24 ms·
The Joyful, Illiterate Kindergartners of Finland
- cassieramen 11y agoMichael Booth talks about Finland's schools in his book, "The Almost Nearly Perfect People: Behind the Myth of the Scandinavian Utopia." He points out that in Finland the most revered and treasured profession is teaching. The smartest students, the most driven students, they all become teachers. Articles like this are wonderful at pointing out that relaxed and individualized teaching can succeed but they are glossing over an important cultural norm.
- secabeen 11y agoThe other important note is that the environment for teachers is good. We get lots of great people into teaching right after college through Teach for America and other programs, but they don't want to stay teachers.
- douche 11y agoWho would, when you get sent to the kind of underfunded, marginalized districts that are desperate enough to conclude that a liberal arts student who has no training in education, nor any student-teaching experience, is a reasonable option?
- douche 11y agoI have several friends that are still in education, and several more who bailed after TFA. It doesn't help that teachers get paid such shit wages, and the only way to earn more in most districts is to hang on and take your yearly bump. Or get a University of Phoenix master's degree for a little bit more of a bump.
- dalke 11y agoI don't think it's appropriate to complain about an article being incomplete when it was written to be a facet of a more complete series of articles. That is, this article 'gloss[ed] over an important cultural norm' because it is mentioned in other Atlantic articles. Specifically, the text "Finnish schools have received substantial media attention for years now" links to another Atlantic article which says: > For Sahlberg what matters is that in Finland all teachers and administrators are given prestige, decent pay, and a lot of responsibility. A master's degree is required to enter the profession, and teacher training programs are among the most selective professional schools in the country. If a teacher is bad, it is the principal's responsibility to notice and deal with it. and the text "because of the consistently strong performance of its 15-year-olds on international tests like the PISA" links to another Atlantic article which says: > Teachers have a lot of autonomy. They are highly educated--they all have master’s degrees and becoming a teacher is highly competitive. Instead, and in the same paragraph, the author says that this article will more specifically provide 'coverage on Finland’s youngest students', which the author thinks has been missing, and not cover the entire topic of Finnish schooling.
- ptaipale 11y ago> If a teacher is bad, it is the principal's responsibility to notice and deal with it. Isn't this the case pretty much everywhere? In reality, if a teacher is bad, there is precious little the principal can do about it in Finland. Almost all teachers are fortunately good, but I have met a couple who were completely hopeless. The schools absolutely couldn't get rid of them once they had been hired to permanent positions. Personal experience (Finland): my grade 3-6 teacher was himself the principal in a two-teacher school, an electrician by profession, and had been quick-trained to take a teacher's job after being discharged from the army at the end of the War - no master's degree, no degree from any university. He actually did close-order drill for PE. And if I was unruly, he hit me in the head. Yes, teachers are better trained nowadays (what I describe was 1970's and the man retired in 1980's).
- dalke 11y agoNice observation! Yes, you're right. To double check, http://teaching.about.com/od/Information-For-Teachers/a/Bad-Teachers.htm http://teaching.about.com/od/Information-For-Teachers/a/Bad-... says (in the US context) "A major part of a principal’s job is to identify which teachers are effective, which teachers need to improve, and which ones are ineffective and need to be dismissed." Though it's not the complete truth. In the US, some school districts have policies that a teacher can be fired for having a bad score based on a 'value added model', where the scores of the students are compared to a model of what the scores "should" have been, and used to assign an effectiveness score to teachers (including, say, the score for an biology teacher when the tests have nothing to do with biology - https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/wp/2013/04/15/lawsuit-stop-evaluating-teachers-on-test-scores-of-students-they-never-taught/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/wp/2013/04...) and even the custodial staff (https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/wp/2013/04/16/d-c-custodial-staff-were-evaluated-by-student-test-scores-really/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/wp/2013/04... ). The principals have little say in the results of these decisions.
- shostack 11y agoHow is teacher compensation over there? I always thought we'd see better outcomes in schools if we paid enough for the best and brightest to become teachers. Fact is, they cannot live in many "reasonably priced" housing markets (let alone the Bay/SF) on a typical teacher salary in the US.
- pasiaj 11y agoThecher compensation is a bit above the national average and they have long vacations. What is also very meaningful to notice is that due to high income taxes, income redistribution, and generally flatter pay scale overall compared to most other countries, a corporate lawyer isn't that much better off than a teacher.
- jkyle 11y ago> generally flatter pay scale overall compared to most other countries, a corporate lawyer isn't that much better off than a teacher. The most important aspect of this is that when your nation's best and brightest choose a career path, massive disparities in quality of life is not a mitigating factor detracting from careers in education.
- aianus 11y agoGood teachers are important, but they can only affect, what, 20 kids a year? The best and brightest should stick to engineering and finance where they can have a bigger impact.
- jkyle 11y ago> The best and brightest should stick to engineering and finance where they can have a bigger impact. Many of the best and brightest stay in academia, but at the university level. Many others go into engineering and finance, but make no real lasting impact mostly working on the day to day tasks of making the cogs turn. Currently many of the smartest engineers in silicon valley have dedicated their careers to selling targeted ads. In the scheme of things, I'd be hard pressed placing selling X more power drills a year or "yet another CRUD app" over building the foundation of a quality education system.
- jkyle 11y ago> The smartest students, the most driven students, they all become teachers. Part of that is the cultural status of teachers. But another large contributor is the policy status of teachers w.r.t rate of pay, autonomy, and educational requirements. All teachers must obtain a Masters. They are paid in line with expected median or greater for those of their educational level. They are also, by policy, the main driving force and final say on curriculums and educational program design. Further, they are expected to remain current within their field and often publish throughout their career. In other words, the pay and job preference is the type that attracts the academically minded. And does so without requiring them to assume standards of living far below their educational investment. Society at large lends respect to fields based, by and large, on superficial reasons. In the U.S. we offer teachers pay and respect (within the job) more in line with short order cooks with a G.E.D. than professionals. Society's treatment of the profession reflects that.
- rapala 11y agoDo note that lower university degrees are relatively new thing in Finland. It is still common to consider your studies "done" only after you have graduated with a master's degree. Teaching teachers in university is also relatively new, started in 1974. By my observations, pedagogy is considered one of the most applied sciencies taught in university and I would say that it attracts the least academically mind of those applying in university.
- wahsd 11y agoIt really feels like we are gutting our education system with this kind of nonsense. It's so weird. We do so poorly in our education system, yet rather than simply doing what the effective and successful education systems and societies do, we decide that we need to change everything and now deprive children of playing as if they are some kind of little adults.
- pavedwalden 11y agoI think there's a real resistance against solutions that don't feel like "getting tough". "increasing standards" and "raising expectations" are easy to sell. The idea that children need to do childish things is dismissed as too wishy-washy.
- jessaustin 11y agoServices provided by the democratic state are vulnerable to feel-good emotion-based mismanagement.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pavlov 11y agoI've lived my life in Finland. I don't know if the schools are all that (it's been 20 years since mine)... But I can speak for municipal daycare / kindergarten, as I have a 3-year-old daughter and I've been extremely happy with the care. The teachers and staff at the center are so competent and compassionate. Playing is always at the forefront, but they have educational themes for a full year that are cleverly integrated into the daily rhythm. The children are always doing short trips that reveal new things of their daily surroundings in the city. The social environment mixes children of various ages: there are kids of age 2 and 5 in the same groups. I know my child's life would be a lot poorer without daycare. And it only costs about 200 euros / month. (We're paying the maximum price since we're two working parents; with less family income the price would go down to nearly zero. Also, children are eligible for daycare even if their parents are not working.) Giving our kids a rich social life and early education without the pressures of a traditional school model is probably the one thing Finnish society has figured out. (The rest is more or less a mess right now.)
- Swizec 11y ago> Giving our kids a rich social life and early education without the pressures of a traditional school model is probably the one thing Finnish society has figured out. (The rest is more or less a mess right now.) Coming from Slovenia, that's what kindergarten is supposed to be. The word literally means "children's garden" and has nothing to do with school. To quote wikipedia "literally children's garden, is a preschool educational approach traditionally based on playing, singing, practical activities such as drawing, and social interaction as part of the transition from home to school.". I don't know what happened in the anglophone world that turned this joyful concept into school. My girlfriend grew up in the US and considers "kindergarten" to be the beginning of school school where they start by teaching you how to read&write. Wikipedia seems to confirm this notion. Maybe it's just semantics and word-meaning drift.
- foobarian 11y agoI thought kindergarten would be equivalent to Croatian "vrtić" too, but it seems to be the year before 1st grade. Before that there is a spectrum of programs like daycare or preschool or playgroups which are more like what the grandparent described. I've no idea why kindergarten took on such a specific meaning in the US.
- andyl 11y agoPerhaps the lesson of Finland is that mono-culturalism achieves better educational outcomes than multi-culturalism. Maybe it is easier if stakeholders have high levels of trust, and similar performance expectations, work ethic, language skills, etc.
- pasiaj 11y agoPerhaps. But let's not jump to conclusions.
- dalke 11y agoStrictly speaking, Finland is not a mono-culture. Finland has people from Finnish-speaking and Swedish-speaking cultures. Your objection has been raised before. As http://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/why-are-finlands-schools-successful-49859555/?no-ist=&no-cache=_page%3D2_page%3D5_page%3D2&page=3 http://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/why-are-finlands-sc... points out: > Some of the more vocal conservative reformers in America have grown weary of the “We-Love-Finland crowd” or so-called Finnish Envy. They argue that the United States has little to learn from a country of only 5.4 million people—4 percent of them foreign born. Yet the Finns seem to be onto something. Neighboring Norway, a country of similar size, embraces education policies similar to those in the United States. It employs standardized exams and teachers without master’s degrees. And like America, Norway’s PISA scores have been stalled in the middle ranges for the better part of a decade.
- ptaipale 11y ago> Strictly speaking, Finland is not a mono-culture. No country is an absolute monoculture or absolutely multicultural, but Finland is a remarkably monocultural country compared to most industrialized nations, with a strong social cohesion and rather minor ethnic divides. Swedish-speakers are very similar in culture and values to Finnish-speaking Finns, they just speak a different language. Right now there is a huge migration going on - about 50 000 asylum seekers will come to the country within the year and it looks the pace will just increase. That means 1% of population, which is a rather significant demographic change in just one year. It will definitely have an impact. I do not really believe Norwegian results are that much different. PISA is just one metric. In the most recent PISA (2012) Finland is #12; in the previous one it was #6 and the one before that it was #2. Did the quality of teaching drop that much in just a few years? Hardly.
- krylon 11y agoIIRC, the Latin word "ludus" means both "game" and "school". I do not think that is a coincidence. The observation that one learns more easily in playful manner is probably well-known in (but hardly exclusive to) hacker circles. In a way, it is baffling that people would forget this, especially as it is not excactly a brand-new discovery.
- SomeCallMeTim 11y agoWhat most people don't seem to know is that fun and play simply is learning. Kids play act scenarios all day that they're learning about. It's a way of internalizing what they've learned. Take away time for unstructured play, and you'll find a lot of kids have less ability to learn, simply because their brains need the play time to absorb the relevant facts. We're using a curriculum-free homeschooling approach, and while my kids aren't on the exact same learning timetable, they're close enough to the normal education track -- and well beyond it in the areas that most interest them -- that I'm not worried. And they play all the time.
- pjlegato 11y agoI think you're interpreting that backwards. "Ludus" originally referred to educational training sessions to build skills for later performing activities of direct practical benefit, mainly combat and political oratory. This is how "ludus" means both "play" and "school." It's originally "play" in the sense of "play-fighting," not in the sense of "having fun without a particular goal." Unlike Greek academies, Roman schools were entirely focused on building practical skills. The idea of "play" as "having fun without any particular goal orientation" is a thoroughly modern idea. The idea that school should be a form of "play" in the modern sense is an even more recent one. It has no basis in ancient Rome.
- krylon 11y agoSo our Latin teacher lied to us! I should have known... Thank you very much for the explation! EDIT: In Latin class, our textbook was called "Ludus Latinus", and our teacher made a big point of explaining how that meant learning was supposed to be a kind of game. It made me groan at the time, but in later years, I always thought it made perfect sense.
- tootie 11y agoMy kids hate it when the schools have unstructured time. They love their free time, but want to do it at home or with their friends and not with all the kids they are forced to interact with at school. At school they want kids to behave predictably. That being said, I'm wondering if they wouldn't benefit from it because it will force them to deal with social situations they aren't comfortable with.
- dalke 11y agoIs 'unstructured' a euphemism? If the children are expected to 'behave predictably' and 'forced to interact with other children', doesn't that imply some structure? (I assume 'predictably' means something more specific than, say 'not try to set the school on fire.') This article uses the terms 'spontaneous and free form' and 'guided and pedagogical'. It doesn't sound like the former requires children to interact with others, though I can't tell from the article. Certainly the latter isn't unstructured.
- tootie 11y agoThey're not forced by the structure, they're forced by the other kids. If she wants to sit and read and keeps getting hit in the head with paper airplanes, she gets annoyed. When do they have some of organized chaos, like all the kids in the playground playing the same game, she's pretty happy with that.
- dalke 11y agoThank you for clearing that up. I totally misunderstood.
- Throwaway1224 11y agoGrew up in the USA. Spent 8 years in Finland. Finnish kids are taught by the parents to read long before they get to school. Sure, it helps that the Finnish language is phonetic... But really, it's a home environment that teaches that reading is fun and enjoyable and can get you what you want. Same goes for counting and basic arithmetic. It's a cultural thing. Teachers in Finland are not geniuses. The caliber of the teachers is, in fact, higher than the USA, but this stems more from seats in schools as opposed to "smart people wanting to become teachers". The desirability ranking of what the average student would like to do goes like this: Medical Engineer Law French Pyschology ... Education ... Waiter ... So somewhere along this spectrum, you get a bunch of qualified people who become teachers. There's only a limited number of seats for each profession (driven by free education... you can NOT become anything you want to become, you have to do better than the others on the entrance test). So you don't get a disproportionate group of people getting a degree in History or Biology or Pyschology. The number seats are arranged according to the needs of the society. And kids would rather be teachers than waiters (yes, there's a school for that). In Finland, teachers do NOT make more than engineers or doctors. They make about one third (pre tax) of what doctors or engineers make. Also, Finland is incredibly homogenous. Take that for what you will...
- dmd 11y agoWhat does "French" mean in this context?
- sanoli 11y agoIt reads as "If finns can't become doctors or lawyers or engineers, they'd like to become french". She/He probably wanted to write Finance, but the autocorrect did its thing.
- nickbauman 11y agoFrom what I've read about the Finish school system educators are selected from the top quartile of academic performers of university students. In the US, educators are ranked in the bottom 1/3. The limited number of seats per profession is a new one, but kinda makes sense. However, by doing this the nation "locks in" their capacity for growth in these areas. It would seem that this is somewhat misguided. An economy cannot be very efficient if it makes decisions a decade in advance.
- aaron695 11y agoThe Finish education myth - http://www.bbc.com/news/business-32302374 http://www.bbc.com/news/business-32302374
- nickbauman 11y agoThat article is misleading. Standardized curriculum was in fact one of the things people looking at Finland said was part of its success model in 2000. So this was never a "misconception".
- aaron695 11y agoThe article isn't perfect but relate it to the current article. To me the author sounds like they have this exact misconception.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- DasIch 11y agoAs a German - you know the country the word Kindergarten comes from - I'm always amazed that people consider Kindergarten to be a school of some kind. Kindergärten aren't schools in Germany, they don't operate like schools, you don't learn to read or write, there is no math, in fact there aren't any classes nor classrooms. A lot of the time you spend in Kindergarten is purely socializing and playing with other children. If there are groups, then only so that the educators (not teachers) don't get overwhelmed. Children are grouped randomly and stay in one group for as long as they go to Kindergarten, so you have children from 3 up to 7 in one group. The activities that are organized or structured in any way are eating, sleeping, singing, getting told stories, making things out of paper like lanterns, a few physical activities and of course activities that happen outside of the Kindergarten. Kindergärten exist and are important not to learn math but to learn to interact with other people, to make friends and to be a child until you are mature enough to handle a school environment. That means that while typically a child is enrolled in school with 6, some also enroll a year earlier or later depending on the child.
- fredrikcarno 11y agoHere in Sweden we pay 110 euros total per month for very good daycare with cocked food (no prefab) for our 3 year old twins. Interesting how it is elsewhere. Our wages are relativley low and massive amounts of tax of course
- jib 11y agoSwedish average wages are close to the top (if not at the top)in EU. The wage gap is a lot lower than most countries though. Just mentioning since I stated Swedish wages were low not long ago, but when I looked it up that wasn't the case overall, it's just that normally high paying jobs pay less there.
- lemming 11y agoI just finished the article, and saw a reference there to a New Zealand study about Rudolf Steiner schools. I attended the same Steiner school as the author of the study, and I would consider several people from my class to be functionally illiterate. This mostly comes down to the quality of the school rather than the philosophy - when I joined it was very new and run by a bunch of well-meaning hippies who had basically no idea about education. If you're going to have a child-led education system where you assume that if the child isn't reading it's because they're not ready yet, you better be damn sure you're not missing the signs of something more serious, because if you do, when you come to address it it will be much more difficult the later you intervene. It sounds like the teachers in Finland are probably good enough to catch this - ours were not.
- fsloth 11y ago"It sounds like the teachers in Finland are probably good enough to catch this - ours were not." Yes, the teachers (not tests or rigorous standardization) are the keystone of the finnish school system.
- maus42 11y agoWell, here the kindergarten with child-led play isn't that much part of the education system. Even the pre-school year is fundamentally just preparing kids for the school, which is still very much teacher-led. The written Finnish being very easy to spell and read also probably contributes. There are only very few peculiarities that differentiate from the logical 1-1 mapping between letter symbols and vocal sounds. Practically all children all able to attain at least the basic functional literacy skills in a couple of years. (I really couldn't understand the concept of spelling bee competitions in US TV shows, like that one Peanuts animated film, until we started English.)
- wmt 11y agoRemember that this article was talking about preschool. Once you get to the first school grade in Finland, you will be taught to read.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ASM_god 11y agoretch....as someone who has worked in education and in government bureaucracy, the stench of unrealistic academic theorizing lies heavy on this idea.