3 ms·
No one wants actual stock. They want to gain money on price differences in stock, or get the dividends that owning stock gives rights to, or I suppose they wan
by kasey_junk 11y ago
No one wants actual stock. They want to gain money on price differences in stock, or get the dividends that owning stock gives rights to, or I suppose they want to be able to have the voting rights stocks grant.
The difference is all about timing. I may want something else more than you do but am willing to sell now. If at the time you close out your trade (that is sell the shares from me) the price may have risen or fallen. If it rose you won and I lost by not holding longer.
This time mitigation is precisely what market makers have always done and what HFT market makers have driven the profits (and thus the costs to outside participants) out of.
- Retric 11y agoBuying stock is trading future money than money today which is a real and meaningful trade. On the other side, I might want a new car, which means I want money, which means I want to sell stock. Even stock to stock transitions can be meaningful as Bill Gates had a lot of MS stock and wanted a hedge so he sold stock. What he got was probably worth 'less' the diversification was valuable to him making the transaction a net positive.
- kasey_junk 11y agoWhat you are talking about are precisely the aggregate benefits to the markets I mentioned, liquidity and easy risk management. That the markets provide those behaviors is what makes them valuable but the actual trades that make up those aggregates, your selling of shares when you need a car to someone else is zero sum. Either you would make more by holding or you wouldn't. That something other than that is more important to you indicates that you are in the market for a middle man to bridge that time gap and buy some of the risk from you. Your time horizon is from share purchase to "need money for car", not from share purchase to "optimal selling point". The service you take advantage of when you bridge that gap is provided by the aggregate work of many zero sum interactions between speculative participants like market makers and "investors" like your self.
- Retric 11y agoContinuing from the perspective of buying a car: If I put a sell order on the market at 12:00 the only impact is the sales price. If it executes at 1PM or 2PM it makes zero difference to me as I can only access money at the end of the day. So, I only gain liquidity if I would have been otherwise unable to sell by the end of the day. Therefore, I don't gain liquidity from HFT.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoIf you don't want liquidity don't buy it. No one is forcing you. https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/how_to_not_get_ripped_off_by_hft.html https://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/how_to_not_get_rippe...
- dragontamer 11y ago> get the dividends that owning stock gives rights to, or I suppose they want to be able to have the voting rights stocks grant. IE: People want actual stock. The stock has innate value due to the potential for dividends or to influence the future of a company. That is a significant amount of value.
- tomp 11y agoBut people don't care about value per se, they care about the extra value they get (over the price they're paying). Therefore, stock is only valuable inasmuch as what you pay for it is less than the present value of future dividends. Otherwise you're overpaying for it, and you might just as well keep the money.