4 ms·
So, if you're trying to change public opinion, rather than changing the minds of the most people, you need to change the minds of the people who others respect
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
So, if you're trying to change public opinion, rather than changing the minds of the most people, you need to change the minds of the people who others respect and whose opinions influence those of others.
This also explains why some issues seem difficult to change public opinion on. For instance, if you want to get a majority of people to care about privacy, or more specific issues such as encryption backdoors and spying, you need those people's social circles to include many people who care. Since those people also tend to disproportionately avoid social networks...
- munificent 11y agoThis was basically official process for Scientology. That's why they deliberately aimed for celebrities—get them and (presumably) the rest will follow.
- nhaehnle 11y agoTwitter is another example of consciously making use of this.
- saurik 11y agoWait, but did that work?
- chippy 11y agoThe organisation appears to have been successful after implementing that approach. But causation doesnt imply etc etc
- saurik 11y agoThe reason I made that comment is that I would not in any way describe Scientology as "successful". Most of the stories I know of people who associated themselves with it are people who were leaned on by the organization and essentially forced to remain active. I also don't find myself thinking there are tons of people who are part of the organization, which was supposed to be the entire point of this strategy. I am actually kind of shocked that you say "the organization appears to have been successful after implementing that approach". Like, the idea wasn't just that they'd succeed in tricking people into thinking they had a ton of members and was successful, but that they would actually be successful, and that seems to not be the case. http://www.villagevoice.com/news/scientologists-how-many-of-them-are-there-anyway-6717701 http://www.villagevoice.com/news/scientologists-how-many-of-... "That's one Scientologist for about every 12,000 Americans. In other words, the total number of active U.S. Scientologists is about the size of your run-of-the-mill local credit union." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology "In 2008, the American Religious Identification Survey found that the number of American Scientologists had dropped to 25,000."
- ClashTheBunny 11y agoBut the fact that many people even have heard of Scientology means that it's far more successful than it should have been in an information based society. 25k is a ton of people for such a radical idea.
- michaelcampbell 11y agoI believe causation does in fact imply [correlation]. The reverse is not necessarily true.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoYup pretty much. People wonder how to change the opinion of any large group, and the answer is to get the "thought leaders" to agree and the rest will follow. So a good skill to acquire is watching to see gets things done and who doesn't.
- newscracker 11y agoIt's not necessary to have "thought leaders" to agree. What matters is how influential the person is among certain groups. This fact has been long used in getting "celebrities" endorse stuff to gain more publicity and momentum in several areas - be they product marketing or social causes - while the facts may be that these celebrities have absolutely no qualification or expertise whatsoever about the product or cause, and thus could not really be called "thought leaders". P.S.: Downvoted.
- unimpressive 11y ago>P.S.: Downvoted. Please don't make comments or edits about being downvoted or downvoting somebody else, see the HN guidelines for more information: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dhimes 11y agoChuckMcM was using jargon that is used especially in markets that are closely tied to academia (pharma, etc.) in which the thought leaders are the influential ones. Extending his 'metaphor' to other groups, thought leaders then would be the members of any group that influences how people think. Thus(sadly) it is true that athletes or other celebrities who may not be qualified or expert in a domain can be, ipso facto, thought leaders to a significant group.
- joe_the_user 11y agoThis is essentially one of the first modern theories of communication, articulated by Lazarsfeld and Katz in the 1940s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-step_flow_of_communication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-step_flow_of_communication
- chippy 11y agoI think the article hints that the reason why people voted the way they do is because they didn't have connections to the people close to them. We should encourage and increase the connections and links between people, rather than disrupt or change the links of the few with the most connections.