5 ms·
One thing I think might be interesting is how the history of economic thought affects the war/peace calculus. For much of history, people thought of wealth as
by lordnacho 11y ago
One thing I think might be interesting is how the history of economic thought affects the war/peace calculus.
For much of history, people thought of wealth as a sort of zero-sum (or near) game. If one country gets richer, another will get poorer. If Athens get rich, Sparta gets poor. If Britain has colonies, France and Germany need colonies. Everyone wants to be an exporter and hoard gold.
The economic thought about this started to change around the time of David Ricardo (comparative advantage overturning mercantilism), but I would not be surprised if mainstream politicians took some time to understand this idea.
These days it's pretty clear the US and China benefit from mutual trade, and anything upsetting that would require quite some compensation.
Aside from economics, there's also the fact that we've seen massive global wars already, and we have weapons that could make the world unliveable for generations. Particularly if you look at Chinese history, there's an enormous amount of bloodshed. The party leadership will understand this.
- staticvar 11y ago> These days it's pretty clear the US and China benefit from mutual trade Yes, that is probably the current perception even with most people never hearing of competitive advantage. I wonder how climate change in the next couple of decades will change this war/peace calculus. I fear we may realize that benefits that the U.S. and China receive from trade partnerships is from extracting natural capital and replacing it with negative externalities. When that natural capital runs out and negative externalities come back to bite us in the form of climate change, what will the U.S. and China think of each other then? Will we still believe in competitive advantage then?
- exelius 11y agoChina has made a huge about-face in the last 2 years on energy. Their policy is currently to invest heavily in green energy for domestic use, and to become the global green energy technology leader. I think they will be successful - advances in energy tech take superpower-level resources, but they also tend to sustain those superpowers for a long time. China will build their dominance on 'clean' energy. No doubt about it.
- exelius 11y agoI think that you're right -- the Chinese administration is ruthless, but also pragmatic. I think when they look at the USA, they see a country at war with itself. There's no need to destroy us since we do such a good job of it ourselves. Also, the USA has a pretty huge advantage geographically over every other country in the world: our borders consist of oceans we can easily defend with our navy and allied countries who are strong both militarily and economically. We also have access to all of the factors of production of an army (steel, oil, etc.) domestically and the industry necessary to process them. Geographically, we're very protected as well: attack from the north and you have 2000 miles of Canadian tundra too extreme to march an army across that can be littered with radar and anti-aircraft stations. Attack from the south and you have to cross rugged, mountainous terrain in Mexico. Even against a weakened USA, victory would be very difficult. War against the US is therefore pointless from the Chinese perspective: a war of the scale a US-China war would likely just rekindle the machinery of American industry while inflicting heavy losses on China. The Chinese government (and people) have a long-term mindset: war would be an impatient choice because China's dominance is all but assured anyway. I don't think American politicians are as pragmatic; and I expect our war hawks to turn their attention to China (likely when China eventually tries to retake Taiwan). From a realpolitik point of view, I actually think that a major war with China is probably the best chance the US has to maintain global dominance over the next 50 years. But that war would need to happen soon, while the US still has a clear technological advantage over China -- in 10 years that advantage will be all but gone. It's looking like the US plans to use Japan as its proxy for fighting China. Japan recently authorized its military to operate in defense of its allies; a first step into removing the post-WWII restrictions placed on the Japanese military. They plan to continue that process; with US support. China sees this as unacceptable -- and is ramping up its military as a result. I think we'll see a China-Japan war in the South China Sea before we see a China-US war. But I think we'll also see China engage in the type of limited incursions / occupations like the Russians did in Georgia and Ukraine, and they won't stop until someone starts fighting back.
- ende 11y agoChina's development is already beginning to slow. It is not headed towards global dominance, it was merely catching up with the rest of the developed world. China will likely continue to enjoy a modernizing economy and growing middle class, but in terms of growth it looks to be headed the same way as Japan.
- pjc50 11y agoThe gas pipeline through Ukraine is a good example of this: it's economically critical to both ends, which is why it's not been blown up in the civil war.
- TheCoelacanth 11y agoIt's telling that of the four cases they studied that didn't result in war, three were the most recent three and the fourth was also in the past century.