3 ms·
Just in case anyone knows.. why are mortgages in the US structured in this lax way? In the UK, if you don't pay your mortgage, you're still entirely liable for
by petercooper 17y ago
Just in case anyone knows.. why are mortgages in the US structured in this lax way? In the UK, if you don't pay your mortgage, you're still entirely liable for the debt even after handing the keys back. If you can't meet the difference between what they make on a quick sale and the owed amount, they will, and do, bankrupt you over it.
- dschobel 17y agoYeah, I'm actually surprised you can walk away from a mortgage (a legal contract) without also declaring bankruptcy. Any legal eagles around to explain how this is possible?
- trjordan 17y agoAs the article noted, mortgage contracts in the US stipulate the penalties for walking away, and those penalties go no further than surrendering the house.
- ajross 17y agoExactly. And as the house is the collateral for the loan, that makes perfect sense. If the bank was dumb enough to write a loan that they can't get back by selling the collateral, why should the borrower be expected to bear the burden? Frankly, I like the US system; it places the burden of analyis and risk management on the party most able to do that competently.
- petercooper 17y agoExcept that's more like a hire purchase agreement than a loan. If you take a bank loan to pay for a car/boat/to fund your startup/whatever and you can't pay it, you're still on the line for the loan if the assets purchased can't match the capital owed. Mortgage loans seem to be treated as a special case in the US.
- ajross 17y agoTrue, though there are loopholes there too: startups are almost universally corporations or LLCs, generally for the express purpose of insulating the owners from the liabilities of the business. And banks routinely write off uncollectable car loans by selling them to collection agencies; they aren't large enough to bother with enforceable legal action. The homeowner protection laws are the same kind of thing. As a society, we decide that home ownership is worth encouraging (whether that's true or not is an interesting side question), so we implement policy designed to encourage it.
- nradov 17y agoNot exactly. It varies in different states, and on whether the mortgage was for purchase money or refinancing.
- wisty 17y agoThey are not breaching the contract. The contract says they can walk away any time, but they lose their house. A full recourse mortgage (where you don't have the option of walking away) must be illegal, otherwise the banks wouldn't put such a clause in their contracts. (I don't know, I'm not a legal eagle).
- pmichaud 17y agoThe system you describe puts 100% of the onus of appraisal onto the borrower. It's in the bank's best interests to inflate the value of the home as much as possible and get a borrower on that inflated amount, because now, regardless of what the property is actually worth, the borrower is on the hook for the full amount. The bank is normally the one who approves the appraiser, which is a clear conflict of interest. In our system, ideally everyone is best served when the appraiser is neutral and competent because the borrower doesn't over pay, and the bank isn't exposed to much risk since the collateral can actually cover the obligation. The system you describe has a huge loophole because lenders hold all the cards and could easily collude on the sly with appraisers to drive prices up at the expense of the individual. It wouldn't even need to be an explicit collusion -- sort of like the default swap stuff, no individual player (who could see that the system was a sham) had any incentive to bring it down. On the contrary, they had incentive to keep up the bullshit in order to make their numbers. A similar pressure could result with laws that heavily favor the lender.
- jacquesm 17y agoThere is a possible upside to the borrower for an inflated valuation too. As long as the market is rising the borrower can point to the increased valuation since the property came on the market and use that to 'pass the hot potato' to the next sucker. Plenty of people made tons of money in this way in the '96 to 2000 period, especially in larger cities where property prices tend to go up out of proportion.
- nfnaaron 17y ago"The system you describe has a huge loophole because lenders hold all the cards and could easily collude on the sly with appraisers to drive prices up at the expense of the individual." That happens here in the US. Appraisers I've talked to have been pressured to raise the value of the property, so the transaction will happen. The seller wants to sell it for X. The buyer wants to buy it for X. The two agents and the bank want the house sold for anything at all. Buyers and sellers should choose and pay for their own appraisal, even if the bank requires the buyer to pay for an appraisal for the bank.
- axod 17y ago
- rsheridan6 17y agoIt depends on the state. In most states the bank can go after you in court. But California is an exception, and it also happens to be the state that had the biggest bubble.
- anamax 17y ago> It depends on the state. In most states the bank can go after you in court. But California is an exception, and it also happens to be the state that had the biggest bubble. CA's exception only applies to the purchase mortage. If you refinance, that lender can go after you for the difference. Note that you owe federal income taxes on forgiven debt. I suspect that most states with income tax do the same.