5 ms·
How many frames can humans see
- ugh 17y agoRe Sensitivity to brightness: Human eyes can see single photons (well, one is too few, but ten will definitly do it). Which means that if there is some light - any light at all - we will see it. Not the direction (if we are talking about single photons) but still. Oh, well, there will never be a TV good enough :)
- d0mine 17y agoThe first hit from Google: The human eye is very sensitive but can we see a single photon? The answer is that the sensors in the retina can respond to a single photon. However, neural filters only allow a signal to pass to the brain to trigger a conscious response when at least about five to nine arrive within less than 100 ms. </quote> http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Quantum/see_a_photon.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Quantum/see_a_photon.h...
- ugh 17y agoIs this a correction? To quote myself: "(well, one is too few, but ten will definitly do it)"
- po 17y agoIt is easy to prove that humans can perceive more than 60 frames per second: wave your hand in front of a fluorescent light. They flicker at the same speed as your electricity (in the US it's 60Hz) and you can easily see the motion break down.
- notaddicted 17y agoThey flicker at 120, because the top and bottom of the sine wave both "flick".
- csbrooks 17y agoSide note: If you have florescent lighting running at 60hz, and a UK tv running at 50hz, you get a horrendous flicker effect on the tv. (I got this working on the EU version of a console game, in the US, on an imported UK tv.)
- ajross 17y agoThat's not "perceiving" at 60Hz though. The eye is seeing an integrated image, which happens to be of several "frames" of your hand lit mixed with gaps of darkness. Effectively, you're seeing multiple strobes "at the same time". You do get aliasing effects with strong strobing though, where your eyes can see beating patterns in the image intensity. That's why some people get eye strain looking at 60Hz displays; moving to ~70Hz or so generally fixes it. But again, our visual systems do not have the ability to distinguish between individual events separated by 1/60th of a second. We just can't do it, and trying to animate at that speed is purely wasted effort.
- csbrooks 17y ago>But again, our visual systems do not have the ability to distinguish between individual events separated by 1/60th of a second. We just can't do it, and trying to animate at that speed is purely wasted effort. And yet, there's a very clear perceivable difference between a game running at 30hz and 60hz. How does that work?
- ajross 17y ago
- est 17y agoWhat's the resolution and bitrate of a general human eye? I have a theory: the ultimate limit of broadband upgrading movement is our brain's whole throughput. After that individual consumers' demand will slow down and the broadband market will be dedicated for industrial broadband market. :)
- Retric 17y agoThat's a hard problem. The human eye is only ~2 megapixels but it's focused on a small part of your field of view. So if you wanted to fool the eye you either need to track what it's looking at or to create a huge high resolution screen most of which is ignored. Add in the ability to focus and you suddenly need to add depth information and a display that can handle it or you will not fool the eye. Now add the fact that most people have 2 of them and it gets even more insane. PS: Video cards have far higher internal bandwidth than external bandwidth for a reason. Focusing on the brains bandwidth is not going to be enough.
- mseebach 17y agoI'm pretty sure I've read that the resolution is somewhat unlimited (i.e. it your field of vision blends in seemslessly with short-term memory) but the bandwidth is actually quite limited, but variable (i.e. can handle much change in a small area or little change in a large area).
- nradov 17y agoBack in 1995 Jakob Nielsen estimated it as ~1Tbps. http://www.useit.com/alertbox/9511.html http://www.useit.com/alertbox/9511.html
- radley 17y agoFollow this up with his other useful sites including: http://100-dating-tips.com http://100-dating-tips.com http://in-my-opinion.org http://in-my-opinion.org
- middus 17y agoBTW: These are other sites by the same author. I think we should dismiss his 100fps articles based on the fact that he operates a strange dating tips site.
- middus 17y agowhoops, this is missing a not. "we should not dismiss ..." sorry about that!
- cliveholloway 17y agoThere was me thinking it was sarcasm - works both ways :)
- riobard 17y agofrom http://100-dating-tips.com/ http://100-dating-tips.com/ "Moreover many women have bisexual tendencie" I can confirm this based on the sample of my female friends. Wondering why ...
- almost 17y agoSorry, I down-voted you thinking this was a spam comment. I see now that you were actually pointing out the other sites this author has written. Sorry about that!
- motters 17y agoThe trouble is that the higher the frame rate the less photons are captured by the light sensitive elements, and so the larger the shot noise becomes.
- wensing 17y agoFascinating, but one bit of feedback--I really would like to pass this on to a couple of young, budding scientists, but I can't because of the examples: murder, people being stabbed with an icepick, etc. Out of all the movies this is what they choose? sigh Please, writers--choose your examples with a broad audience in mind.
- CUViper 17y ago3dfx had a demo of this a while back. (11 years ago!) It would show 60/30/15 fps side-by-side, so you could better compare how the frame-rate impacts you. I found it archived here: http://www.falconfly.de/artwork.htm http://www.falconfly.de/artwork.htm http://www.falconfly.de/downloads/3dfxdemo-3060hz.zip http://www.falconfly.de/downloads/3dfxdemo-3060hz.zip You're likely to need a Glide wrapper too: http://www.sierrahelp.com/Utilities/DisplayUtilities/GlideWrappers.html http://www.sierrahelp.com/Utilities/DisplayUtilities/GlideWr...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]