4 ms·
It's an utterly brazen lie to say the company didn't know about this. Anyone who's ever built anything as part of a team - whether the Linux kernel, a space sh
by lordnacho 11y ago
It's an utterly brazen lie to say the company didn't know about this.
Anyone who's ever built anything as part of a team - whether the Linux kernel, a space shuttle, or a Lego set - can tell you design decisions like this cannot be secreted into the final product.
So let's say a software guy decides to make this fix. How do you do that?
- You'll have a version control system, won't you? At the very least someone will see it. There's some interesting if statements referencing the speed of the rear wheels, which you can explain at code review.
- How do you test it? I doubt your normal office happens to contain the entire running setup of a diesel engine, with nobody around to notice, and nobody needed to tell you about the details. Because you know, an engine test rig wouldn't have details, right? You just turn it on yourself, spin the car up to speed and debug, right? And I'm sure there's nothing complicated about gas measurement, even though it tends not to be a part of CS courses.
- What do you tell the cluelessly naive good guy engineer about his results? Would he really only test the car under test conditions? Does any engineer with even the slightest grain of curiosity test only the one mode that he's supposed to?
- bsder 11y ago> What do you tell the cluelessly naive good guy engineer about his results? Would he really only test the car under test conditions? Does any engineer with even the slightest grain of curiosity test only the one mode that he's supposed to? While I agree with the rest of your posts, I can't let this one slide. This happens ALL THE TIME. I have to beat engineers senseless over this on a regular basis. "Just because it passed one test, one time, does not mean you are done. It has to do something sane even when the rest of the world is coming flaming down around it. Crashing could be the sane thing to do; logging could be the sane thing to do; returning very obviously insane values is non-ideal, but might be your only option. A couple of safety checks are warranted."
- branchless 11y agoI guess they are worried about significant legal action against the top-brass and are throwing off some chaff. Will the legal system go after the little guy again or land the big fish?
- lordnacho 11y agoWell it's cases like this that cause people to win/lose respect for the system. If they throw some engineer under the bus, I don't want to live on this planet anymore.
- Havoc 11y ago>design decisions like this cannot be secreted into the final product. I'm not entirely convinced. You compare it to the Linux kernel. I'd say a better comparison is router firmware upgrades. If a manufacturing plant gets sent a new image with a note attached saying "HQ says use this one" then they're definitely going to load it onto the cars. Clearly someone cooked the image somewhere & there is likely to be version control in place but I doubt the whole thing is as transparent code-wise as you suggest.