6 ms·
Show HN: FoxType – Using NLP to help you write more politely
- adhsu01 11y agoNice! Congratulations on putting this out there. How does this work? What did you use as training data? Do you parse the sentence in any way? For example, "Hey! It was so so great to see you." gets a 46/100, and 'so' is listed as an impolite word, which is understandable in some contexts but not this one.
- plusepsilon 11y agoThanks. Yes, we built our own training set. Catching all the different senses of the word is a hard problem. There's always something to improve.
- pavornyoh 11y agoGood job first of all.. So out of fun, I typed in "the dudes and dudettes were here" to test your system. The neutral responses as rewrites were a bit worrying. You may want to look into it. Congrats on it. EDIT: @Mikkiq, thank you for taking those words out promptly and correcting it. Cool site.
- jaymzcampbell 11y agoAgreed, it's nicely put together. I think this could grow into a handy tool, like an advanced thesaurus of sorts. Not sure if it was another word, but the word 'dudes' still has a suggestion to a word I'd firmly rank 'impolite' when I tried just now. That said it includes a whole bunch of swear words (marked impolite) - I could weirdly see using this to add a bit of flair to a put down. I do find these things quite fun; I put in "You are a sexy beast" and got "You are a hot dog" as neutral, "You are a beautiful dog" as neutral but "You are a beautiful horse" would be pushing it and impolite; though "You are a glamorous horse" (or hot) is neutral. Giving it a go with some Donald Trump twitter text, the suggestion was "President Obama was terrible on @60Minutes tonight" is impolite; a suggested change that would be more polite was "President obama was incredible on@60minutes last night.". I noticed with that it looped through the same words a few times - in some cases labelling the same phrase as both neutral and polite.
- pavornyoh 11y ago@Jaymzcampbell, The suggested rewrite for "the dudes and dudettes were here" and gave it a 60/100 and a neutral response was "The N(hint: for black) and fellas were here". All in all, this is a neat site for when I am angry and need to be polite with words. I like the responses you got though. I can see myself using you are a glamorous horse:)
- tekromancr 11y agoThis actually seems pretty profound. Semantically, in some contexts, those words could be used interchangeably. It seems that the algorithm simply didn't understand the context where it would be socially acceptable to use such language, It's kinda like a small child!
- pavornyoh 11y ago>It seems that the algorithm simply didn't understand the context where it would be socially acceptable to use such language, It's kinda like a small child! Thats correct. I further used the the suggested rewrites and it came back with some wild suggestions. It is hard to get $100%.
- dang 11y ago> @Jaymzcampbell, Please don't repeat the username you're replying to. HN's threaded comments make that redundant.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pavornyoh 11y agoI agree..
- tekromancr 11y agoAhh, guilty. Sorry about polluting your dataset! My first reaction to seeing this tool was "Ohh, I wonder what it thinks about cursewords". I can't imagine that is a rare thought.
- jval 11y agoWow, this is excellent, congrats on the release. Are you planning on adding the ability for people to feed in suggestions/feedback or is that too prone to abuse? Great seeing more cool NLP technology out there!
- SixSigma 11y agoIt's not very British :) Apparently "Pardon my intrusion but may I enquire as to your state of health." Is neutral and should be replaced by "Pardon my ingress but may I question as to your government sources of medical treatment." Which I guess is also more in tune with American politics. Truly is has achieved singularity.
- drglitch 11y agoGreat product and lots of fun to play with! The odd edgecases remind me a little of http://translationparty.com/ http://translationparty.com/ :)
- kiddico 11y agoThis was really fun to play around with. its funny how changing a word in one scenario will make you more polite, while in another it'll become the least polite thing ever.
- angersock 11y agoFor added good fun, seed it with some Torvalds: https://adtmag.com/blogs/dev-watch/2014/04/linus-torvalds-rants.aspx https://adtmag.com/blogs/dev-watch/2014/04/linus-torvalds-ra...
- sswaner 11y agoStymied by one of the hardest sentences to parse: "Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo." But, I did find it handled typical sentences very well. Good job.
- JacobJans 11y agoThis isn't a criticism, per se, but I do find it interesting to try to "beat" the system. Impolite: "You are wonderful." "I really love it." "Your work has really inspired me." "Why do I love what you're doing? Because of the following reasons." Polite: "Again, please show me your failure, which I love to see." Ok. I'm out of time. :)
- nicolashahn 11y agoI would say this is sarcasm, which is a huge NLP problem by itself.
- Nadya 11y agoI find that more and more of these sort of "Write more politely" things are propping up. Inherently they come off as either too distant or too unsure of oneself by throwing a bunch of non-assertive statements ("hedge statements") or speaking in a way nobody would actually speak. Combined with training sets always being incomplete and human nuance being something extremely difficult to teach, it always returns to "use your best judgement". I feel like maybe I just "don't get it". At least I can have fun playing a game of "how rude can I be while still getting a polite score". >I think your mother would have had a better life if she had swallowed you." Polite: 77/100
- gnu8 11y agoIs there a way to link to a specific query?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- musesum 11y agoS'up? Polite Would you know if s'up? Polite May I ask if s'up? Polite May I know if s'up? Polite I was wondering if s'up? Polite Could you say if s'up? Polite Could I know if s'up? Polite I was thinking if s'up? Polite Could I ask if s'up?
- SignMeTheHELLUp 11y agoHow to come across as a dickless pushover for dummies. Seriously though I think it's bad to encourage people to pepper their comments with such trite. I would rather read a brief, sincere message than a longwinded weak one.
- pablovidal85 11y agoHilarious, after some iterations I got: Would you know if I might wonder if I may know what the heck you are looking at?
- rzzzt 11y ago> "You are not the greatest instrumentality in the scaffolds." > "He's a bit of a spare barrel." Idiomatic expressions are also perturbed in a quite pleasant manner. :)
- JoshTriplett 11y agoWhy does profanity produce "contentious" rather than "impolite"? (That doesn't make it universally inappropriate, but it's certainly less polite.)
- bshep 11y agoMakes me think of the book 'Avogadro Corp'
- cmccart 11y ago>Please would you kindly help if good with you please, thank you kindly, thanks. Took a while, but along with a coworker, we were able to get 100.
- imh 11y ago>You suck stupid shit. FUCK YOUUU?? Same here, but I was going for 0.
- tomc1985 11y agoDisagreeing with the 'politeness' assessment of some of these words... type in 'Howdy' and the only "polite" words are "Welcome" and "Goodbye". More troubling to me is that this feels more like one person trying to impose their definition of "polite" onto others, and many of the suggestions seem result in speech that is weak, weasel-y, or lacking a feeling of weight.
- 1123581321 11y agoIt suggested I upgrade the curse in "Yo, fix the goddamn server already" to motherfucking (as it's only merely contentious.) I don't think it does what it promises! Fun idea, though.
- rahimnathwani 11y agoAnd when you feed that output back as input, the top suggestion is: "Yo, fix the goddamn civil servants before"
- chavesn 11y agoI used this to check the text messages from Key and Peele's "Text Message Confusion" skit[1]: Keegan: "I've been trying to reach out to you all day, are we on for tonight?" Polite (71 / 100) Jordan: "Sorry dude, missed your texts. I assumed we'd meet at the bar. Whatever, I don't care." Polite (71 / 100) Keegan: "Do you even want to hang out?" Impolite (30 / 100) Jordan: "Like I said, whatever." Neutral (47 / 100) Keegan: "Jesus, you are fucking priceless" Impolite (30 / 100) Jordan: "You're the one who's fucking priceless!" Impolite (6 / 100) Keegan: "You wanna go right now?" Impolite (31 / 100) Jordan: "Ok let's go" Polite (76 / 100)[2] Keegan: "You wanna really do this now?" Impolite (13 / 100) Jordan: "Fuck yeah, let's do it" Impolite (19 / 100) Jordan: "First round's mine" Neutral (43 / 100) [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=naleynXS7yo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=naleynXS7yo [2]: Adding a "." to the end of the "Ok let's go" drops it by three points to 73 / 100
- pavornyoh 11y agoThat youtube video is hilarious..
- jordigh 11y agoFun game. Trying to say "you are wrong" in the most polite way possible. I still cannot get anything above 70.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chavesn 11y ago"Thank you, but please realize that your response is zero percent correct, thanks." 94/100
- te_platt 11y agoThank you, please understand your lovely response is zero percent correct, thanks. 95/100
- rahimnathwani 11y agoThanks, please understand your lovely response is zero percent correct :) 97/100
- Nadya 11y agoI deleted my last response which missed the "above 70" requirement and only tried to be "polite". I managed to get 85 with the following: "I am sorry but the statement you have made is incorrect and I would like to offer a correction."
- anthony_romeo 11y agoHi! I thank you kindly for your lovely thoughts! Haha, please! They are very specious! Thanks! :-) 99/100
- xnxn 11y ago(Yours is my favorite so far, LOL.) Hi, I would discuss the impressive contrast between these thoughts and the facts of reality with you, please; thanks! :) 100/100
- chei0aiV 11y agoApparently smileys make everything so much better :) http://i.imgur.com/GxKOMuw.png http://i.imgur.com/GxKOMuw.png Edit: "We would like to express our sincerest thanks to all the best, most amazing cocksuckers that created this tone checker! :) " [96 /100]
- deadlycrayon 11y agoClosest we got was: "Hi, thanks for happy" -99/100
- anthony_romeo 11y agoI found it: "Hi, we thanks for the happy! Thank you for love! :-)" 100/100
- sova 11y agoPretty cool but it would be helpful to have a way to add or submit entries (!)
- reviseddamage 11y agothe suggestions for impolite needs fix? If you enter vulgarities and offensive language, the suggestions seem to be just as bad. ""this is a fucking stupid task and idiotic in it's delivery."" edit: it's a really cool tool, actually has helped me to make polite to uber polite.
- beilabs 11y agoSuck my lady lumps, Thank you. 83% polite....hehe Suck my dick, Thank you. Contentious....ha! The gender based norms are strong with this one.
- thelonecabbage 11y ago"Bite me, please" 83/100