6 ms·
Let's not spend any more time arguing about the style and cut of the emperor's new clothes. Terrorism constitutes a tiny fraction of the threat to life, health,
by jessaustin 11y ago
Let's not spend any more time arguing about the style and cut of the emperor's new clothes. Terrorism constitutes a tiny fraction of the threat to life, health, and property that numerous widely-accepted institutions in Western societies constitute. For some reason, though, it's the only topic that folks in DC find fit for discussion. Could there be a reason for that?
- mason240 11y agoBecause national defense is one of the few actual responsibilities of the US Federal government.
- pnut 11y agoThat is an opinion, not a fact.
- tvanantwerp 11y agoNo, it's the the first paragraph of the US Constitution that the federal government ought to "provide for the common defense".
- webXL 11y agoPerhaps parent was taking issue with "few actual responsibilities", which our current government treats as an opinion.
- emodendroket 11y agoI don't think anyone is disputing that the government should provide for the common defense; saying it is "one of the few responsibilities of the federal government" implies a certain conservative view and the unstated assumption that the huge security apparatus created to fight terrorism is an effective way of providing for the common defense is also a matter of opinion.
- pnut 11y agoIn addition to this, I meant that OP's assertion implied there is a commonly agreed upon list of core responsibilities assigned to the federal government. Practically all of the major political battles ongoing today in America are to clarify the proper scope and function of government. Healthcare, taxation, voting rights, abortion, religious liberty, on and on and on. It has been going on since the Revolutionary War, and will never reach consensus. Here's another opinion - The constitution is a starting point, not a recipe book.
- mason240 11y agoThe Constitution is pretty explicit in stating that it limits the scope of government, which is the opposite of being a starting point.
- oldmanjay 11y agoPoliticians are pretty clear in their POV that the Constitution is a bother to be worked around, so there's realistically no point in going down the path you've chosen.
- jessaustin 11y agoWhy wasn't there an equivalent of the 18th Amendment in order to allow the drug prohibition?
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoBecause drugs were already illegal? You could perhaps argue that they shouldn't have been illegal, constitutionally. But, IIRC, they were, and so new change was required to start the war on drugs. It was just "we're going to get serious about stopping this stuff".
- jessaustin 11y agoThis doesn't really make sense. If that arrangement had made legal sense for opiates, marijuana, etc. it would have made legal sense for alcohol. In fact it was perfectly legal to distribute, purchase, and use those in numerous places through at least 1914, when the Harrison Narcotics Tax Act passed. Even that Act attempted to finesse the issue by limiting imports rather than just outlawing the substances directly. The Volstead Act didn't go in for such half-measures, because it had the backing of the Constitution. Neither Harrison nor any of its successors could say that. Frankly, I was mostly attempting to engage with mason240's rather strict legal philosophy in a way that would cause most strict constructionists some discomfort.
- drivingmenuts 11y agoNational defense also happens to be the most lucrative. No one has ever lost an election by demanding that we throw more money to defense contractors.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoNo politician will ever come out and say they want to double or triple the defense budget, they usually do it after they get in office. What usually happens is the candidate talks about reducing the military budget, only to increase it once in office. Obama would be a great example. He was opposed to the multiple wars the US was fighting, then once he got into office, he increased spending on various defense projects: In Obama’s first year as president, his defense secretary, Robert Gates, ratcheted up spending on the F-35 as a compromise for halting production on the F-22, a larger, more expensive stealth aircraft. But the F-35 has turned out to be nearly as costly and considerably more troubled. His budget for 2016 looks to increase the military budget: Intriguingly, while the Pentagon’s “overview” briefing notes that it’s requesting a 4 percent increase in the total defense budget and a 21 percent reduction in the OCO accounts, it doesn’t express the base-budget increase in percentage terms, so let me do the math for you: It translates to an increase of 7.7 percent. This is enormous. source: http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/war_stories/2015/02/president_obama_s_enormous_defense_budget_it_favors_big_weapons_systems.single.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/war_stories/...
- ryanx435 11y agothe reason is that the a large portion of policy makers still believe that the american economy runs on a military industrial complex. The military industrial complex works great when there is an enemy to fight that requires the production of military equipment. examples of this enemy, in the past, were the Axis powers and the USSR during WWII and the cold war. It doesn't work so well when there is no enemy to fight. after the dissolution of the Soviet Union in the early 90s, there was an "enemy vacuum": who would be the next enemy that the US could use to drive the military industrial complex? Russia wasn't worth fighting indirectly any more because they were too weak, and there really wasn't a competitor that was strong enough or threatening enough for the US to parade around as the enemy. enter terrorism: it provides a target that fulfills a number of very crucial aspects: 1) non state actors: the US can go to war with terrorists without going to war against the officially recognized government. This is key to global security because conducting war within a nation's borders no longer constitutes an assault on that nation. This prevents WWI type wars that start as a series of cascading mutual protection treaties or similar. 2) difficult to define the enemy: who are terrorists? whoever the ruling party deems terrorists. everyone else is a freedom fighter. This makes it convenient to come up with a new enemy group of terrorists when the current batch has been "defeated" or the american public becomes war weary. 3)easy for the government to drum up support for new military action by creating and appealing to a sense of fear within the populace and a desire for "safety". 4) oil: the majority of terrorist groups that are in the focus of the american public's attention are primarily located within countries that have large oil interests. Other terrorist groups located in other areas, such as the philippines or south america, are largely ignored. 5) percieved threat of terrorists: it is easy to believe that terrorists are a significant threat to US citizens precisely because of their ability to strike on american soil. This greatly adds to their value as a enemy for the military industrial compelex because the general us population sees the threat as legitimate. (a converse example of this would be if the new enemy would have been, say, brazil: they're not really a threat to the US because they wouldn't really be able to directly threaten the american mainland.) there are other reasons, i'm sure.
- danbruc 11y agoThe whole thing still doesn't make sense to me. You keep the people in the military industrial complex in labor but you are not generating any wealth for the nation. You collect taxes from people producing real wealth for the country to feed weapons producers and an army only to then throw those expensive bombs into some random dessert village at the other end of the world. Why not use all that money and manpower to build things useful to the nation? So what am I missing? How is war an economical effective way of using those resources? Some would probably say it is the access to oil and other resources but whenever I looked at that it seemed to me that no exceptionally profitable deals or other outcomes were reached.
- lbenes 11y agoYou ask the right questions. The documentary "Why We Fight"[1] attempts to answer them. It's a fascinating look into the military–industrial complex and its 50-year involvement with US wars. [1] https://vimeo.com/29896630 https://vimeo.com/29896630