4 ms·
I've written FX trading algos, and I don't think it's so much to do with the fixing scandal. For a long time now, FX has been a low margin business. It's just
by lordnacho 11y ago
I've written FX trading algos, and I don't think it's so much to do with the fixing scandal.
For a long time now, FX has been a low margin business. It's just a guy on the end of a phone. Now they can't even use their one advantage, which is knowledge of flow, because of regulations about prop risk. So that guy on the phone, he's being replaced by a robot. At the end of the day, what does a market maker do? He provides prices and tries to keep risk steady. You can easily (*tm) write a program that does that.
The fixing thing, sure, it means something. It means you lose another income source, because now everyone will be afraid of getting caught. And rightly so.
But the writing was on the wall for the FX traders for a long time. Pretty much every trade under a few million bucks is done by a machine. To justify a phone call you're looking at maybe 30MM USD minimum. If you want to hide your trading, you can probably break up your big trade with an algo. It's also likely that if you have a big order, the guy on the desk is just hitting an algo as well.
Another benefit of automation is you get a load of data about how things are going. The banks will phone you and complain if they are losing money on your flow. They have stats about how profitable all the clients are. And they know if you are gaming their hedging algo.
I really doubt the figure that only 15% of trades were done by algo a year ago. Maybe a few jumbo orders skew it, but by ticket numbers I would think over 80% of trades are on some sort of automation.
- blazespin 11y agoI think you have to weight by trade size. If you didn't, I'd say 99.999% of all trades are algo.
- lordnacho 11y agoYes, but even by trade size, the 15% figure is suspect. Perhaps central bank intervention is done by mega-trade on phone. But even your huge hedge fund is going to be able to execute their B+ trade on an algo.
- jackgavigan 11y ago> I really doubt the figure that only 15% of trades were done by algo a year ago. Maybe a few jumbo orders skew it, but by ticket numbers I would think over 80% of trades are on some sort of automation. I'm inclined to agree with you. The article seems to conflate "algo" and electronic trading, which doesn't help matters. In my experience, the majority of FX trades are just straightforward deals at spot - no algo required. It's only when you've got a really big deal that you want to spread out to avoid moving the market, or where you need to execute at the fixing, that an algo would come into it. > "A year ago, algo orders placed by fund managers and other investors accounted for no more than 10-15% of total trading volumes.." To my mind "trading volumes" refers to the amount being traded, rather than the number of trades, so maybe he means that the value of the algo orders amounted to 10-15% of the total value of all trades (e.g. ten algo trades for $5m each vs one voice trade for $500m).