4 ms·
The linked Bloomberg article has a hilarious quotation at the bottom: > Exploring odd things isn’t likely to help SAP attract more cloud customers in the short
by jacobolus 11y ago
The linked Bloomberg article has a hilarious quotation at the bottom:
> Exploring odd things isn’t likely to help SAP attract more cloud customers in the short term, says Bill Hostmann, an analyst at researcher Gartner. “What SAP really needs is more execution,” he says. “A lot of people took inspiration from PARC. Did Xerox directly benefit from that? Not really.”
Bill Hostmann has no clue. Xerox got the laser printer out of PARC, which ended up as a multibillion dollar business for them.
- davelnewton 11y agoFor awhile. Xerox didn't realize the potential of what they had--it took time to realize their vision, by which time it was too late for Xerox. They failed to capitalize on their entire portfolio.
- rayiner 11y agoThe bigger problem for Xerox was that in 1975, about five years after establishing PARC, the DOJ forced them to license their entire patent portfolio to Japanese competitors. That dramatically changed the dynamic at Xerox, which had been able to think big ideas while riding its copier monopoly. Xerox, AT&T, and to a lesser extent Google are strong examples of competitive markets being bad for innovation. Bell Labs didn't survive the AT&T breakup in the same form, and I doubt Google would be able to screw around with self-driving cars and wearable computing if they didn't have network effects protecting them from competition.
- api 11y agoPeter Thiel likes to make this contrarian point: competition forces you into a deflationary downward spiral where you must spend all your energy fighting with and therefore duplicating your competitors. An example of the latter would be Google Plus, which was an attempt to compete with Facebook by badly imitating them. Government is the ultimate monopoly, and government research can spend time trying to send people to space, look back to the origins of the universe, and so on.
- coliveira 11y agoThe problem of Xerox was that they research group produced things much beyond their ability to market and execute. Xerox executives thought about the world in terms of printers, not in terms of revolutionary computers. They could have made trillions of dollars if they had executives who truly understood and valued innovation.
- davelnewton 11y agoThey only barely understood the world in terms of printers, too. If they'd capitalized on their entire portfolio they could have taken over the world and we'd probably be a decade beyond where we are now.
- Tloewald 11y agoSAP ain't Xerox though. The idea of SAP hiring a bunch of maverick UI geniuses is pretty mind-boggling. This is a company whose products are almost the complete antithesis of good UI design (they're also the antithesis of software integration you don't customize their software for your organization, you customize your organization for their software). If there's one corporate software experience I've had that was worse than Lotus Notes, it's being forced to use SAP (and at the time I was also being forced to use Perforce for a marketing website). I guess this is a sign SAP (or someone at SAP) at least recognizes they're got a real problem, but I doubt they'll be able to turn that boat around.
- ryanmarsh 11y ago> The idea of SAP hiring a bunch of maverick UI geniuses is pretty mind-boggling. Except that in the late 90's they did exactly that. They brought in Frog and what they produced was quite exceptional given the state of native UI at the time. Not saying SAP is the paragon of innovation, just that even a broken clock is right twice a day.