4 ms·
But that's actually irrelevant for the cited report. What the referenced graph says is that from 2008 to 2014, auto manufacturers declared a certain increase i
by kbenson 11y ago
But that's actually irrelevant for the cited report. What the referenced graph says is that from 2008 to 2014, auto manufacturers declared a certain increase in emissions/economy, real world people reported a different amount, and those amounted to, unique to GM in this report, a negative percentage in how well they achieved their claims. That is, on average, GM car fuel economy got worse over this period, or people's driving habits changed for GM cars. (I can't discount the possibility of something else is going on, such as an influx of a different type of car for GM over that period, I haven't read yet how they normalized the study and accounted for things like that).
- rnovak 11y agoIt's not irrelevant at all. Manufacturers report fuel consumption during a controlled environment, with specific driving habits, etc. Real world people drive insane (at least in the US), and most wouldn't even re-pass their drivers-license test, so most assuredly do not have the best driving habits. So drawing the conclusion that manufacturers are "lying" from the discrepancies between those two data sets is ridiculous.
- kbenson 11y agoIt's irrelevant because unless both a) people changed their driving habits on average over that time frame to cause more emissions and b) that change was primarily limited to drivers of GM vehicles, then driver habits do nothing to explain the data. > So drawing the conclusion that manufacturers are "lying" from the discrepancies between those two data sets is ridiculous. Perhaps you should pay attention to actually what I said, not what you think I said. I didn't say GM was lying, I implied their numbers deserve extra scrutiny.
- rnovak 11y agoThe whole controversy is over manufacturers reporting false numbers, i.e. lying. Saying a manufacturer deserves extra scrutiny can absolutely be inferred to be an accusation of them reporting false numbers, i.e. lying. My reading comprehension isn't at fault here. Secondly, it's still irrelevant. You would have to prove that an improvement at throttle position 0.10 over 5 years equates directly to an improvement at throttle position 0.40. How an engine performs in condition A has no inherent relation to its performance in condition B. So yes, I stand by what I said. Maybe before accusing people of "not paying attention", you should look at your own language and see if it's ambiguous?
- kbenson 11y ago> Saying a manufacturer deserves extra scrutiny can absolutely be inferred to be an accusation of them reporting false numbers, i.e. lying. > My reading comprehension isn't at fault here Except that I very clearly said "I can't discount the possibility of something else is going on, such as an influx of a different type of car for GM over that period, I haven't read yet how they normalized the study and accounted for things like that." > Maybe before accusing people of "not paying attention", you should look at your own language and see if it's ambiguous? You ignored clear text from me saying that it didn't necessarily indicate GM was at fault. What am I supposed to infer from that? As to the matter at hand, you still seem to be under the impression that driver habits can account for a change in the numbers we are talking about, when that would mean that GM drivers specifically drive very differently than all other car drivers in the report. We are talking about number across the industry, categorized by manufacturer. Everything listed on the graph in question shows automakers overreporting gains, which could be driver habits. GM specifically shows vastly different numbers from event every other manufacturer, not just the reported numbers. I fail to see how driver habit accounts for a specific manufacturer being so out of bounds with it's own reported numbers (keep in mind engines are often shared across multiple manufacturers). Have you looked at the graph on page 13 yet?
- rnovak 11y ago> You ignored clear text from me saying that it didn't necessarily indicate GM was at fault. What am I supposed to infer from that? I didn't ignore anything. I said the source of data is not irrelevant. That's my entire argument. And I was specifically refuting your thesis that the source of data is irrelevant. and, "as to the matter at hand", yes, driver habits can account entirely for the discrepancy in numbers. Flawed data can account for it. Poor sampling can as well. The report seems to have come from a self reporting site in the EU. Are you asserting that a US car manufacturer has sold a uniform distribution of make/model/engine cars across the globe? Are you also asserting that this site is getting a proper randomized sample of the car-buying population, such that they don't all have a similar complaint? In my experience, the people who report such things are one of two cases 1) Extremely Satisfied, or the much more common 2) Extremely Dissatisfied. Are you then also asserting that if GM optimizes for test conditions, which they believe to be similar to normal driving habits, that their engines would be optimized to perform well under conditions that people actually drive in? That's just sloppy. That's like comparing data from your Dev environment to that from Production, I believe there have been a few academic articles to refute that as well. But, ultimately, are you asserting that we should just accept the source of data as a source of truth, and never question whether or not that it's valid? Should I just go buy a bunch of tabloids and take that as my "new news", since.....the source is irrelevant, right?