5 ms·
It is a big one. Many expats had to resign their US citizenship to avoid this silly law. Double taxation only exists in Aethopia and the US. Read this blog: h
by rurban 11y ago
It is a big one. Many expats had to resign their US citizenship to avoid this silly law.
Double taxation only exists in Aethopia and the US.
Read this blog: http://www.overseas-exile.com/ http://www.overseas-exile.com/
Protection? Yes, maybe that's the reason. To support the US military efforts and budget.
On a side-note: If I would applied to the US greencard, and then decided to move back to Germany, I would have to pay double income taxes. To Germany and to the US. You don't even need to be US citizen.
- deong 11y agoTo be clear, you wouldn't actually pay double-taxes (I think -- if you make more than $100k, it depends on if the Germans and Americans have a treaty over it, but most countries do, I think). You'd have to file twice, but the US side would consist of forms that say you don't owe the US government anything because you already paid more to the Germans than the US would have charged.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoThere are cases where double taxation can occur that aren't covered under tax treaties. Consider an American working abroad going on a business trip to the USA. Depends in the country, you can be on the hook for taxes in both countries, where neither country recognizes the right of the other to tax.
- mike_hearn 11y agoDouble taxation does happen pretty regularly, in particular, the USA often doesn't recognise various types of European investment and pension instruments and that causes complications. It's a really byzantine system that shouldn't even exist at all. People who live outside the USA get nothing from the US government, so they should pay no taxes. Every other country has this figured out.
- rayiner 11y agoI filed five returns last year (4 states and 1 federal) and I didn't even leave the U.S.
- ckozlowski 11y agoNot necessarly disagreeing, but when you say "many" (And that 266% increased made headlines everywhere), I feel it needs some context: 8.7 million abroad. 3,417 renounced citizenship. Or, .039%. I'm going to take a stab at this and guess that's some of the 1% right there who had millions stashed abroad. Maybe the tax law was painful to them, but for the rest, it's hardly a crisis.
- mike_hearn 11y agoThe statistics on renunciations may not be correct. There are lists of people published who renounced, but every time I read a story about FATCA I keep coming across comments posting by people who claim they gave up their citizenship and never appeared on these lists. The real question is how many people would like to give it up, but can't, because obtaining citizenship where they live is extremely tough and because the US is unusually vindictive towards people who try and renounce. They can even retroactively undo your renunciation if they decide you did it for tax reasons. Seen from one angle, US citizenship looks a lot like modern slavery. You're born into it, it's difficult to escape, you get no benefit out of the relationship and no matter where in the world you run to your 'owners' will demand a slice of the fruits of your labours.
- chadscira 11y agoThats crazy! I had no idea they can "undo your renunciation". Sounds like slavery to me ;).
- jleyank 11y agoThis is Hacker News, right? Way easier to work in SV with that blue passport/screaming chicken than otherwise (except possibly countries such as Canada). Throwing away easy access to the Valley strikes me as a reasonably high price for non-retirees to pay.
- mike_hearn 11y agoThere are far more hackers outside of SV than in it, I'd guess.
- dangjc 11y agoThe flip side is that foreigners who invest in America aren't taxed at all. At least in Singapore, I know people who invest in the US stock markets and pay not a single cent in capital gains taxes or dividend taxes (Singapore does not tax these). I'm not sure the citizenship based taxation makes the most sense.