9 ms·
Batteries for homes and businesses could already make economic sense
- chaostheory 11y agoIt already makes sense in the 3rd world where rolling blackouts and unplanned blackouts are quite common.
- dghughes 11y agoIt makes sense in the first world too to have a stable source of power at all times. By that I mean medical reasons I know someone who has a home dyalysis machine and absolute uninterruptable power is required.
- MBlume 11y agoI honestly can't understand what use patterns the article is suggesting. "During these hours, the report argues, the battery could be “dispatched” elsewhere to helps smooth supply and demand on the grid" Do they actually mean moving the battery, or something else?
- maxerickson 11y agoIt's jargon, it just means using the energy, with some implication of centralized management. So as an example, natural gas peak load plants are dispatched when there is a sudden increase in demand.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoArbitrage. The price of power changes every few minutes (wholesale) to a utility. They shield you from this with flat rates per kwh or tiers. With battery arbitrage, you switch to a time of day metering scheme where you're exposed to dynamic pricing. The benefit, of course, is that you can charge when power is cheap, and run off your battery when power is expensive. A great example: I reside in Illinois for part of the year. My utility provides power from nuclear plants, which cannot be idled. That means, at night, I can get power between midnight and 5am for about 1 cent/kwh. If batteries get cheap enough, cheap power + batteries means I save money. Most electric vehicle charge controllers are already "smart" in this regard, and can charge when power drops below a certain price.
- dogma1138 11y agoThe only problem with this is that this will be a zero sum game. If peak power consumption drops electric companies will start charging higher rates for off-peak hours or drop the off-peak rate completely. Anything that will eventually lower the revenue of the electrical companies won't really be supported by them, however if they can employ batteries to "flatten" their peaks they might be contempt with keeping the current rates as long as is financially beneficial for them.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> The only problem with this is that this will be a zero sum game. If peak power consumption drops electric companies will start charging higher rates for off-peak hours or drop the off-peak rate completely. Which will push those who can to local rooftop solar generation. We've already entered what the utilities refer to as a "death spiral" [+]. > Anything that will eventually lower the revenue of the electrical companies won't really be supported by them, however if they can employ batteries to "flatten" their peaks they might be contempt with keeping the current rates as long as is financially beneficial for them. Agree. [+] http://cleantechnica.com/2015/06/11/graph-of-the-day-what-a-utility-death-spiral-looks-like/ http://cleantechnica.com/2015/06/11/graph-of-the-day-what-a-...
- dogma1138 11y agoSolar is still very expensive at around 10K$ an upwards in the US and considerably more expensive in Europe, solar is also not an option for the majority of residents in the big cities where electrical supply is usually a bigger issue. I'm personally not a big believer in residential solar, it can't be as efficient as dedicated solar installations and the cost overhead for so many small scale installations pretty much outweigh the benefits in the long run. I do however believe that many smaller communities should be powered with renewable energy where possible. It can allow you to build much bigger and more efficient installations of wind and solar, won't require you to convert it to high voltage in order to connect it back to the grid/transfer it along large distances and your energy storage is also much easier.
- Shivetya 11y agoin the home, no thank you. however within substations, or perhaps subdivision localized power storage facilities, or lets go even further, charging stations for cars, I can see it. Utility setup and managed charging stations replete with a lot of battery storage soaking up wind, sun, and base line power when off peak usage times, providing both a source to recharge EVs and serve peak power usage times. To insure adequate power on hand they could charge EVs based on time of day to move people off peak. because honestly, the last thing I want in six hundred to thousand pounds of lithium batteries in my home.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- joe_the_user 11y agothe last thing I want in six hundred to thousand pounds of lithium batteries in my home. Think for a second. If there was danger to the batteries then like a propane tank or similar thing, a home battery would be in an enclosure some distance from one's house.
- snowwrestler 11y agoI've got pressurized natural gas lines into my basement and running to my hot water heater, to my furnace, and to my stove. These appliances actually release and burn that gas, sometimes only a foot or two away from me. It's kind of crazy, if you think about it. I barely know a thing about how these work and why they are safe. I just pay professionals to show up and install or maintain the things--and that happens very rarely. No one has looked at my stove or water heater since the home inspection years ago. My point is, there are seemingly risky technologies all around us, which we ignore out of familiarity. I'm not going to buy the very first Tesla battery--I'm not an early adopter in general--but I see no reason to reject lithium-ion battery technology entirely. I mean, I press a small lithium-ion battery directly against my head on a regular basis, with only a thin sheet of glass to protect me.
- beambot 11y agoIn order to "dispatch" power as-needed, you need buy in from municipal power companies to grid-connect the supply (or generation). As we're seeing (eg. in Hawaii), the power company becomes less-and-less incentivized to permit grid-connections as the rate of decentralized supply (or generation) increases. What I'd really like to know: How will the power companies adapt to new, decentralized generation (or storage) on a massive scale? Or alternatively: The municipal power companies budgeted their massive expenditures over decades; does this analysis account for all the expenses municipal power companies will necessarily incur (and pass to consumers) if the status quo shifts?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoHomeowners in Hawaii are using batteries to go completely off the grid, so as to not be required to get permission from the utility for their solar grid tie connection. The upside is, once the utility comes around to investing in their transmission infrastructure, they can receive power from those houses. http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/19/business/energy-environment/solar-power-battle-puts-hawaii-at-forefront-of-worldwide-changes.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/19/business/energy-environmen... “I’ve actually taken people right off the grid,” he said, including a couple who got tired of waiting for Hawaiian Electric to approve their solar system and expressed no interest in returning to utility service. “The lumbering big utilities that are so used to taking three months to study this and then six months to do that — what they don’t understand is that things are moving at the speed of business. Like with digital photography — this is inevitable.”
- brandmeyer 11y agoWell, right now many of the Independant System Operators (ISO's) have specific markets for frequency support which are theoretically separate from the market for energy supply. So as distributed renewable dump-as-much-as-available style generation gets added to the grid, in principle the price for frequency support increases. In the same vein, distributed energy storage works very well for frequency support, which can drive the price for that service downwards. That still leaves the wires themselves. At the residential level, you typically pay a flat connection fee for the wires (and distribution and maintenance thereof). Commercial sites pay a Demand Charge for their peak total power consumption at any time during the billing period. So that's how the interconnect infrastructure gets paid for - the commercial demand and residential interconnect charges.
- bavcyc 11y agoPower is currently dispatched according to the most efficient units run most frequently. Peaking units run only when it is most cost effective, i.e. power is needed and there are not cheaper options. Yes it is possible to store the energy (one method is pumped storage) for peak shaving, but different methods have different break even points. Also of interest is the Clean Power Plan and how it will change the generation mixture. A battery is not available 24 hours as the article indicates. There is the time to charge and the time to discharge. There is also the time for maintenance activities on the batteries. If a battery system or solar system is installed then it breaks and power is wanted from the local utility, the utility has the costs associated with supplying that power with less time in use although it is expected to be available at need and at the peak demand for all customers. Will end users be willing to pay for the emergency back up or will another solution be found? How long will it take to repair battery or solar when it breaks? And what do you do for power until is repaired (if you don't use the utility)? Using more energy efficient building technologies, e.g. ICF or something like enteria.com; will probably be useful in combination with batteries. And using a chest fridge as a refrigerator can also help: http://newlifeonahomestead.com/convert-chest-freezer-to-fridge-solar/ http://newlifeonahomestead.com/convert-chest-freezer-to-frid... (one example from the google search results). It is an interesting time as energy use and supply are modified. 30-50 years ago, a 15-50 minute outage wasn't that big of deal, but today it is expected that power is always available. Interesting how our perspective changes.
- transfire 11y agoIf we could get in-house/building DC power (not to replace but to complement AC power) and get industries to make digital products work with this we could get another substantial savings in energy efficiency. Plus digital products would cost less b/c they wouldn't all need AC to DC adapters.
- brandmeyer 11y agoUnfortunately, unplugging DC power plugs under load tends to damage them much more than the equivalent AC plugs. Similarly, DC rated circuit breakers and fuses are much larger than their AC counterparts. The reason is that the zero-crossing of the AC voltage waveform naturally allows the developed arc an opportunity to be extinguished. DC current/voltage has no such zero crossing.
- badsock 11y agoI believe transfire is talking about low voltage DC.
- simcop2387 11y agoThe problem with low voltage DC wiring is that it requires much more metal to prevent serious losses in the lines. You could switch to higher in the lines and then a converter in the wall but then you're back to the same circuit breaker problem. AC deals with this by the fact that zero crossing gives a great way to break arcs and you can convert it to DC really efficiently.
- caf 11y agoI believe the idea is probably to have one large switchmode converter running off the mains at the POE that supplies, say, dual rail 20VDC / 5VDC throughout the building, replacing the umpteen smaller converters in the average house. Not sure it would end up being a net win.
- 11y ago
- DorothyS 11y agoThere always is sense in self-renewing energy sources. Especially, when it comes to saving our environment and lives. Implementing of such batteries would be beneficial for everyone. And it would finally let the mankind get rid of petroleum fever, which is now a source of all evils and the main cause of all wars.