2 ms·
I don't think there's a real way to fight this in the age of networks and cameras in every pocket. Sure there is. For one thing, a similar level of technology
by Silhouette 11y ago
I don't think there's a real way to fight this in the age of networks and cameras in every pocket.
Sure there is.
For one thing, a similar level of technology to the capture and processing applications could also be used to automatically detect and obscure faces where storing them isn't necessary, probably with imperfect but highly reliable success. Consider how Google's Street View wound up hiding car licence plates for a lot of places after the privacy complaints, for example.
For another thing, the problem with a lot of modern privacy invasions is asymmetry: large, powerful organisations like big businesses or governments can do a lot more to you with lots of information than you can do to them in return.
This could be solved for businesses by imposing rules and meaningful penalties for violating them. Facebook isn't going to be processing anyone's face for dubious reasons if it's subject to compulsory scrutiny on account of processing a high volume of personal data and the penalties for repeated breaking of the rules escalate as significant percentages of annual revenue. For deliberate violations, you could remove the corporate shield from the responsible executives as well, as with other criminal conduct.
Governments is harder, because right now the governments of the West seem to be more hostile to their own people than to foreign surveillance. Ideally, our governments would actually be on our side, and the vast resources they seem to be devoting to invading their own people's privacy would instead be devoted to protecting it. Imagine how much safer we would all be from things like fraud, identity theft, commercial espionage, and worse, if instead of trying to exploit vulnerabilities and limit secure communications, organisations like the NSA and GCHQ helped to close vulnerabilities and promote safe and secure use of technology by everyone. Like everyone else, I don't know exactly what the real threat from terrorism is, but I'm pretty sure the potential savings to our economies alone from safer technology would run to many billions.
- scott_karana 11y ago> Consider how Google's Street View wound up hiding car licence plates for a lot of places after the privacy complaints, for example. Right, isn't that just "hiding the microphone"? Google still has records of your license plates. Can agencies subpoena them for that information? Can Google themselves use it maliciously? The technology exists, and will be used, even if it's not accessible to the public. How much do you trust our information oracles?
- Silhouette 11y agoYes, those are all valid concerns as well. I was just demonstrating what is technically possible, not asserting that current practice is sufficient. If Google applied that same fuzzing to its own internal copy of the images, it would not have records of everyone's licence plates any more. I don't know whether they do this today, but we could empower the official regulators to investigate such things in reasonable ways, for example by mandating greater disclosure of working practices or some sort of inspection regime for organisations processing high volumes of personal data.