4 ms·
Am I correct in thinking that the people who have a positive view of brutalism are people with a background in architecture? Because I've never met any non-arc
by lordnacho 11y ago
Am I correct in thinking that the people who have a positive view of brutalism are people with a background in architecture?
Because I've never met any non-architect who thought it was nice. It's part of a wider observation on my part about certain aesthetic tastes that only people who are part of specific in-groups declare themselves to enjoy works that 99% of people find unappealing.
Various kinds of modern art, for instance.
- ctdonath 11y ago“There are some ideas so absurd that only an intellectual could believe them.” ― George Orwell
- liotier 11y ago> Am I correct in thinking that the people who have a positive view of brutalism are people with a background in architecture? I may be heavily biased as having grown up in La Défense, but I thoroughly enjoy brutalism for how it embraces functionality as the yardstick for aesthetics. The outward appearance of brutalist buildings may clash with many people's tastes, but their inside is livable - way more livable than classic architecture and at a much more affordable cost. Don't forget that brutalism came of age during Europe's housing crisis and that mass manufacture was the key to solving it. As a result, many brutalist products have been cheaply built, giving it a bad name - but as buildings such as La Défense's Vision 80, they can be very nice too and stand the test of time: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/R%C3%A9sidence_Vision_80 https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/R%C3%A9sidence_Vision_80
- Lagged2Death 11y agoA person with a background in architecture probably has a different understanding about the meaning and origin of the very word "brutalism" than the average bystander does, so it's hard to say. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brutalist_architecture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brutalist_architecture "Brutalism" as an architectural critical term was not always consistently used by critics ... "brutalism" has become used in popular discourse to refer to buildings of the late twentieth century that are large or unpopular – as a synonym for "brutal" – making its effective use in architectural historical discourse problematic. "Brutalist" in English is a terrible, misleading name. It was about futurism and misplaced faith in concrete as a miracle material, not brutality. Given the way so many bad Brutalist buildings look, it's easy to see how people could make the mistake. It seems to me that at least a few well-known architectural trends consist of 1) a few amazing masterpieces that become instant classics and 2) 20x as many cheap knock-offs, which everyone comes to hate, which are consequently not maintained well, which eventually give the trend a bad name. The "International Style" is the other example (alongside Brutalism) that stands out in my mind; for every Seagram building or Lever House, there are dozens (hundreds?) of copycat school buildings or anonymous low-budget office cubes that end up looking like prisons.
- i80and 11y agoI have no background in architecture, but by far my favorite building from my school campus was very brutalist in nature: http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-___cRB72NnI/TmmMnkQWPCI/AAAAAAAADTM/3vbzlkjqVPA/s1600/fqwpeok.jpg http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-___cRB72NnI/TmmMnkQWPCI/AAAAAAAADT... http://images51.fotki.com/v1/photos/1/10467/18529/fe820adcjpgorig-vi.jpg http://images51.fotki.com/v1/photos/1/10467/18529/fe820adcjp... http://www.mndaily.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/slideshow_image/images/photos/2011/11/08/p1demolition.jpg http://www.mndaily.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/slides... It's been shunned by my school for years; is due to be demolished; and there are few photos of the interior. It's a tragedy to me, since I spent as much time as I could lounging in it.