10 ms·
A multigenerational hit: Student debt traps parents and kids
- jenkstom 11y agoAs many articles as there are about this in the press, I wouldn't be surprised if this didn't become one of the biggest issues for the presidential election.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoIf only Gen Y/Millenials turned out in decent numbers.
- ryandrake 11y agoWhich candidate(s) have an actual realistic plan that will make college education affordable and reduce the burden of existing student debt, as opposed to "Affordable education for all!" as a hollow platform piece?
- Someone1234 11y agoYeah, and it is a hard problem to solve. Colleges could literally spend as much as they're provided. A lot of money right now seems to go towards adding shiny new things to attract more students (e.g. newer buildings, more tech, nicer chairs, etc). The only thing stopping them from charging more is competition, but so few students even check the cost of their education that it isn't working well, and many are geographically restricted. Community college is where people go if they actually care at all about the costs. Or at least they get 2/3rds of their education done at a CC. If I was in charge I'd attack this problem as follows: - College loans are now provided by the US Government only at an interest rate DESIGNED to break even (i.e. no longer for-profit). - Loans are repaid as a tax (for people who remain in the US, like a debt for people abroad). - No repayment is required under a certain threshold (e.g. $30K single, 50K family, in 2015 dollars). - Repayment schedules scale similar to income tax (e.g. you MUST repay faster the more you make). - Loans are not subject to bankruptcy and are treated like a tax for inheritance purposes (i.e. paid back first). - Under certain circumstances interest can be frozen (e.g. documented medical issues, natural disasters, continued education, etc). This means that unemployment or illness isn't as damaging. People who leave college and get low paying jobs aren't hurt as badly day to day (although might technically have an outstanding loan for the rest of their life).
- derekp7 11y agoHow about this: set tuition caps on any government guaranteed loan. Or maybe expand the role of community colleges so that you can get a BA or Masters at CC pricing.
- xyzzy123 11y agoYou just described exactly how student loans work in New Zealand. You have a special tax code "addon" SL, which means you pay a little bit of extra tax, which goes towards your loans. Only major difference is, death & bankruptcy release you from the loan in NZ...
- rconti 11y agoAlso, even 18 year olds (minimum voting age in the US) are unlikely to be impacted by the college plan of any President they elect. It's the parents of younger kids who should be paying attention.
- derekp7 11y agoIt really doesn't matter if they have a plan now -- what matters is the demographic that put them in office. So if they want to get re-elected, they know they have to work hard enough to keep those that voted for them (and can vote them out) happy.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoIf you want the Democratic Party to run progressive candidates who will do more than give lip service to student loan debt, people need to 1. Vote in primaries and 2. Vote for Democrats (esp left leaning ones) in primaries and general elections. That's the only way the party will move closer to the left. I'm excluding Republicans since their base believes that government intervention to alleviate student loan debt will be the equivalent of Judas kissing Jesus and Road to Serfdom and all that shit. And it goes without saying the quixotic brand of Silicon Valley libertarianism is not fertile ground for this sort of thinking.
- unimpressive 11y agoWell you don't even necessarily need to relieve student loan debt, you could start by making it forgivable. Right now student loan debt can't be discharged through bankruptcy, and it creates a perverse market incentive for college tuition. Not to mention this attack ad is right on the website for the Washington State Republican Party: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uOYX3TBZEM8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uOYX3TBZEM8
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoThat ad has nothing to do with student loan debt per se, and is a standard attack ad, the veracity of which I'm quick to doubt for being a 30 second sound bite.
- unimpressive 11y agoIt's in the overton window, is what I mean. Obviously attack ads are not to be trusted.
- Mz 11y agoIn some cases, they can be discharged: https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/repay-loans/forgiveness-cancellation#discharge-in https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/repay-loans/forgiveness-cancell...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- logfromblammo 11y agoI certainly hope so. It would be a far better discussion topic than D. Trump's hair, or gay marriage, or immigration, or the ACA. Speaking on behalf of the entire middle class--and let me assure you that I am both qualified and authorized to do so--we are getting sick of working our asses off just to live our entire lives sunk up to our multiple chins in debt. But no one is likely to lift a finger to do anything about it until after missing a few meals. Perhaps it will help when Mr. Khan and allied parties in the tech industry start to eat Academia's lunch. Thanks to the Internet, you don't absolutely need to pay $100k+ for a degree, and you don't even need to pay the "buck fifty in late charges from the public library," as suggested in the movie Good Will Hunting. Once employers start de-prioritizing an accredited degree and start recognizing online coursework certifications, it will already be too late. Nobody will be going to college for anything short of calculus, law, medicine, or petroleum-related geology. After all, if your art history degree isn't going to help you get a job anyway, you could just browse artists' pages on Wikipedia and visit museums instead.
- ashark 11y ago> Once employers start de-prioritizing an accredited degree and start recognizing online coursework certifications, it will already be too late. Nobody will be going to college for anything short of calculus, law, medicine, or petroleum-related geology. What is the mechanism which will cause this change? It looks a bit chicken/egg from here—there will continue to be college graduates because they are strongly advantaged during hiring, and hiring will continue to strongly advantage graduates because there are enough of them that doing so doesn't drive their costs up much. Plus, no-one in HR gets fired because the Harvard grad didn't work out—take a chance on the guy with a GED and pile of Coursera certificates, OTOH...
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> Speaking on behalf of the entire middle class--and let me assure you that I am both qualified and authorized to do so... Out of curiosity, who authorized you? And who had the authority to authorize you to speak on behalf of the middle class?
- 11y ago
- dang 11y agoWe changed the URL from http://www.businessinsider.com/americas-crushing-surge-of-student-debt-has-bred-a-disturbing-new-phenomenon-2015-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/americas-crushing-surge-of-st... to the AP's own less sensational version.
- Mz 11y agoThanks. FYI to anyone who is curious but not enough to check out both: The actual writing appears to be the same, but they have different titles and different photos (+, of course, photo descriptions/comments) and I guess one has a video the other does not.
- sageabilly 11y agoI absolutely agree with the article stating that vast amounts of students borrowed on the "premise ... that virtually every degree — regardless of the school or the major — could more than pay for itself because college graduates would command premium incomes". That's driven home in the previous paragraph: "The treatment led him to study Chinese medicine after graduation and become a licensed acupuncturist himself in 2004. He had already racked up $45,000 in college debt; acupuncture school required more." When I went to college (2001-2005) the thought process was "borrow as much as you can, you'll get a good job straight out of college and no one can repo your college degree". I had the head of the financial aid department tell me that borrowing the max every year was fine and dandy and I should keep doing it because my degree wasn't like a car that could be repossessed. So I graduated $38K in debt and spent maybe half of that on actual school with the rest going towards stupid shit that 20 year olds spend too much money on.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mfoy_ 11y agoIsn't there an inherent economic fallacy in the idea that "virtually every degree - regardless of the school or the major - could more than pay for itself because college graduates would command premium incomes"? If everyone has a bachelor's degree, how is everyone going to command a premium income?
- sliverstorm 11y agoIt's an arms race. The ones early out the gate really do reap huge benefit but the system eventually equalizes.
- at-fates-hands 11y ago>> If everyone has a bachelor's degree, how is everyone going to command a premium income? Then it becomes a starting point, not an end point. Most businesses, when faced with a deluge of BA's, will start to look for people with master degrees. Same thing if they have a highly sought after position and get a deluge of people with masters, then they look for PhD candidates. This becomes an issue when you have a BA in a field where a majority of people have master degrees. I had several roommates who were engineering and CS graduates. At the time, the economy was shit (early 2000's) and they went back for their masters. Most said it was because when the economy finally bounced back, they would have a leg up on the people they were competing with. The only problem they found was as the economy recovered, they had more opportunities with a masters degree, but many were hired at the salary level of an entry level engineer.
- retbull 11y agoI am seeing this happen to me even with a Computer Science degree. I just got out and am only making enough to pay for housing and food nothing else. I did end up in a shitty situation but I was under the impression that this wouldn't happen to me as I have a "STEM" degree. I don't have that much debt but I can't get a job that will pay me more than 40k ish a year and Seattle is too expensive to live in for that little even with a roommate and cooking skills. This will hopefully change and my income with increase over the next few years but it is scary enough that I am regretting how I went to school. I should have worked for more than the first year even if I had to be in school for longer because of it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bcbrown 11y agoYou should put some contact info in your profile.
- retbull 11y agoadded thanks I thought that my email was visible.
- winslow 11y agoLook into using Hired.com (note: not all that apply get approval). I used it when switching jobs and it help me land a 50% salary increase. I am not exaggerating that. It showed all the possible salaries that companies were willing to pay me before negotiation and interviews started. It helps show what you may actually be worth to employers. Obviously your milage may vary but 40k is extremely low for computer science. Now it obviously depends how good you are etc. For reference I struggled straight out of school as I did computer science minor with another computer degree as my major. However, once I landed my first job ($65K) it has been upwards every since. Best of luck and reach out if you'd like (or anyone else in a similar position).
- retbull 11y ago
- SimpleXYZ 11y agoGetting an education was the stupidest thing I've ever done.
- coldcode 11y agoWhen I went to college in the late 70's, my parents paid a portion, I got a few small scholarships and worked every summer and part time through the school year. It was enough to pay for 4 years at a private university and then I spent two years elsewhere trying to get a masters, which at least was cheap as I worked as a graduate assistant. That is impossible today without either full scholarships or massive borrowing; the inflation of the cost of a 4 year degree from a private school from then to now wouldn't allow me to duplicate this any more. I spent 10 years volunteering at a local public university and most students had a similar experience (working, some help from parents, a few scholarships) although a few had to borrow a small bit of money. The difference of course is it was a public university which isn't as well regarded as mine, but in the end I bet the actual educational benefit was similar. Going to college is a great benefit socially and educationally but spending a fortune on it is only useful for a small set of careers (like go to Stanford for CS). I never used any of my 6 years of college studying Chemistry. But I never had to borrow to get my degree. Unless you are talking about medical school I can't see the benefit to going into massive debt just to get a degree.
- granos 11y agoUnfortunately many employers require a degree to even be considered. They are basically expecting you to come in the door with skills that they used to have to train employees in. In highly technical / safety critical fields I can understand this, but it has gotten out of control.
- eimai134 11y agoI used to not have a bachelor's and thought I was doing fine in my career. Then the Internet came along and every job required filling out an online profile, where people were screened out if they didn't have a degree. So I felt I had to go back. Perhaps some fields are different and a degree doesn't matter, but not mine, and not applying at large corporations.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoA big missing piece in this conversation is the fact that there's essentially two ways to save on a national multi-decade scale: either you have easy to exploit oil reserves that you save for later, or you convince the next generation to build stuff for you later in exchange for things now. That's the fundamental driving force behind a lot of insane pro-debt policies, especially student loans and mortgages. If you want the college situation to get better, attacking the idea of retirement is the way to go. That, and suing places like fire departments that require a college degree for no relevant reason.
- bdcravens 11y agoI guess I can say I escaped. Got my first computer my sophomore year (I grew up really poor), and was going to a tiny state school. Was a bad student, staying up online and sleeping through morning classes. Had to leave school (bad grades = financial aid probation), got my first real job (worked for local computer store/ISP), and that turned into my career. So my debt load from school is actually pretty small relatively speaking (about $6500 for the 2 years)
- eimai134 11y agoSorry, but I have trouble feeling sorry for these people. I know a person who has more than $100K in student loan debt, for degrees she has decided she doesn't want to use, who just quit her job to follow a dream of being an artist. I have other friends with student loan debt who have much nicer things than me (probably from credit card debt too). I paid off $10K in student loans. It didn't take too long and i was making well under $50K a year. Lived in a cheap, not-very-nice apartment, drove an old car, didn't spend much on entertainment, etc. It's very possible to pay off even the average of $20K in debt and not have it be a chain on your life forever. People also need to make sure they actually want to use the degree, that it's in a field where there are jobs, work while they are in school, and during their school time forgo the extras in life.