3 ms·
I wonder how much all of it has to do with crude oil being traded in USD.
by digi_owl 11y ago
I wonder how much all of it has to do with crude oil being traded in USD.
- adventured 11y agoIt's a common theory certainly, that the so-called petro dollar is the reason the USD is dominant. However the US had the world's largest economy by about 1890 or so. At that point it was already significantly far ahead of the classic (and much older) powers France and Germany. It didn't require the global petro dollar to accomplish that. Oil has become less important in the last 40 years, while the dollar has remained stubbornly in place as the reserve standard. We're now within ~20 years of a large scale switch to electric vehicles for instance, and the dollar is doing the opposite of quaking in its boots. Possessing ~45% of all global wealth is far more powerful as a lever, than having the petro dollar. The US has the world's richest corporations, its richest citizens, the world's largest middle class, the #2 manufacturing economy, the top universities, the highest total scientific and invention output, and remains extremely innovative with a high level of productivity - while having 320 million citizens generating a massive tax base and GDP. I understand the arguments about the importance of the petro dollar. I don't agree that it's nearly as important as supporters of that theory project.
- digi_owl 11y ago> The US has the world's richest corporations, its richest citizens I do wonder how quickly those would "flag out" if ever the tide turned. Damn it, likely many of them already have wealth stuffed away in offshore accounts.
- realusername 11y ago> The US has the world's richest corporations, its richest citizens, the world's largest middle class For the richest corporations, citizens and the rest I agree but I'm not sure the middle class is as good as it was before, the american middle class has been quite destroyed recently. It's more that the richest got richer, the poor got poorer and the middle class sort of disapeared in the middle. But I have an impression that it's a trend with a lot of things in the US. Sure the top US universities are the best in the world but if you pick one school at random, I'm pretty sure that it's not as good as its european counterpart. (But this does not affect your argument anyway).
- caf 11y agoGermany isn't "much older" - there wasn't a unified German state until well after the founding of the USA.
- hueving 11y agoNone, that theory makes no sense because if neither the seller nor the buyer of the oil want USD, it's a zero sum for the value of the USD. If either of them want to keep money in USD, then that is demand completely separate from the oil.