4 ms·
It's not "the worst idea". It's designed to stop countries commandeering or nationalizing assets that a company owns. (Search for "venezuela expropriations" f
by rwmj 11y ago
It's not "the worst idea". It's designed to stop countries commandeering or nationalizing assets that a company owns. (Search for "venezuela expropriations" for some recent cases). For that limited purpose it's fine.
- mimo84 11y agoIt is designed to remove power from the people and give it to the big corporations.
- josephagoss 11y agoCompanies are essentially groups of people. I'm not sure that taking away the right to sue from groups of people is such a good idea. I see this as actually giving power back to the people.
- nmrm2 11y agoNo. By this logic, giving any organization power is giving power to the people, because all organizations are "essentially groups of people". But that's clearly fallacious -- in all but the most bizarre cases, the local warlord's crime organization isn't nearly as representative of the will of the people as a democratically elected local government. Companies are not democracies. Especially multi-national corporations and the lobbying arms of entire industries are in no sense representative of the will of the general public -- or even of their own employees (see unions)! This is significant because it is categorically not possible to actually choose not to interact with a particular corporation. In fact, the historical truth of that observation is the root cause of environmental, health, and many other regulations. A defining characteristic of democracy is one person, one vote, and it is that characteristic that safeguards the will of the people. There is no corporate structure (other than unrepresentative radical experimental structures) that even conceits to affording one vote to each person. In fact, there's no provision of the TPP that requires the suing company to be publicly traded, so in some cases it may not even be possible to buy votes.
- rorykoehler 11y agoYour statement fails to represent the reality in that corporations are inherently undemocratic. They are groups of people controlled by a few people with all the money and therefore power.
- wfo 11y agoCompanies are absolute dictatorships generally owned by a very tiny class of wealthy elite capitalists. Calling them "groups of people" is deeply dishonest.
- brianclements 11y agoBusiness's are amoral entities, designed with just a single charter: to increase the bottom line for it's majority stakeholders. Nothing about that is inherently democratic or good for their customers, for the environment, for the nation that company occupies, for anyone not in the company, or even for any one of their bottom tier employees by default. Any adoption of altruistic practices are either part of the companies branding and therefor good for business, or are core beliefs held by the majority stakeholders and are adopted by force. This also works for adoption of not so altruistic practices as well, and we shouldn't leave it up to chance. If anything, corporate structure creates a multiplier effect on the influence of single humans or small groups of humans thereby corrupting the one-person one-vote intent of democracy. While I agree with the philosophical kernel of the Supreme Court's citizens united ruling that money is free speech, just like many things, at large scale, it has unintended side effects that need to be thwarted by campaign finance reform so that some people don't have MORE free speech then others.
- melloclello 11y agoCall me socialist but I actually kinda like the idea that my country can just nationalise whatever if we just so feel like it. Sure, it would ruin our reputation, but I like to think sovereignty means something, right? I tell you what, if I was PM of my country and, say, a foreign company discovered a significant oil field within our territory, I would want to nationalise the shit out of it, reputation be damned.
- _yosefk 11y agoWhy should sovereignty mean that you can disregard the rights of foreigners any more than owning a home should result in a right to take a guest's wallet at gunpoint? Whether or not either of these situations is morally desirable, I don't see how they would be sustainable, as in, why would everybody else put up with you? To take your example, if my country nationalizes an oil field found and owned by your country's citizens (assuming that my country originally tricked them into searching for oil by promising it'd be theirs to some extent or other when they find it - otherwise why would they search for it in the first place?), why would your country stop at "tarnishing my country's reputation" when it could apply force, ranging from economic sanctions to an actual war?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- michaelt 11y agoSovereignty means having the power to make or change any law. And our elected leaders should have that power so that bad laws can be fixed. Imagine if, in pre-civil-war America a lot of British investors had invested in cotton plantations whose profitability depended on slavery. Should Lincoln have said "gee, I guess my hands are tied, banning slavery would be bad for our foreign investors" and done nothing? You might argue that in the past we had bad laws, but we don't have bad laws any more and all our laws are perfect. But the fact we still employ legislators rather implies we think we might need some legislating done.
- _yosefk 11y ago
- mimo84 11y agoI see how a lot of people in this thread are just conservative American thinking "government is bad" and "private is good". Very open minded for HN.