4 ms·
The idea of "spacetime" makes a fun narrative, fun thought experiments, and interesting ways to graph and visualize events. But many physicists wish that popul
by dahart 11y ago
The idea of "spacetime" makes a fun narrative, fun thought experiments, and interesting ways to graph and visualize events.
But many physicists wish that popularizing this concept would stop and go away, because it is misleading. There is both evidence and theoretical work demonstrating that time, unlike the spatial dimensions, is not a choice when it comes to direction of travel, and never will be.
The definition of time as a numerical order of change in space is replacing the 106-year-old concept of time as a physical dimension in which change runs,” Sorli said. “We consider time being only a mathematical quantity of change that we measure with clocks. This is in accord with a Gödel view of time. By 1949, Gödel had produced a remarkable proof: 'In any universe described by the theory of relativity, time cannot exist.' Our research confirms Gödel's vision: time is not a physical dimension of space through which one could travel into the past or future.”
http://phys.org/news/2012-04-physicists-abolish-fourth-dimension-space.html http://phys.org/news/2012-04-physicists-abolish-fourth-dimen...
Edit: previous thread on HN re this article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3842734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3842734
Sounds like some think this phys.org article is BS. I don't know, I am not a physicist. But I have been wondering for many years whether it makes sense to treat time as a dimension. I assumed it made sense in relativity study, and has been mistranslated in popular science culture as a thing that somehow opens up the option of time travel.
- Ono-Sendai 11y agoMy take on it is that special relativity provides no evidence that time is an extra dimension (like the spatial dimensions) in anything but a mathematical sense. General relativity however has quite a lot of effects that mingle together space and time in various ways, so I'm still thinking about that one.
- RivieraKid 11y ago> no evidence that time is an extra dimension (like the spatial dimensions) in anything but a mathematical sense What do you mean by time being an extra dimension in non-mathematical sense? Dimensions and space are mathematical concepts.
- Ono-Sendai 11y agoSome people think that time is physically similar to space, e.g. that their is something 'out there', physically existing, which we call space-time.
- whatshisface 11y agoTime can be a dimension and still be treated differently. In fact, in special relativity, it is. When calculating the spacetime "distance" between two events, we use something that looks like the Pythagorean theorem, but we must always make sure to put a different sign in front of time than we do space. (If we sum the squares of space, we must subtract the square of time) (see: minkowski metric, really any metric) Another point of interest would be the matrix representation of the Lorentz transformation (the way to go from one reference frame to another). The matrix "mixes" the values of the time coordinate with the space coordinates, and the space coordinates with each other, but time is mixed differently. (This is a nice one to bring up because its clear if you just look at the matrix.) This is very significant for people wondering about time's status as a dimension. It is emphatically not the same kind of dimension as space, even if we choose to represent it as a component of the position vector.
- api 11y agoA big source of confusion is dimension as mathematical vector element vs spatial dimension. These are different concepts. Still it is interesting that x, y, and z seem identical while t is intrinsically unidirectional. Why?
- dweinus 11y agoNot a physicist -> My assumption is that this is because x,y,z are just constructs to model physical space. They don't exist and we could just as well describe space with cartisian coordinates or some other system where the dimensions would not be isometric. Meanwhile, as you point out, t as a vector is also itself a convenient model for something, not an actual dimension.
- api 11y agoHmm... if t is also then not a Cartesian dimension, it makes me wonder if the whole Cartesian model isn't a bad model of fundamental reality. Maybe it's just a mathematical shortcut.
- foobarian 11y ago
- RivieraKid 11y agoI really like the presentation in one of Lev Landau's books. He calls it a fictitious 4-dimensional space. That's the correct way to look at it, spacetime is just a mental model, a tool for describing physical laws. So depending on the mental model or framework we decide to use, time can be a dimension or something completely different.
- mbfg 11y agodahart: >> has been mistranslated in popular science culture as a thing that somehow opens up the option of time travel. Ah, time travel isn't science fiction. Clearly we have concrete experiments that show this is common place, easy and done all the time. The faster you go in the space dimension, the slow you move in the time dimension. Now certainly being able to go back in time is something of speculation, and more the realm of science fiction. but that you can jump into other people's future is fact.
- dahart 11y agoYou're right, and that's my understanding too. But I would say that relativistic perception of time does not classify as "time travel", unless mere existence classifies as time travel. Yes, time slows down or speeds up depending on velocity, but not in a way that you have any control over. Time is not a choice, its not an axis upon which you can choose your direction of travel, it is only something you are subjected to and can observe. Now, I guess this is a very subjective discussion, but saying you can "jump into other people's future" feels like a way to make it sound sexy while glossing over the boring detail that you have to sit through all the intervening time along the way, the "jump" isn't instantaneous, and once you "jump", there's no going back. In this sense, we're always jumping into the future each and every second, and it would be equally correct to state as fact that we can wait into other people's future.