3 ms·
If Google wants its employees to experience the point of view of its customers, it should stake them with meaningful amounts of Google monopoly money, have them
by patio11 17y ago
If Google wants its employees to experience the point of view of its customers, it should stake them with meaningful amounts of Google monopoly money, have them actually attempt to achieve business goals with it, and put half of their salary on the line based on their CPC performance.
Every so often, something should go wrong -- subtly or otherwise -- and then the employee should have to go through seven redirects on the AdWords interface to locate the form to send a message to a representative. The message should, with 30% probability, never be read by anyone. If it is read, it will be read by someone in a call center in India, who does not know the customer is a Google employee, and has only a cursory knowledge of Google's own policies and none of the algorithms. Escalation should be nearly impossible to achieve, but if it happens, it should go to someone in Mountain View who is as unhelpful as possible to avoid giving the customer any incentive to ever call back.
For the fully authentic experience, if the employee doesn't like this state of affairs, they should be encouraged to either a) blog about it and pray that it ends up in Matt Cutt's feedreader or b) make a lateral move to Microsoft, for an instantaneous 90% reduction in salary.
Google employees who did this for a few weeks would have a much better sense of where AdWords advertisers are coming from than somebody who is playing with a toy account. (The Google employee experiences < 1% CTR and one click a day? Good, you may succeed in identifying where the buttons are in the AdWords interface. You have no idea what the actual use of the platform is like.)
- jacquesm 17y agoExtrapolating from 1 click per day is also really funny. For any kind of statistical relevance there ought to be a substantially larger number of impressions and clicks. The price per click is interesting information though, now it would be nice to know how much the publisher received of that $.88 (assuming it got paid out at all).
- netcan 17y agoThis is not an exaggeration (even though it's funny). I have had Google reps literally run out on me. IE, stop answering emails, supplying phone numbers that go nowhere etc. When I finally did get someone back on the phone to talk to, they acknowledged that they had stuffed up with their suggested "campaign optimisation" & that they must restore the old campaign. They promised to call back within 20 minutes once a person with more authority was located. I haven't heard back since, had to try & restore things myself. Even with this terrible service, this account still sent almost $1m to Google this year. In fact, we haven't even been able to get reasonable payment methods from Google & they still follow their hide, acknowledge then disappear CRM. This comes up a lot since credit cards don't always work well when you try to charge $2k every 5 hours. Adwords has all sorts of bugs that appear when the banks get suspicious about these.
- patio11 17y agoA bit of context for folks who don't know the back story: Netcan is (or works for) a fairly significant AdWords spender. (He has a few comments about AdWords on HN which are worth reading.) I spent about $6k on them in 2009, and they're directly responsible for about 40% of my revenue and 1/3 of my profits. My comment above which on second reading appears to be sarcastic and exaggerated is a literally accurate account of what I went through last August. See generally http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=790800 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=790800 or http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=791003 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=791003 and the blog post linked from the second comment. Full disclosure: I am a case study for how effective AdWords is. http://www.google.com/adwords/conversionoptimizer/bingocard.html http://www.google.com/adwords/conversionoptimizer/bingocard.... (And I'll say this: despite having worse customer service than the Japanese immigration authorities -- whose three part mission statement includes the words "Forcibly expelling undesirable foreigners from our nation" -- AdWords was and is the best advertising option that has ever been invented for small businesses.) Edit to add: On review of the posts I remembered, I realized that I appear to have mentally conflated netcan with a HN member named netsp. My apologies for my memory being dyslexic.
- netcan 17y agoNetcan & netsp are the same person (me) so it does apply. (sorry about that, I updated my profile to show this) You make an important point. This poor quality of service from Google hasn't affected their revenue from this advertiser(s) at all. Actually, several times a year the ads go down for a few hours due to a failed payment, CC issue or some payment related adwords bug while I drop everything & try to get a rep on the phone. I suppose that ads up to a few grand per year. But.. these are highly competitive areas. If we aren't on the page someone else is for a marginally lower CPC. BTW, your case study link doesn't work
- patio11 17y agoBTW, your case study link doesn't work I fixed it. My apologies for the typo.
- axod 17y agoThis is a slight exaggeration (IMHO). I've had one issue as far as I remember. Once one of my adgroups got suspended since it contained a copyrighted word. I called (Yes called) the support number in Ireland, and spoke to a real Google employee (My account manager), who knew exactly what was going on, and discussed with them. They looked up my account, advised me about options, and why it had been suspended and knew exactly what they were talking about. Maybe it's different depending on if you're in Europe/US. The Ireland support has been great. The other time I needed to call was when Google accidentally suspended my whole Google account. It took a few days, but they got it sorted eventually. The example is also a little extreme - I currently pay 5c for a click on average. So if I was that Goog employee, I'd be getting 20 clicks/day - not great, but valid statistically to draw some conclusions. Not everyone is paying 88c/click. It's really easy to beat up Google and complain. I'm pretty impressed they give their employees anything like this to play with.
- pbhjpbhj 17y ago>Once one of my adgroups got suspended since it contained a copyrighted word. I suspect you mean a trademark. You can not [normally #] copyright a word. # I'd love to hear from anyone who's got evidence of a word being copyrighted. I can imagine that a really long poem length word could be considered to be a work for the purposes of copyright?
- axod 17y agoYeah sorry... snow has frozen my brain. Trademark :) thanks.