3 ms·
The Zombie Preacher of Somerset (2009)
- joe_the_user 11y agoThe thing about this is that a "philosophical zombie" actually is expected to be absolutely indistinguishable from the outside from an ordinary person[1]. This person's stated self-reflection violates that and so this person couldn't be philosophical zombie - or at least couldn't be deduced to be p-zombie because of this behavior. Given that the concept is basically utterly dull - there literally "nothing to see here" - I understand the impulse to liven it up by conflating a zombie-like-person or person-who-says-they're-a-zombie with a p-zombie. But it's more reasonable to discard the idea of immeasurable, inherent, atomic consciousness/qualia/satience as something useful to consider and look at measurable, meaningful versions of these labels. And by the end of the article the author admits his example is an "imperfect p-zombie" but I think that entirely misses the point of p-zombies, which absolute hypothetical constructs or they are something else entirely. "A philosophical zombie or p-zombie in the philosophy of mind and perception is a hypothetical being that is indistinguishable from a normal human being except in that it lacks conscious experience, qualia, or sentience. For example, a philosophical zombie could be poked with a sharp object, and not feel any pain sensation, but yet, behave exactly as if it does feel pain (it may say "ouch" and recoil from the stimulus, or say that it is in intense pain)" [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_zombie
- civilian 11y agoAnd if you think the idea of philosophical zombies are rad, you should read Blindsight by Peter Watts. http://www.rifters.com/real/Blindsight.htm http://www.rifters.com/real/Blindsight.htm His books asks a somewhat different question, which is: "is consciousness an evolutionarily desirable trait?"
- joe_the_user 11y agoWell, it seems like he'd have to first answer the question "what is consciousness", something the confused idea of "philosophical zombies" shows we're far from answering.
- cbd1984 11y ago> or at least couldn't be deduced to be p-zombie because of this behavior. But that's rather the point of the p-zombie concept: Anything you can do, they can do just as well, to all outwards appearances, it's just that they don't have the true deep awareness of doing that you do... You do have that, right? You sure? Really sure? So there's no objective test which can distinguish between you and a p-zombie, but there's still a difference. Poking into the nature of that difference is either blasphemy or contrary to the spirit of the thing, your choice.
- hugh4 11y ago> So there's no objective test which can distinguish between you and a p-zombie Oh there is for me, just not for anyone else. I know I'm conscious, but I don't necessarily expect anyone else to believe it.
- cbd1984 11y ago> I know I'm conscious Ah, but do you really?
- joe_the_user 11y ago* it's just that they don't have the true deep awareness of doing that you do... You do have that, right? You sure? Really sure?* Actually, I don't find such concepts even interesting, so I'm neither sure nor not-sure. The belief in a conscious defined as a quality-with-no-testable-attributes seems like an extension of the idea of a soul and this lines of philosophical seems like the very ghost of belief in a dead god.
- unclebucknasty 11y agoPossibly among other things, it sounds like he was suffering from extreme depersonalization. It's a dissociative state that can present after a traumatic event, then persist.