4 ms·
The worst thing is, that according to the report he's both claiming that giving a login to strangers to "fuck it up" is "an act of journalism" and simultaneousl
by notahacker 11y ago
The worst thing is, that according to the report he's both claiming that giving a login to strangers to "fuck it up" is "an act of journalism" and simultaneously protesting that he's completely innocent and it must have been someone else using his login to pass another of his logins to hackers whilst masquerading as a person with a grudge against his ex-employer. It's basically the reductio ad absurdum version of all the more sensible arguments people have made about computer crime legislation not upholding free speech and giving insufficient attention to burden of proof.
I agree that this is the sort of low level vandalism whose sentencing time should be measured in days rather than years, but it doesn't really help the case of civil liberties when the usual supporters of the cause rush to make someone so undeserving a martyr.
- gozo 11y agoI wouldn't focus to much of what is said in proximity to court proceedings. When you're facing jail time you don't really have the luxury of doing anything else than trying to argue the best defense possible, often by embellishing or excusing your side of the story. Especially with the aggressive prosecution in the US.
- danso 11y agoKeys has been arguing this line for a while though. He's been unusually vocal in his own defense in the months leading up to the trial (compare that to how relatively quiet Aaron Swartz [0] was) -- and I think it's a calculated tactic. Not necessarily a wrong one, but Keys' reputation as being savvy about online and social media is very well deserved. But I think that it is likely to severely backfire on him. A lot about the justice system is public relations -- check out the press releases feed at the Dept of Justice [1]...and he's doubling down in such a way that the prosecutors and judge can only lose face if they go lenient with him. The best defense for him is to be contrite and ask for leniency -- that's the whole point of his defense lawyers arguing that it was just a simple webpage defacement. Instead, he's arguing federal-level type coverup and incompetency, from the FBI investigation to the jury-by-trial itself. If the judge slaps him on the wrist, the judge is basically insinuating "Yeah, you're right...our court system is a joke!". From what I can tell, not many judges choose to go that route. [0] http://techcrunch.com/2013/01/14/aaron-swartz-asking-for-help-119-days-ago/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/01/14/aaron-swartz-asking-for-hel... [1] http://www.justice.gov/doj/news-feeds http://www.justice.gov/doj/news-feeds
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoMost Journalists think that laws are for little people and that the end justifies the means - just look at News International and how hundreds of journalists have got off on a technicality.
- wpietri 11y agoThe journalists I know definitely don't think News International is representative of their field. If you'd like to tar most journalists with that particular brush, you'll have to try harder.
- mc32 11y agoTrue, true, but there are journalists who don't hesitate to paint with broad brushes and push buttons in order to get page views or please an audience and seldom get called out by more reputable journalists.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoReally there a substantial minority of GMG Journalists who supported the NI line and where openly anti investigating it. And the General Public certainly thinks Journalist are not trustworthy. And don't forget even progressive Journalists do freelance work for NI so they have to keep their head down