comes from being happy with the scraps you get, I guess.
- scotty79 11y agoSelling copies is insane way to monetize something. When I want to make money programming I'm looking for a person that needs a program and write it for him often requesting at least portion of money up front. Writing programs in hopes of selling them in the future is like trying to strike gold. Even if you are not horribly wrong and someone will buy copy of your stuff and not immediately request a refund it will most likely be insanely cheap (from your point of view) and expensive for the people who can get that copy for free because it is almost as easy (often easier) than paying for it.
- deciplex 11y agoThe problem is you're right, but you're not in good company. I want copyright too, and for pretty much the same reasons as you. But right now supporting "copyright" means you're taking the same side as assholes who insists on a term of 70 years after the death of the author, or more. Some people even at HN think copyright ought to have infinite duration. It means you're on the same side as those who want to send people to prison or put them in the poorhouse for putting a video on Youtube. The same side as jerks who want to deploy bots all across the web to indiscriminately take down content whether it infringes or not, and who wheel and deal with distribution channels when the draconian laws they bribe governments to pass aren't enough. Seriously, fuck these people. The political climate in much of the world eschews nuance on basically any issue you can name, and copyright is no exception. I want reasonable copyright terms of ten to twenty years from publication and to wipe my ass with the DMCA. If I can't have that, and if the choice is between copyright maximalists and those who would abolish copyright completely, I'll support shit-canning the idea altogether. It might not be the most fiscally or culturally sound solution, but it at least shows a basic understanding of how human culture even works, which I can't say for the maximalists.
- graeme 11y agoYou're throwing the baby out with the bathwater. This comment in another part of the thread put it well. Do you have a response to the argument below? "If that happens, the web as we know it would cease to exist. Without a legal recourse to stop plagiarism and stolen content, people who are actually creating new content stop completely and move into other areas of work. Websites that produce original and unique content close up shop. Instead you're left with a bunch of low-quality rip off sites that have nothing original of their own. Then it the entire web stagnates over the years as very few new things get added to the net as a whole. And that's just the effect on the internet, that doesn't take into account real world publishing. I wish people would consider all of the consequences of these things before making statements like that. I haven't even begun to consider the consequences of eliminating copyright completely and just from what I can come up with off the top of my head makes it a non-starter." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10384178 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10384178
- scotty79 11y ago> could take my work, attribute it, put it on some SEO'd site and outrank me Attribution should be made in the way you want it to be made. Your domain name or email or unique random string one could google, could be part of your signature that would be obligatory for others to include if they want to share or build upon your work. > Very few people are going to find the original source, search it If I like something that somebody made I usually look him up to find out if he has other cool stuff. I do it with musicians, I do it with authors, with actors, with directors ... less so with graphic designers because they are way harder to find because information about authorship is almost never carefully retained for images. Same way as with code. If I find cool project I'm looking for original repo and most prominent forks.
- MichaelGG 11y agoHmm? The stripping of metadata is done for privacy reasons. People accidentally expose too much info when they take a photo if the metadata is left intact. When sharing a picture online, user's don't expect that they are also sharing the datetime, location, camera model and settings, and possibly their name (or the camera owner's name). The number of people that intentionally add their info to EXIF and want it to stay there is dwarfed by the people that would view that as a privacy violation.
- vidarh 11y agoIt'd be straightforward enough to define metadata tags that are specifically not to be automatically added at source, intended to use specifically to survive privacy stripping. Of course that'd depend on tools actually respecting the intent and not adding them other than when explicitly requested to.
- mahranch 11y ago> If we could get rid of copyright If that happens, the web as we know it would cease to exist. Without a legal recourse to stop plagiarism and stolen content, people who are actually creating new content stop completely and move into other areas of work. Websites that produce original and unique content close up shop. Instead you're left with a bunch of low-quality rip off sites that have nothing original of their own. Then it the entire web stagnates over the years as very few new things get added to the net as a whole. And that's just the effect on the internet, that doesn't take into account real world publishing. I wish people would consider all of the consequences of these things before making statements like that. I haven't even begun to consider the consequences of eliminating copyright completely and just from what I can come up with off the top of my head makes it a non-starter.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Without a legal recourse to stop plagiarism and stolen content, people who are actually creating new content stop completely and move into other areas of work. Copyright doesn't prevent plagiarism; plagiarism can exist without copyright violation and vice versa.
- snowwrestler 11y agoCopyright prevents creative impersonation. If I take your creative work and try to pass it off as my own--whether for profit, reputation, etc.--copyright gives you a legal tool to stop me. Without it, anyone could get away with pretending to have done anyone else's creative work. To illustrate with a recent example, Andy Weir wrote "The Martian," and distributed it online for free, originally. Without copyright, Crown books could have copied the text, put a different author name on it, sold thousands of copies and kept every dime. Same with the movie--they could have just copied the story and made a movie without paying Andy anything.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThat's the aspect of copyright I'm willing to support, but it doesn't require DRMs, just a working justice system. Also, sadly, publishers have many different tricks to rob authors out of the money from book sales. Bigger ones probably don't care, but there are a lot of smaller "entrepreneurs" willing to lie and cheat, so one has to be careful (as my physics professor learned in a painful way).
- nness 11y agoI don't see how that would work — not all copyrightable acts can convey the author information in the body of the work, and more importantly, you wouldn't be able to recover damages if someone used your work for profit. Sure, an image might be watermarked, but if someone plays a song without a license do you expect each recording to include a copyright statement before the music? If you remove penalties for copying then what would stop a private gallery from showing your photography and charging admission? All you get is attribution note, not a cut. Likewise, anyone could use your music on any commercial, radio station, movie without royalties.
- scotty79 11y ago> recover damages if someone used your work for profit What's the damage? > if someone plays a song without a license do you expect each recording to include a copyright statement before the music Even if you play live on the street you can have flyers that state who composed music, who wrote text, who are you trying to imitate. > If you remove penalties for copying then what would stop a private gallery from showing your photography and charging admission? Nothing. And that's bad because...? > All you get is attribution note, not a cut. Great. That means if somebody likes my work he comes to me for more. > Likewise, anyone could use your music on any commercial, radio station, movie without royalties. Sure. Again. I'd very much liked my music or whatever used in Hollywood movie or commercial or whatever without even if I can't get a penny for that if they will display or say my name and website address each time it's seen or heard by people.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoCopyright is important. A limited monopoly on the distribution of your work means you can recoup development costs and actually make money. What needs changing isn't abolishing copyright, but making it less draconian and returning to the original principle: a monopoly for a limited time (not an infinite one), perhaps ten or twenty years, or varying by field.