4 ms·
It's a challenging problem when you're diagnosed with a potentially terminal cancer at just 48 years of age. Do you spend what may be a short amount of time th
by adventured 11y ago
It's a challenging problem when you're diagnosed with a potentially terminal cancer at just 48 years of age.
Do you spend what may be a short amount of time that you have left on trying to build a foundation to give your wealth away, or do you spend it doing what you enjoy most? Jobs gets viciously and unfairly criticized on this point. If other people ('normal people') choose to pursue what they want to with their remaining time in the face of such a diagnosis, few would dare criticize them.
That becomes an even more important question when you realize that Jobs knew his wife would be fully capable of giving his wealth away after his passing. In the second half of his cancer battle, it was pretty obvious he was not going to survive longer term. So what do you do at 52 or 53 years of age, when it's apparent you're going to die? Do you spend years (which you may not have) trying to build a successful foundation? My personal opinion is that's an absurd premise. The reality is, we'll never know if Jobs would have become a successful philanthropist, or whether he would have focused on his work as Buffett has and leave the giving to eg his wife.
If Bill Gates had been diagnosed with a terminal cancer at 48, and died in his early to mid 50s - it's likely his legacy would look a lot different too. When Gates was 48 in 2003, his public reputation was far different than it is today, he was openly reviled as an abusive monopolist and robber baron with a long reputation for having been mean and abusive to employees.
It's Steve's vast billions that will be given away by Laurene, and he deserves a lot of credit for that, as much as someone like Warren Buffett does for the good his wealth will do. I don't see many examples of Jobs getting a comparable treatment versus what someone like Buffett does on this point however.
edit: if you care to, feel free to explain why you disagree with me, assuming it's not just based on a reflexive need to bash Steve Jobs and not give him credit for any of the good his wealth will do and or has done (while someone like Buffett gets a lot of credit, while performing almost none of the actual philanthropic effort either)
- jack9 11y ago> he was openly reviled as an abusive monopolist and robber baron with a long reputation for having been mean and abusive to employees. For some people (like me), he isn't anything more. Jobs and Gates were both rather disruptive people. Gates held the entire computer industry back, technologically, and abused his employees to stash wealth. What he does with ill-gotten gains is well and good from an absolute standpoint (no eye toward history), but the damage he did on his watch, doesn't make up for the relatively short-term altruism he has shown. Saving 10 or 100k lives via water treatment and scholarships or sabotaging technological innovation for decades, is not equivalent to me. It's immoral for Gates to take from others so he could make the decision of where that time and to what end to spend some of his lifetime of hoarded wealth.
- ised 11y ago"For some people..." I think there are a lot of people who share a similar perspective. For every Gates and Jobs, there are many other equally talented programmers and marketers who were not and will not be as lucky as these two. But if these other talented programmers and marketers conducted themselves in the manner of Gates and Jobs, would anyone forgive them? It's tempting to retort with some rhetorical rationale like "the ends justify the means," but then no one has any proof that behaving like Gates or Jobs has any causal link to the level of success they experienced. Microsoft and today's Apple are what they are. Some people love these companies' products. The word "cult" is sometimes used and people get quite defensive about their computer preferences, too. Effective marketing I guess. But not everyone has been so impressed. For people in the later group, there is little reason to celebrate Gates or Jobs, unless one is on the receiving end of some of their cash, whereby it can be put to beneficial use.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- RaleyField 11y ago> Gates held the entire computer industry back The industry does this job well by itself, I doubt things would be much different if Microsoft wasn't around. > What he does with ill-gotten gains Yet all transactions that contributed to his gains were voluntary.
- subdane 11y agoTechnically no, if we're talking about installs of OS on platforms. Bad business decisions and uninformed consumer decisions don't necessarily line up with "voluntary". Voluntary on the part of the manufacturer, yes. But less obviously so on the part of a less informed consumer. And complicated further by the fact that some of those manufacturers later came to regret the deal they entered - specifically that MSFT got a cut of all shipped machines regardless of whether their OS was installed.
- RaleyField 11y ago
- IBM 11y agoIt's also not true that Jobs didn't give to charity. The Jobs family has been giving to charity anonymously for more than two decades according to this report. http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/24/laurene-powell-jobs-and-anonymous-giving-in-silicon-valley/ http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/24/laurene-powell-jobs...
- eevilspock 11y agoI don't know if Jobs deserves praise or honor, but I will say that true giving is anonymous, except when a person gives non-anonymously with the sole genuine goal of influencing other people to give, not to enhance his or her image or legacy. The Gates family name is plastered everywhere. Buildings on the University of Washington campus, the name of their foundation. That puts into doubt his true motivations. He seems to like amassing things: fortune, and now legacy. I'm sure he's also quite motivated to reform his image. I'm glad Gate's is spending his ill-gotten gains on social and health causes. That doesn't mean he deserves praise. He is sacrificing nothing. He lives just as luxuriously, but now he also gets to luxuriate in all the adoration of his "generosity". Who deserves more admiration, Bill Gates giving away money he can't really spend on himself anyway, from the comfort of his 60,000 sq ft mansion with a 2,500 sq ft gym, a 60 ft pool, and a 23-car garage filled with exotic cars? Or the person who decides against a lucrative career path to be a public school teacher with the meager pay and little thanks? Or the doctors who volunteer for Doctors Without Borders, often working in dangerous places, when they could be using that time to rake in more money at home?
- MichaelGG 11y agoIt's not really the "giving money away" part - though I would note that there are ways to spend it (like a floating sea palace or something). It's that the Gates Foundation is successfully getting things done. At least, that's the impression I get after reading their annual letters. It's not a typical charity where it's all about helping people today (giving out food, medical service, etc.). It's about changing things so things will get improved. So things like bringing in new types of crops to Africa - that kind of thing might make a real impact forever. And even more interesting is that his money isn't enough. He cannot buy solutions to these problems. 50 or 100BN just isn't a ton of money on a global scale, to e.g. immunize a billion people.
- jtmcmc 11y agoI think the answer would be try to treat it using modern medicine and having a high chance of living.
- gozo 11y agoWhen people get cancer they usually get more concerned about their legacy. Whether denial or not how Steve Jobs choose to spend his last years tells us something. Bill Gates is the real deal when it comes to philanthropy. Not only directly, but by founding the giving pledge with Warren Buffet. They made giving away your wealth cool. I think people who feel a relationship to Steve Jobs are doing what they are accusing other of, making him into someone he wasn't.