10 ms·
Volkswagen Emissions Investigation Zeroes in on Two Engineers
- mpweiher 11y ago> in August 2007,[..] It rebranded the company’s diesel engine TDI—for turbocharged direct injection. Huh? VW's diesel engines had been TDIs for well over a decade at that time, for example my 1996 Golf was a TDI. The TDIs are awesome engines. I previously had a gasoline engine with the same horsepower rating, but the TDI was better in every way: unkillably high torque at low RPMs (I could go from a standing start to 4th gear without ever pushing the gas pedal), great acceleration at high speeds (at 160 km/h, hit the pedal and it goes, whereas with the gasoline engine it was hit the pedal and ... wait ... wait ... still trying to accelerate ... wait ). And of course far, far better gas mileage.
- to3m 11y agoTo be fair, great gas mileage is true for every manufacturer. It's inherent in the technology, and applies across the full range of engine sizes and configurations. I've driven my BMW 330d 35,000 miles and to my knowledge it's never used even a single millilitre of gasoline.
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoThe reason people perceive diesels to be better is that they have much flatter torque vs RPM curves, so any schmuck can make them accelerate without shifting to the correct gear. If diesel engines gave better performance at the same amount of horsepowers, and used less fuel, why don't we see diesel engines used in horsepower-limited racing car classes? Why has Ferrari and Lamborghini not ever offered a single diesel engine?
- deelowe 11y agoAudi did make a diesel race car. It was quite famous actually. That said, the main issue with diesel is that while they have a much better torque curve, diesel engines have a much lower RPM limit. This plus the emissions issues make for pretty big compromises.
- zik 11y agoDiesels are great for having a wide spread of torque from very low RPM which makes them very tractable for everyday driving. Race cars have different priorities. They need maximum power which generally results in a very peaky engine. They substitute a highly skilled driver for tractability.
- mpweiher 11y ago"The Audi R10 TDI, usually abbreviated to R10, is a racing car from the German car manufacturer Audi. The car is a classic at Le Mans, winning every year since its introduction until it was replaced by the R15. [..] It was the first diesel-powered car to win either of those events. " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audi_R10_TDI https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audi_R10_TDI
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoThe LMP1 class is not restricted by horsepower, which is what I said. Nascar or WRC would be examples of classes with horsepower limits.
- mtgx 11y agoI assume they are the scapegoats.
- DyslexicAtheist 11y agoof course your "assumption" is right. "head of" is a low level (entry-level) mgmt position in these places. No idea why anyone would down-vote you.
- selimthegrim 11y agoThis is HN, remember. Engineers are demigods here, freshly sprung from Athena's head herself, but one step removed from Zeus.
- x0ra 11y agoEngineer merely implements the decision of the upper management...
- dev1n 11y agoI'm sure these engineers weren't acting on their own here.
- TheCapn 11y agoWell, seeing how one is titled the "Chief Engineer" I wouldn't be too surprised that he represents an entire department (or many) and is the last stop before board of directors.
- hkmurakami 11y agoTo me, having been in the auto industry as a peon, Chief Engineer sounds like a person with a Junior Middle Manager pay level without officially having any direct reports.
- zardo 11y agoThat's odd, I work in an auto company, our chief engineer is the head of all engieering, he reports to the GM, who reports to the board of directors. Another odd thing though, is that VW apparently puts their compliance responsibilities under engineering management. Our compliance department, which I work in, is an independent department. That has its own difficulties with being less integrated with development, but we don't have any competing goals.
- trhway 11y agowasn't the last Great Recession simply due to some poor schmucks making mistakes while calculating risk estimates for bonds ratings?
- coldcode 11y agoScapegoats, in other words. People don't do this on their own.
- to3m 11y ago"regulators are considering steps to tighten emissions standards for diesel engines"? - interesting that the old emissions standards were (one presumes) absolutely fine, until somebody turns out to have been cheating.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoWell, enforcement of the old emissions standards was lacking. If "tightening" means "actually enforce the ones we have, even against the revealed gamesmanship", that's a very proper step.
- mhw 11y agoI think you've got to look at this as a process of gradual refinement in which both government and industry participate. The government wants to achieve its overall objectives of reducing emissions over a long period of time (decades); it knows that if it just set the emissions targets at the target on day zero the entire industry would fail to meet them and the industry would collapse. So the regulations have to be set with some idea of what is currently achievable or within reach of the industry given an economically feasible amount of investment. So the aim of the regulation is to push the industry in the direction you want them to go at a rate which gets everyone to the destination without destroying the industry. And every so often the regulations need to be tightened to keep the development process moving forward.
- dsfyu404ed 11y ago...at the expense of the consumer who can't get a decently priced compact pickup (among other examples)
- rancur 11y agosurely management at fault here for undue pressure? NASA / Morton Thiokol
- akamaka 11y agoThe rest of the commenters are quick to dismiss this article as presenting scapegoats, but I'm very keen to see more in-depth investigation about how this was orchestrated. There are a lot of different ways that this type of cheating can develop over time, and simply saying "lots of people knew must have known about this" isn't very satisfying to me. There are plenty of ways that upper management can stay in the dark. In the case of Deepwater Horizon, BP didn't make the decisions that lead to the blowout, but created excessive pressure for cost-cutting. In the case of Barings Bank, the managers were genuinely unaware of the rogue trader's fraud, but allowed him to bypass internal controls. There are important lessons that will come out of the VW case and I'm very interested to learn them. The dismissiveness of the comments here is really disappointing, on the other hand.
- 5h 11y agoI wonder how differently the reaction here would be if the title/article didn't call them Engineers.
- electricblue 11y ago"we didn't know" is curiously not an excuse you can use in any other facet of human life except to exculpate rich people
- ppod 11y agoIn what other facet of human life would you be held responsible for something you had no knowledge of?
- x3n0ph3n3 11y agoTypically ignorance of the law is not an excuse when found disobeying it, and there are more laws than any reasonable person can know.
- vonmoltke 11y agoTO both x3n0ph3n3 and mkaziz: Knowledge of the act, not knowledge of the law. There are very few contexts in which you can be punished for not knowing an illegal act took place, and they are all situations where you should have known but were negligent.
- djaychela 11y agoIt will be interesting to see if the investigators manage to obtain an email chain which will show where the pressure to do this came from - from day 1 I've felt it was unlikely that this was an isolated incident, or one which management weren't tacitly aware of, and I would be very surprised if it doesn't turn out that we find out where it all came from - my bet is that it was pressure from above that led to it, but that's just a hunch - it may be that management didn't know what was going on, and the engineers took it on themselves to cheat. But either way, I don't think we're near the bottom of this yet.
- crb002 11y agoProof is in the version control commits.
- kinofcain 11y ago"Engineers" in this context meaning "Heads of engineering departments". These guys aren't individual contributor engineers.
- deegles 11y agoI can see it already: "[Car manufacturer]'s Self Driving Car Crash Investigation Zeroes in on Two Engineers."
- smoyer 11y agoIn my opinion, this is going to get far worse for VW. People bought cars expecting the stated fuel economy - if they submit their cars to the recall, there's likely to be a class-action suit aiming to recoup enough cost to pay for the difference in fuel costs over the life of the car. Cars that don't go through the recall process will continue to pollute at a greater rate and will earn the ire of the EPA (here in the US). It's going to cost them a huge amount of money to satisfy both the EPA and their customers.
- mratzloff 11y agoIt's going to get worse, but not for the reason you state. Changing car performance (acceleration profile, etc.) for the worse is a necessary outcome of fixing this issue. That's why people will sue.
- smoyer 11y agoYou're right - I was assuming the pollution controls would only result in a lower fuel economy. On the other hand, degrading the car's performance to improve emissions is the opposite end of the spectrum. Since fuel economy versus performance provides an entire spectrum of tuning options, it will be interesting to see exactly which trade-offs they make in the ECM's code.
- developer1 11y agoIt seems premature to assume they can fix the problem with code changes alone. If that's the case, the performance drop will likely be beyond acceptable. The required changes could make the vehicles physically unsafe to be on the road (think, being unable to accelerate out of danger's way because now you need 60 seconds to go from 0-50 km/h). If the option for a compromise between performance and regulatory requirements is already possible with the current hardware, wouldn't the cars likely have already shipped as such? It seems much more likely that there will be parts replacement involved, and we may soon discover that the entire engine must be swapped out. This is unlikely to be feasible for cost, but bricking cars to intolerable driving conditions is also not enough. It's going to be really interesting to see how this develops. Done properly, this would probably be the end of VW. So I'm sure we'll see some half-assed solution that doesn't work for the consumer, but lets the company survive for a few more years until they finally collapse from consumers taking their future business elsewhere.
- oralhistory 11y agoIt's going to be ridiculous that people will go to jail for this and not any of the people responsible for the subprime mortgages.
- edanm 11y agoSo, I've been wondering about this. Who, exactly, would you want to see in jail for "subprime mortgages" and on what charge? I hear people say the general statement a lot, but I'm not sure who specifically they're talking about.
- oldmanjay 11y agoObviously we need to jail all of the people who fraudulently accepted loans they knew they couldn't pay back. Obviously.
- hga 11y agoYou want to throw Barney "Roll the Dice" Frank in jail? There tend to be lots of unintended consequences to punishing stupid politicians like that, or people outside the government following the government's prior orders.
- joezydeco 11y ago"For more than a year, Volkswagen executives told the Environmental Protection Agency that discrepancies between the formal air-quality tests on its diesel cars and the much higher pollution levels out on the road were the result of technical issues, not a deliberate attempt to deceive Washington officials." http://www.houstonchronicle.com/business/article/Volkswagen-denied-deception-to-EPA-for-nearly-a-6520476.php http://www.houstonchronicle.com/business/article/Volkswagen-... So VW is telling us that this year of lying to the EPA was done completely by these two engineering managers and nobody else in the VW executive staff?
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoWhere did they say that? They are suspending people left and right and there are investigations ongoing against Winterkorn.nright now there has nothing final been said yet.
- DyslexicAtheist 11y agoglad they found the culprits. I was absolutely certain it would be renegade engineers and the higher level up (politically secured allies) have nothing to do with it. Torches and pitchforks everyone. The amount of restraint I have to exercise as an ex-consultant who made his living working for the likes of Audi, VW & Siemens nobody here can possibly comprehend.
- selimthegrim 11y agoSurely, Winterkorn/Piëch/the whole post-2007 and post-Pischetsrieder exec team must have dirt on the TÜV/CDU politicians in lower Saxony? e: And hilariously for you, according to Wikipedia, Piëch himself is in fact a dyslexic atheist. Zounds!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- crpatino 11y agoDid you seriously said the word "renegade"? Even if their superiors did honestly not know that they were loading fraud-ware in the vehicles, this is most likely the result of systemic social dynamics and perverse incentives. Mutually exclusive goals get set with no regard to the laws of physics or reason. Everyone who dares mention this self selects outside of the management hierarchy, so the whole chain of command becomes an echo chamber of overconfidence. Then, at the end of the day, something has to give. It was the emission control testing in this case. It could have been much worse.
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoI had an interesting conversation with a co-worker today, about why unit-test coverage is always bad unless enforced. I decided that it's because even though my boss and myself will have good intentions, we can both mutually decide (without ever discussing it) that the tests should slide - I will try to meet his deadline, he won't check too hard. Unless there are credible institutions that take that decision away from us (a build bot that refuses to deploy untested code for example) we will slip towards worse. Management does not need to apply pressure towards misbehaviour - they simply have to not constantly strive for best behaviour. Our expectations fill in the rest. As such, we are unlikely ever to find an email from the board saying "Hans, frig the tests next week, we can't be arsed to invest in catalytic converters", but the organisation decided that anyway. I think it's to do with lack of candour - see the Pixar book out recently
- crpatino 11y agoThis is not on the same league. Your unit-test coverage example is closer to the Toyota incident. Surely, it was a catastrophe, and lives were indeed lost, but no one actively inserted a "speed up when driver hits the breaks" feature into the firmware. A closer analogy to the VW case is if the build bot actually did exist, but you wrote some nefarious unit test that just spit out all OK results regardless of what the exercised code did, so that you were allowed to merge whatever crap your team produce, as long as it actually compile. If that is the case, we can discuss different possible assignations of responsibility, but you cannot claim that some good intentioned people just slide into misbehavior due to not paying enough attention. Someone had to be aware they were actively cheating!
- lifeisstillgood 11y agoBut my unit tests do do that ;-)
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoThese scapegoats are old dudes; they might really be the right scapegoats (as opposed to the a couple of junior or mid-level coders, one might expect).
- onli 11y agoDo I miss that in the article, or is it really not stated from where the information that the investigation is focusing on them is coming? People "familiar with the matter" as only source? It would be a pretty bold (and irresponsible) move from a criminal investigation to leak suspects to the press that early, given that this will destroy their career. Stuff likes that needs prove or very very strong hints pointing at them, enough to start a trial, and there is no word about that. I understand everyone who thinks that this looks like presenting scapegoats. This stinks. The whole article shouldn't have been published like that, and we should not upvote it.
- a3n 11y ago> Both men developed an international reputation as engineers, said Ferdinand Dudenhöffer head of the Center of Automotive Research at the University of Duisburg-Essen. > “It will be difficult for Volkswagen to replace them,” he said. Genuinely legendary engineers, and allegedly with the balls to cheat (but not quite the balls to stand on principle). It will indeed be hard to find that combination among the remaining legends.
- hcrisp 11y agoWhy didn't this same link I posted earlier get picked up when peterthomas submitted it? I think they are the same? Seems like HN had a glitch? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10330573 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10330573
- greg1232 11y agoIt is outrageous to suggest that the blame lies with a handful of people and not a whole division of the company. I don't work in the automotive industry, but I do work as a design engineer in the semiconductor industry and for a mature product in a highly competitive industry, I can guarantee that the external test wasn't the only test that these cars were put though. When we release a chip external reviewers will run it thorough a handful of benchmarks, but we run far more tests internally because when you are building complex systems, not everything that you plan for happens, and you need an extreme level of detail to be able to understand and fix performance problems. Literally hundreds of engineers will participate in performing these measurements, and most of them, along with the whole management tree up to the CEO (especially for an important consumer facing product), will participate in interpreting them. Not doing this means getting left in the dust by your competitors. There is no way that only a small number of people knew about this. Two is laughable, people here with software engineering backgrounds should be highly skeptical that any piece of software in a product with as many users as a car was only examined by two people. The only explanation is that a large number of engineers and managers knew about this and did nothing.
- jpatokal 11y agoOne of the people named is Audi’s chief engineer, and they're both described as "being in charge of R&D" at VW. So I would presume they're pretty high up the food chain, not the low-level guys who actually wrote the if: test then: cheat bits.
- greg1232 11y agoStill I can't believe that so many people must have known about this and just let it happen. Sad. This is a tech oriented forum and I hope some of the engineers reading this would act differently in a similar situation.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- colin_jack 11y agoSome of these comments seem to be proof that not everyone commenting on here reads the articles before giving their views.
- wiz21c 11y agoStrangely, nobody talks about the investors... Did they command such a cheat ? After all, the top engineers are already 2 levels deep in the management (top level being investor, then CEO, then tehe engineers) so they're relatively low enough to be scapegoat...