4 ms·
It's not fair to compare the Model X to a Sedan. Do you have numbers for other SUVs? Remember the idea here is that it's assumed you'll be buying a car alread
by jedberg 11y ago
It's not fair to compare the Model X to a Sedan. Do you have numbers for other SUVs? Remember the idea here is that it's assumed you'll be buying a car already.
Also, even if the total lifetime carbon was equal, it's still better to buy a vehicle that produces all that carbon in localized places where it could possibly be captured instead of all over crowded urban areas.
- doczoidberg 11y agoI just want to mention some facts. EVs are interesting and the future for sure but thinking EVs are the holy grail is just stupid. http://www.digitaltrends.com/cars/hold-smugness-tesla-might-just-worse-environment-know/ http://www.digitaltrends.com/cars/hold-smugness-tesla-might-... How do you can capture carbon?
- jobead 11y agoI think what jedberg meant was that if you are producing the electricity at a centralized place (like even a coal-fired power plant) you could theoretically capture carbon using massive scrubbers on the exhaust towers. Developing similar technology and installing it in all of the individual gas-burning cars would be near impossible. My 2c: The real "secret plan" here is that converting us to electric vehicles paves the way to develop (and creates structural demand for) 0-emission ways to recharge them, like: - resurgence of large nuclear plants - self-contained micro-nuclear reactors that you could bury in your yard - solar on your garage (paired with a Tesla Powerwall to recharge your car at night)
- doczoidberg 11y agoThese 'scrubbers' and nuclear plants are already in my calculations of battery manufacturing C02 production. Base of the CO2 production calculation is the energy mix of germany. In the US it would be even higher(?). Source is an independent german energy research institute btw.
- adventured 11y agoEVs are the holy grail, at least for the next century. Thinking EVs are the holy grail, is incredibly smart. You link them up to nuclear, wind, or solar and drastically reduce the total pollution output across the life of the vehicle, versus a gasoline or diesel vehicle. EVs are as clean as their energy source. Gas and diesel cars are the exact opposite: extremely polluting no matter what you do to them. EVs win period. There's no scenario in which they don't, especially over the next few decades as they leap far ahead of traditional vehicles in every regard. At worst they're less polluting than gasoline vehicles over time, at best they're far less polluting.
- threeseed 11y agoWhy isn't fair to compare Model X to a Sedan ? It IS basically a sedan. It isn't a Landrover style SUV that you could legitimately take off road.
- jedberg 11y agoBecause the people buying an X are not replacing a sedan. They are replacing another SUV like an X5 or ML.
- timdorr 11y agoNot only that, but the fuel source of an ICE must produce carbon output. However, there are many fuel sources for EVs that are carbon neutral (solar, wind, hydro, nuke). Where I live, my power comes from mostly nuclear sources, so the production of my car has been the only major carbon impact that it's had.
- doczoidberg 11y agoAs you can see by the numbers the manufacturing takes a big part of the whole carbon production of EV. Nuclear power is a very bad power source. There is no final depot for nuclear waste on earth. We have to get rid of nuclear power. Hundreds of generations past us will have to deal with this shit of our generation.
- roflchoppa 11y agonuclear energy is the cleanest energy. ALL you produce is a little nuclear waste that you can store underground somewhere.
- doczoidberg 11y agoThe big part is the battery. That causes the high numbers. Not because it is a SUV.