13 ms·
Global coalition to Facebook: “Authentic names” are dangerous for your users
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoI wish to God that Google+ had done the right thing on names during their five minutes of relevance. They might have actually lasted as a viable Facebook competitor.
- LordKano 11y agoGoogle needed Facebook to have a MySpace moment to open the door but their insistence on real names, binding all of your accounts (Gmail, Youtube, etc) to your Google+ account and Google's history of unceremoniously dropping support for services if they under-perform kept me and millions of others from going there.
- seiji 11y agoIsn't it kinda obvious the long game of facebook is to become the single globally mandated identity service? Governments will contract with them to maintain your official citizen ID records. Game over.
- artursapek 11y agoI can't imagine the government mandating something like that. I haven't used Facebook in four years.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoI can't, either, but it's an interesting thought in a twisted dystopian kind of way...
- junto 11y agoYou should read "The Circle". It is basically that and more.
- seiji 11y agoThe book was awful in all the right ways. It was a perfect example of SV employees "going native" and surrendering their entire sense of self worth over to the desires of their employer. It tracked the ways startups indoctrinate naive employees into to their cults of personality pretty accurately. Company as Godhead. If the protagonist drank any more koolaid she would have become the koolaid man herself. After all, without that external sense of approval, you are worthless. One for all, and all for the billionaires. It's a case study in trojan horsing your way to the top though. Company offers shiny service X, but with nefarious capabilities (surveillance, tracking, blackmail) nobody considers, because, hey, shiny selfies!!! Sign up now for my 2016 course: Defense Against the Dark Software
- qznc 11y agoI found The Circle entertaining. As an argument against Facebook (or Google,Amazon,etc) it just sets up a strawman. Not realistic enough. That politicians can be pressured into 24/7 live streaming is ridiculous. The Circle has no serious opponents, while in reality there are more powers which would acquire or destroy Facebook if they attempted something like that.
- seiji 11y agoYou may be a little oblivious to how Facebook has "like" buttons, which are also javascript tracking beacons, on basically every site online. Well, "Facebook" doesn't have them there, the site owners include them willingly, serving up the privacy of their users in exchange for "engagement." Billions of tracking beacons spread around the Internet give Facebook a real time click-by-click bread-cumb trail of almost your entire thought process and Internet experiential reality (reminder: use uBlock Origin with everything enabled). Google has the email of probably over a billion people. Sure, there are safeguards to prevent employee naughtiness (supposedly there are now, after years of "lol, i'm a sysadmin and i'll read the email of my ex" abuse), but if they wanted, they could do a lot of damage and there's nobody capable of stopping them. Heck, let's not even include google analytics. Sure, they say there is a "corporate firewall" between the global analytic record of every web user alive and the rest of the company, but we just have to trust them. Trust Google. Trust Facebook. Trust VW. It's only software created by and data retained by for-profit corporations in constant competition who must meet growth targets or else the market will punish them. What could go wrong? (Amazon doesn't have a bird in this fight.) Old quote (from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUXh-GPa5dI&t=36m00 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUXh-GPa5dI&t=36m00): "In some respects, it's pretty clear that we are sleepwalking into nightmares. Absolutely. And the most distressing thing is how hard that is to explain to anybody. The way in which people will give away their personal details in much the way as in the child history books about colonialism. You had native chieftains who handed over mineral rights in return from some baubles from some canny imperialist. All that stuff is happening but it's very hard to explain to anybody."
- hellbanner 11y agoOne of the investors in FB held a previous position at the CIA's investment company. https://www.corbettreport.com/meet-in-q-tel-the-cias-venture-capital-firm-preview/ https://www.corbettreport.com/meet-in-q-tel-the-cias-venture...
- 1ris 11y agoAnd in fact illegal in Germany and probably a hell lot of other places. I wonder if that gets enforced anytime soon.
- jawns 11y agoI'm sincerely curious ... how is a social network like Facebook, which is built around connecting you with your real-world friends and acquaintances, supposed to work if you can't require users to identify themselves in a meaningful way? The little "people you may know" widget is really useful, because it shows me names I recognize from my offline life. If it's just a random stream of pseudonyms and online handles, there's no way I can find my long-lost friends and former co-workers and classmates.
- PhasmaFelis 11y ago> I'm sincerely curious ... how is a social network like Facebook, which is built around connecting you with your real-world friends and acquaintances, supposed to work if you can't require users to identify themselves in a meaningful way? "Hey, Steve, what's your Facebook name?" "Goku35179." "Cool, I'm friending you." If your long-lost friends and former co-workers and classmates do not choose to be findable, that should be their decision to make. But that was always only a secondary use case for Facebook.
- pjc50 11y agoWell, they're not using the name you know because they don't want you or other casual acquaintances to find them.
- jawns 11y agoIt seems like this sort of privacy control could be put in place without resorting to pseudonyms. For instance: you register using your real name/"authentic identity", but you select a restrictive privacy option that says that your profile won't show up when people search for your name on Facebook; nobody can friend-request you; and all your posts and other info is visible to friends only. Voila, you now have a private profile, but the people whom you are friends with on Facebook don't have to create a user script that replaces your pseudonym with the name they actually know you by.
- Animats 11y agoReal names keep Facebook spam down. You can report real name violations to make spam accounts go away. That's worth doing. Giving that up to make a tiny number of drag queens happy isn't worth it.
- cableshaft 11y agoEvery teacher I know either doesn't use Facebook at all, or if they do, they don't use their real name. Why? Because they know that their students are going to look for them on Facebook out of curiosity and gossip amongst themselves about any detail that's on there (or if it's locked down, try to sneak onto their friends list and then gossip). They often have to be very careful or else they could easily get in trouble. One of those people will actually leave a movie theater if they spot one of her students in the same movie, because she knows from experience they'll take pictures of her on their cell phones and try to catch her saying or doing something even slightly off. Teaching can't be the only profession where people want to be careful about using their real names so they can easily be found by anyone who wants to look. And it certainly isn't just a tiny number of drag queens either.
- Karunamon 11y agoSo the idea is we give up social networking entirely because a small percentage of people are jerks? Doesn't that seem a little defeatist?
- x3n0ph3n3 11y agoNo, because a large percentage of people are jerks.
- jleader 11y agoNo, we require our social networks to provide us with meaningful, usable, robust privacy controls. When they don't do well enough at that (difficult) task, we insist on our own privacy measures, such as pseudonymous use.
- detaro 11y ago
- vectorjohn 11y agoI don't understand why people make anything of "real names" policies. They just want the users to have real looking names. They don't actually have any way to force real names. So it's a non-issue. There's no oppressed person in a police state signing up for Facebook that reads a EULA and concludes "well, Facebook said I have to reveal my true identity, I guess that's the way it is."
- anseljh 11y agoDid you read the post?
- publicfig 11y agoBecause many people have had accounts disabled or names changed back for trying to change their name.
- mjquinn 11y agoThey can and do enforce the real name policy. If they suspect your name isn't real (via algorithm or user reports) they will freeze your account until you send them scans of government ID confirming your name. I have a friend with an unusual name, and she's had to go through the process twice thanks to harassers flagging her.
- VLM 11y ago"thanks to harassers flagging her" This is a fairly significant and under discussed problem. Rush Limbaugh is probably safe from harassment... that dude commenting in some political group is not so immune. This creates an interesting chilling effect.
- acabal 11y agoExactly! I have a similar policy at the community I operate. Members have to sign up with a real-sounding pen name. I'm very flexible on that too. All that means is you can't sign up with a pen name like "CRaZzE BlOgGeR". I don't care if your pen name is your real name or not--it just can't sound like a dumb made-up internet username. And yet people still email me daily, enraged that they can't sign up for a professional online community with the pen name of "BitterDoll SweetBear". This kind of policy goes a long way towards the perception of professionalism at any web site. You're probably not going to take a person named "Spazmo Jones" as seriously as you would "Amy Wong". It's a sort of broken window theory. (And yes, all of the examples above are pen names people actually tried to sign up with!)
- junto 11y agoI use Facebook as a developer using a completely fake but real looking identity. I have to have a developer account because of my job. Otherwise I wouldn't touch the site with someone else's bargepole. Thank you http://www.fakenamegenerator.com http://www.fakenamegenerator.com If that account gets blocked then I'll just have to create another fake one.
- oniTony 11y agoWhy not use actual Test Users for development? https://developers.facebook.com/docs/apps/test-users https://developers.facebook.com/docs/apps/test-users
- hoorayimhelping 11y agoI think what GP is saying is that you need a Facebook account to get a developer account, so they create fake identities to attach to developer accounts.
- jleehey 11y agoI believe you're required to have a real, verified account in order to create and modify test users, and I think there are certain features that are blocked for test users.
- nathancahill 11y agoMore generally, to access and edit app settings.
- baby 11y agoWhy not create a second account for work under your real name?
- scintill76 11y agoI don't think they have a real first account. They only created an account at all because they needed it for work, and they didn't give it any real information because they didn't want Facebook to have it.
- otto 11y agoI was recently kicked off of Facebook for lack of an "Authentic Name." Humorously my name was my legal name. Getting kicked off of Facebook was the best thing to happen to my productivity and mood. My only frustration is that there are several people on Facebook I have no easy method of giving alternative contact info to.
- morgante 11y agoI wish the EFF and others who are against using real names would at least acknowledge the drawbacks of pseudonyms and the proliferation of fake accounts and fake names which comes with them. The real name policy has huge benefits. I'm not constantly bombarded by fake friend requests like I am on Twitter, Skype, or any other platform which allows random usernames. Even more importantly, I can easily find the people in my life without having to go through an awkward song and dance. If I'm working on a project with someone, I can immediately find them and message them without worrying that it's some random imposter or some such. Facebook is a platform designed for digitizing your real world relationships, not for accumulating thousands of "followers." There's a reason they limit you to 5,000 friends. People who are trying to disconnect their Facebook identity from their real world identity are not using Facebook the way it's meant to be used and should probably just leave it. That being said, Facebook could definitely do a better job of making it easier for people to prove that a name is their everyday name even when it's not their legal name. I fully expect to lose a lot of karma over this comment, but I'd love to hear an argument over why access to Facebook is a right together with your down vote.
- throwaway6845 11y agoAgreed. I run a small-town community website. Instituting a real-name policy stopped the trolling overnight: people behave much more reasonably if they know they might meet the person they're yelling at in the street tomorrow. The key is that our site aims to be solely a resource for the existing community (where people relate to each other through real names), not a virtual community in itself. I certainly wouldn't argue that the web should be real-name only, but nor do I believe everyone always has an automatic right to post on privately-owned websites using pseudonyms.
- morgante 11y ago> I certainly wouldn't argue that the web should be real-name only 100% agreed. The vast majority of the web is based around pseudonymous interaction (even this comment thread). I love that about the web, but I also appreciate Facebook creating one place to foster those real world connections.
- strommen 11y agoI don't understand why people feel entitled to use Facebook in this way. Facebook is a place to communicate with your friends and family, not a publishing platform. If you want to write anonymously, then get a free account on any number of other platforms that are designed for anonymous publishing.
- smoreilly 11y agoYou guys should really understand the policy before ripping on it. There are tons of other ways to have your name verified. https://www.facebook.com/help/159096464162185 https://www.facebook.com/help/159096464162185
- 30183839 11y agoI think you misunderstand. The only way for me to verify my authentic name as a transgender individual if I understand the page correctly is for me to go and take out a magazine subscription (to match with my mail and another non-matching photo ID). The other identification options are all required to match my legal name.
- curiousjorge 11y agoHow does EFF get it's funding? I feel like they should be given more credit for what they are doing.
- aianus 11y agohttps://supporters.eff.org/donate https://supporters.eff.org/donate
- personjerry 11y agoI've only heard of the issue from the LGBTQ stance, and I'm not very clear here. But I'm wondering, for these people, why not just legally change your name?
- djur 11y agoLegally changing one's name ranges from "a pain in the ass" to "impossible", depending on jurisdiction and the contexts in which you have used your previous legal names. It is also generally part of the program for trans* people to spend a period of time living as their gender (name, clothes, etc.) before more permanent (medically and legally) steps are taken.
- kuschku 11y agoTake for example Germany: Photocopying your ID is a crime, and changing your name is impossible (unless you get a court verdict that there is an actual need for you to change your name). So Facebook’s Real Name policy forces me to get a court verdict and commit a crime? Great...
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoAre you British? Because outside of the UK, changing your name is much more difficult than just printing off and signing a piece of paper.
- rmc 11y ago> why not just legally change your name? Well, what if you're not fully out of the closet yet? What if you're a teenager in a very religious household?
- warewolf 11y agoPeople just need to stop using Facebook. Join Twitter and be Happy #JackIsBack "I don't make the rules, I just pick which rules I follow"
- Spooky23 11y agoI hate Facebook, but I think they are right about this policy. If you're a person at risk due to many of the issues described here, you don't belong on Facebook. If you're a domestic violence victim avoiding a dangerous person "liking" the wrong thing or somebody's innocent repost can put you in danger, pseudonym or not. The transgender situation is similarly tragic, but it's an issue that trans people run into when presenting ID to buy beer as well. We should get states to provide some sort of transitional ID or something.
- 30183839 11y ago> We should get states to provide some sort of transitional ID or something. The fact that identification is difficult to change for transgender individuals is an enormous fractured problem. Also consider that Facebook is used around the world in various political climates. Even in the state of California it is necessary to go through treatment and get a doctors note and pay several hundreds of dollars and wait several months (You can forgo the doctors note if you're willing to publish it in the local newspaper a few times).
- OldSchoolJohnny 11y agoI'm stunned by the defenders of this policy I'm seeing here. Not singling you out in particular this is for everyone who doesn't seem to get it due to youth, lack of experience, very privileged life, complete inability to empathise, I'm not sure what exactly in each case but it's ugly at times and Hacker News seems to be ground zero for a lot of this stuff. I suspect like many things I see on here there is a huge lack of life experience informing opinions. Luckily on HN you don't have to use your real name so these immature opinions won't come back to bite you as a well adjust adult with life experience.
- baby 11y ago> defenders of > everyone who doesn't seem to get it due to youth, lack of experience, very privileged life, complete inability to empathise > huge lack of life experience informing opinions > immature opinions That comment was very mature.
- 11y ago
- yuhong 11y agoI dislike real name policies, but I do want the problems with using real names to be fixed if possible.
- kristopolous 11y agoIt's to decrease the perception of click fraud. Facebook's real name policies have to do with how people perceive the plausibility of the numbers reported for their a-la-cart paid advertisement customers. This policy doesn't actually decrease fake shell accounts. It's an intentionally ineffective ceremonious anti-fraud campaign. Facebook knows that third parties conducting click and follow fraud for paying advertising customers brings them a lot of money. They came up with a policy that gives the perception of combating it ... actually closing real human accounts. However, all the fake bot accounts are and have always been named like "Jane Doe" and "Bob Smith" ... they remain untouched. What's the effect? The paying customer thinks that Facebook is making an effort to combat fraud but in truth they have every interest in keeping the fraud around and creating a false perception that things are changing - like the oil and tobacco companies; like nike and nestle; like fast food - like every other billion dollar company ever. You don't amass $30 billion by being an honest Joe.
- alansmitheebk 11y agoThis petition strikes me as painfully naive. It should be obvious to anyone that Facebook's user data is what makes it a multi-billion dollar company. That data is worth fuck all if it correlates to superhero names and cat pictures as opposed to real people.
- dredmorbius 11y agoOne of the best commentaries I've seen on the matter of "authentic" or "real" names policies comes from Yonatan Zunger, chief architect of Google's Google+ social network. I've had plenty of disagreement with Google and Yonatan over many aspects of G+, and have given both the company and him much grief on multiple counts, including Real Names (Google's varient of Facebook's policy), though I'll also note that Yonatan's generally heard me out quite patiently. But his comments strike me as wise and hard-won, painful knowledge: https://plus.google.com/+YonatanZunger/posts/WegYVNkZQqq https://plus.google.com/+YonatanZunger/posts/WegYVNkZQqq In practice, the forced revelation of information makes individual privilege and power more important. When everyone has to play with their cards on the table, so to speak, then people who feel like they can be themselves without consequence do so freely -- these generally being people with support groups of like-minded people, and who are neither economically nor physically vulnerable. People who are more vulnerable to consequences use concealment as a method of protection: it makes it possible to speak freely about controversial subjects, or even about any subjects, without fear of harassment. That's quite an evolution of opinion. I respect Yonatan deeply for both conceiving of, and publicly stating it.
- kentonv 11y agoFWIW, despite the "chief architect" title, IIRC Yonatan Zunger didn't actually join the G+ project until well after the initial launch. That is to say, the real name policy predated his involvement. I suspect he was always opposed to it.
- dredmorbius 11y agoI suspect that myself, and there's a discussion I've had with him since. As with other of his observations on human behavior generally, Yonatan's take here is both perceptive and nuanced. I have discussed with him (on G+) the point that it took so long for him to state this, his reponse being that Google itself never suggested he shouldn't, but that he wrote this when he felt the time was right. My sense is that there's self-censorship going on, and yes, I self-censor myself (under various identities, for various reasons). Regardless of when he joined the project, Yonatan's used G+ heavily over the past four years or so and seems to have a pretty good sense of its strengths and weaknesses.
- Slushpuppisan 11y agoHow do you get blocked? I changed my account to a ridiculous name and I know a couple of people that have changed their equally ridiculous pseudonyms multiple times. Maybe they only block you if you have a real-sounding name?
- pdonis 11y agoWhile I sympathize with the underlying sentiments of this, I have to disagree with what it actually says. If the EFF were really trying to help users, it wouldn't be trying to get Facebook to change; it would be trying to get users to stop using Facebook. The problem is not that FB needs to improve its name policy; the problem is that we have a single centralized social network for everybody. What we should have is a way for people to build their own independent social networks, so that someone who wants to be able to connect online with friends while avoiding their creepy ex can do so. Why isn't the EFF pushing for that?
- cwyers 11y agoPseudonymity is a double-edged sword; it enables people to hide from abusers online, but it also enabled a lot of online abuse (Twitter is rampant with the stuff, not that Facebook is immune). I don't know which side is right, and I wish that there was some way to combine the best of both but so far nobody's struck that balance or even really come close. But if that balance is struck, I don't think the sort of stridency the EFF is engaging in here is going to be part of the solution.
- steve_taylor 11y agoFacebook beat all other social networks because it is the best at connecting people who already know each other. And its most effective tool to connect these people is its search functionality whose effectiveness requires that all its users use their real name. It is unrealistic to expect Facebook to risk its very existence just because the EFF demands that it do so.
- xacaxulu 11y agoTheLastPsychiatrist explains expertly why the whole form of this argument is wrong in a post questioning Randi Zuckerberg. It's well worth reading, especially if you are considering the benefits of opting out of Facebook (and I strongly recommend you jump in, the water's find :) http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2014/01/randi_zuckerberg.html http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2014/01/randi_zuckerberg.html
- Kiro 11y agoI've supported everything EFF has done so far but this is a really bad idea. Have people forgotten the chaos of MySpace and other social networks before Facebook?
- rwhitman 11y agoThere has to be some sort of middle ground, where people who need to mask their identity for various reasons can be allowed to without tipping the scales towards platform abuse. This doesn't have to be a black or white issue. FB simply needs to figure out a fair way to validate identity but allow a user to use a sanctioned alternate identity. I think this is what the EFF action is really about