3 ms·
My startup: Genetic testing for CCR5 delta 32 (HIV Resistance)
- rms 19y agoThanks news.yc. What do you think? This is our first site to be selling tests, we've got something of a business plan involving marketing different genetic tests to different audiences: men, women, b2b, etc. Send me an email if you'd like to see one of our other, flashier sites that isn't quite ready for launch.
- mynameishere 19y ago* target audiences * Craigslist m4m?
- motoko 19y agoDespite your crudeness... that's actually not a bad idea...
- mynameishere 19y agoI'm almost certain that that's what he meant (or something close to it). If not, then he hasn't looked into the relevant statistics, or doesn't understand marketing. EDIT: Well, I guess he has looked in the relevant statistics.
- rms 19y agoCertainly men who have sex with men are a scientifically studied group with regards to CCR5 delta 32. We link to this study on the site. http://hsphsun3.harvard.edu/faculty/seage/JAIDS2001-27-p472.pdf http://hsphsun3.harvard.edu/faculty/seage/JAIDS2001-27-p472....
- henning 19y agoWhy is the term MSM used instead of "gay men"?
- motoko 19y agoThey take away your Science Sounding Licence (SSL) if you fail to meet your TLA quota.
- rms 19y agoBecause not all men who have sex with men consider themselves gay. And some gay men are celibate. For this study, at least, MSM is the most relevant term.
- henning 19y agoWhat does it matter if they don't consider themselves gay? If you smoke crack on a regular basis, you're a crackhead, regardless of whether you identify as one or not. Denial is irrelevant. Some straight men are celibate. They still get called "heterosexual", though. Straight men who are not celibate are not called "men who have sex with women" (MSW?).
- rms 19y ago>What does it matter if they don't consider themselves gay? Well... this is mostly semantics here, but the term MSM is what makes the denial irrelevant.
- curi 19y agomaybe they have sex with women, too. then "gay" doesn't fit so well.
- mnemonicsloth 19y ago> What does it matter if they don't consider themselves gay? They might be bisexual. The be trans-something. They might have other problems that make the sex and gender of their sex partners irrelevant: http://www1.villagevoice.com/people/0804,savage,78927,24.html http://www1.villagevoice.com/people/0804,savage,78927,24.htm... There is a good answer to your question having to do with the semiotics of sex and gender which is practical, smart, and important in day-to-day life (even if the people who wrote it all want to dig up the remains of Jacques Derrida so they can stare at his navel some more). I'm not going post it here because you probably don't want to read it, but you should know that the people who look down their noses at you for saying stuff like this aren't just doing it because of some feel-good PC nonsense.
- bayareaguy 19y agoGranted this is not something most people probably would expect when they go for a checkup, but have you considered some kind of kit dentists could use or offer?
- apathy 19y agoIn the Castro I could see it becoming a huge hit... hell my old hairdresser could probably make a mint pushing these.
- davidw 19y ago+1 It certainly beats that other junk you were trying to push:-)
- edw519 19y agoYou mean the memory stuff?...I forgot what it's called.
- nextmoveone 19y agoYou should use Authorize.net to process your payments...so your customer can stay on your site...I wouldnt like having to go to google to pay if I was going to buy.
- rms 19y agoI agree, it's on our to-do list. Though Google's $.20 + 2% - adwords discount is anticompetitively good.
- kirubakaran 19y ago+1 for 'anticompetitively good' :)
- dcurtis 19y agoDoesn't google have a really nice API that you can use to make the process mostly transparent?
- sspencer 19y agoIs there any guarantee of confidentiality? I looked in the FAQ and saw nothing. This seems like a very sensitive test; I would not submit anything to someone who did not _absolutely guarantee_ confidentiality. Even then, I would be a little wary of doing something like this over the web.
- rms 19y agoYes, privacy is of paramount importance. We would only disclose information if we were legally compelled to do so. I will add this to the FAQ.
- sspencer 19y agoYou may even want to crank out some legalese about precisely what is done with the info: how long it is retained, what exact circumstances would compel you to release it, etc. Sounds like you have the right idea, though.
- icky 19y agoPossible privacy hole: What's to prevent someone from acquiring a sample of someone else's DNA and sending it off for you to test?
- pius 19y agoThis is a great idea. I think that you should work on the presentation of the site, though. In the Web 2.0 world it's considered stylish or at least excusable to have a very barebones site, but the average person needs a more reassuring presence in order to trust someone with sensitive medical information.
- motoko 19y agoThis is something that we've discussed. Actually, we've left the site looking "barebones" as an explicit design decision. People can be put-off by something "too slick," especially when you position yourself as a simple, single-product company, and especially in the research/academic world. But you are right, too. We are working on other brands with more premium product which we will release soon. The designs of these sites will reflect the more premium brand. Email rms for more information if you're interested, he's our news.yc baron.
- dcurtis 19y agoBarebones is nice, but it looks like a spam site or a template of some sort. It actually reduces customer confidence in that case. Are you trying to follow the 23andme model, but only testing for a single gene?
- motoko 19y agoHey, I absolutely agree with you. I also think that McDonald's tastes like puke, but they run one hell of a franchise business.
- webwright 19y agoI think it's interesting and (if it were free) I'd want to know (even the me 10 years ago who wasn't married would). But what problem does it solve? Why (besides curiosity) would I want that? Is it for HIV positive people to who might be hoping for a slow progression? For people who just want to feel a little more comfortable having lots of unprotected sex? I guess I can see the former... Though I would think that the audience is relatively small (and hopefully getting smaller) and would be looking to their doctor for stuff like this.
- tlrobinson 19y agoAgreed. I know nothing about this gene, but I doubt it would be wise to go around having lots of unprotected sex just because a test from some random company said you were resistant to HIV. I think it would actually be irresponsible and dangerous if that were the explicit or implied message. A lawsuit waiting to happen. Make sure it's clear to your clients that that's not the case.
- rms 19y agoFor now, it is for information purposes only -- to satisfy curiosity. The state of the current research into CCR5 delta 32 doesn't allow for treatment decisions to be made -- it is known that CCR5 delta32 slows down the progression of HIV to AIDS, but you can't adjust medication dosage based on this. Similarly, scientists have concluded that individuals with CCR5 delta 32 in high risk populations are less likely to have HIV. But that study is based on an after the fact study of the group. It would be irresponsible for us to encourage unprotected sex and foolish for anyone to make a decision like that. So what problem are we solving? I'm not sure that there is a real problem here, beyond a lack of genetic testing services. We're offering a service providing information and some people are more curious than others about this particular information.
- daniel-cussen 19y agoI could see you selling it to people who have been told they have AIDS, but want to see if they are actually immune and don't need the expensive (around 20,000 a year, last I've heard) medicine.
- apathy 19y agoFix the "Huntingdon's disease" typo, for heaven's sake. You're asking people to view your company as an authority on the topic. Typos detract from that credibility.
- gojomo 19y agoDoes 23andMe or anyone else in the space bundle testing for this gene in their larger/more-expensive packages?
- rms 19y agoNo, 23andMe only tests for SNPs (Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms) and this is a 32 base pair deletion.
- apathy 19y agoI forgot to include explicitly in my anti-23andMe rant that deletions, repeat polymorphisms, and the like were not included in their product's results. Thanks for reminding me :-)
- sungam 19y agoLeaving aside the doubtful utility of this test you really must provide some information about who is behind this company, what techniques will you use to perform the test? What expertise do you have in molecular diagnostics? How do potential customers know that you are not simply taking the money and sending out random results?
- ingenium 19y agoWe've discussed putting how we do the test on the site, but concluded that we were best off not disclosing that information, seeing as no other genetic testing companies explain the techniques they use to do the testing. I guess you could call it a trade secret, even though anyone with experience in the field could figure it out pretty easily. As for expertise in molecular diagnostics, I've been doing research at a hospital for a couple years now designing and developing tests such as this. Furthermore, most of these techniques are now taught in undergraduate level molecular biology labs. For the last question, I suppose the same can be said for any company doing genetic testing. It would be unethical to simply take money and send out random results, though this could be a valid concern to some people. Do you have any suggestions on how we can prove the legitimacy of the results?
- greendestiny 19y agoDisclosing who you are, qualifications and relevant experience would be good I think. If you don't feel comfortable putting them up then you'd have to understand customers might not feel comfortable using your service.
- timr 19y ago1) What's to prevent someone else from selling a test for the same thing? Surely, you're not the first to consider a test for this mutation, right? 2) Also, I think you're going to have to be very careful with your copy. You're selling an unapproved genetic test, for which the only real purpose is to give people confidence that they can't be infected by HIV (don't split hairs -- this is how 99% of the population is going to view your service). The medical establishment is going to denounce you without a second thought, and I wouldn't be surprised if an enterprising lawyer tries to make a case against you for encouraging unsafe sex. 3) What are your error rates? 4) Your email input box is overlapping with your bullets under firefox 2 for mac.
- ingenium 19y ago1. There is little to nothing preventing competitors, though I would be surprised if anyone can compete with us on price. 2. I agree. A startup is inherently risky and we are taking every precaution we can. 3. Error rates are effectively 0% as far as the technique goes. The only possibility of error is human error in handling. Our testing procedures are specifically designed to minimize the risk of human error. Furthermore, due to the nature of the testing procedure, any possible errors would result in false negatives, not false positives. In addition, we have a policy of retesting all positive results. 4. Noted, thanks... it does the same thing in Safari also.
- timr 19y agoI'm suspicious of your claims in 3. What method are you using? Certainly not RFLP, right? Are you sequencing the gene? A labeled oligonucleotide, targeted toward the deletion? I'm having a hard time conceiving of a method with zero error rate (either type I or II).
- omgz3rgrush 19y agoThis site doesn't look trustworthy at all. Sorry..but for all I know you guys are just making up the results. Without more information on who you are, or how you do the testing, or some sort of certification from a trusted source, I wouldn't use this service because I don't know if the testing is accurate.
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- daniel-cussen 19y agoIs it possible to be diagnosed with HIV, not know you have CCR5, and mistakenly purchase the medicine?
- rms 19y agoVery, very unlikely. And you would still want to see a doctor and have your viral loads regularly checked.
- rms 19y agoOld discussion on CCR5: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47751 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47751 Includes Josh's idea for curing HIV