5 ms·
I found three things very sad about that article; these guys were raised to a strict religious code but had no idea about right and wrong, they had no problem r
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I found three things very sad about that article; these guys were raised to a strict religious code but had no idea about right and wrong, they had no problem rationalizing their behavior to themselves and others, and they ended up with a fat exit because the guardians of sleeze on Wall Street bought them out.
Really? Sort of encapsulated the attitudes of some of the worst sorts of people who exploit "perfectly legal" loopholes to prey on people.
- Retric 11y agoDepending on what there books looked like they might have gotten similar returns winding down the company, it's not like there going to spend 20 million this year.
- protomyth 11y agoThat's basically the difference between being raised as a biblical rules lawyer and being raised with a moral compass. I've noticed empathy seems to be the opposite of rules. Its not unique to Christianity or even religion, but you would think people who claim to study the New Testament would see their relation to some of the people mentioned as having conflicts with Jesus. I mean, its not like it doesn't hit you over the head with "don't be like that". They also slip into the "any means to an end" side of the spectrum which I find the true one phrase definition of evil.
- JesperRavn 11y agoThe people in the article are Jewish, not Christian, so I'm not why a critique of Christianity is relevant here. What is your opinion on Judaism?
- protomyth 11y agoI have more experience with Christians doing the biblical rules lawyering than Jews, but its not an unknown way to learn codes in any religion. I'm pretty sure empathy is a shared trait from the common books from the Old Testament for both Christians and Jews[1]. 1) On a side note, Catholics and Protestants have different Old Testaments. [edit: folks JesperRavn has a legitimate question - be nice]
- austinsharp 11y ago'Different' Old Testaments is a somewhat misleading thing to say. The vast majority of the Old Testament is the same - Catholics include the Deuterocanonical books that most (but not all) Protestant churches do not[1]. There's a lot of interesting history behind this, but my understanding is that Catholics don't necessarily put these books on the same level as the broadly accepted Old Testament, but include them in printings nonetheless. I've heard that they were dropped from Protestant Bibles to save money on printing, but I have no idea if this story is true. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deuterocanonical_books https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deuterocanonical_books
- protomyth 11y ago> 'Different' Old Testaments is a somewhat misleading thing to say. The Catholic Old Testament has 46 books and the Protestant Bible has 39 books. 46 and 39 are different numbers and it is not misleading to say that they are different. A red car is different from the same model in blue.
- kenbellows 11y agoIt's not incorrect, but it is misleading. It's not so much that Catholics have a different Old Testament; it's more like they have extra Old Testament. Similarly, if you have a copy of the first edition of a book and I buy a second edition of a book with an added epilogue, it would be misleading to say that we have different books. The book are completely the same, but one has some extra content. Again, it's not technically wrong, just misleading to someone unfamiliar with the topic at hand. In terms of relevance to the conversation, the reason it's misleading is that the moral codes and content present in the Protestant OT is all present in the Catholic OT as well; the Catholic OT has a little more, but by and large, they are pulling from the same moral background. Saying that they have different OTs in this context seems to suggest that this is not the case, and that Catholics and Protestants have a different set of sources for, e.g., moral guidance and teaching.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIndeed, you would expect more from Christians than from Jews, given that big parts of New Testament are about replacing the rule-based thinking of Old Testament with empathy and conscience-based principles.
- protomyth 11y agoI personally don't think I would expect any difference, but that is one of the major differences between all the branches of Christianity: "how much of the Old Testament has been rewritten by the New".
- api 11y agoIf the only reason something is bad is because a big guy will send you to hades, then once you stop believing in that then nothing is evil and everything is permitted. It's not really a moral code at all, since there is no understanding of morality. It's just "don't do X or God will whack you." Two of the least moral people I've ever meet were raised fundamentalist. A part of their atheist conversion was to realize there is no morality and that humans are "just animals" (in the words of one). It's a perfectly rational conclusion if force wielded by God is the only basis for moral action.
- xacaxulu 11y agoOne could argue that some the worst things happen precisely when you think you have god on your side. In the paraphrased words of Christopher Hitchens, "The suicide bombing communities and the child genital mutilation communities are almost entirely faith-based."
- cpr 11y agoYes, but it's taboo (this will get downvoted hard) to point out that neither the Christian nor Jewish communities are involved in such activities. (Not that Christians and Jews as a group are sinless, of course.)
- homonculus1 11y agoChristians and Jews are pretty heavily involved in child genital mutilation.