8 ms·
Agreed. But even when the USA sees the light on proportional representation, there will continue to be winner takes all elections. Executive positions (preside
by specialist 11y ago
Agreed.
But even when the USA sees the light on proportional representation, there will continue to be winner takes all elections. Executive positions (president, governor, mayor), senators, judges, ballot issues, etc.
In those cases, approval voting is the correct answer. Easy to explain, easy to tabulate, most mathematically fair, hardest to game.
Per Duvenger's Law, approval voting would probably also help replace the current two party system with more choices.
- powera 11y agoOn the other hand, you can't gerrymander Senate seats. (it's not representative now, but it's not changing either)
- specialist 11y agoI'm totally on board with starting over with new state boundaries.
- afarrell 11y agoI'm actually really intensely curious how one would design a voting system for people to choose what subentities to belong to. How would you populate the ballot? Would you run a clustering algorithm on the votes? What if New Jersey and Michigan just decide they want to be as they are, but excluding Camden and Detroit respectively? Or would you do something whimsical like draw lines based on football/baseball teams and cleave states like CT in half?
- vpeters25 11y agoUnlike the House, which represents the people, the Senate represents the states. That's why each state has 2 senators regardless of its size and population: I think the idea was to prevent oppression by large states.
- tadfisher 11y agoSo splitline-partition the country.
- nickff 11y agoThe intent of the Senate was to preserve the independence and influence of the states. If you splitline-partition the country, you are eliminating the means of achieving this goal, and it would be simpler to abolish the Senate. It can be argued that the current system of directly electing Senators has already made the institution unrepresentative of the interests of the state governments, but your proposal would further alienate Senators from their home states.
- WildUtah 11y agoThere is no constitutional provision that would ever allow abolishing the Senate. The Constitution of the USA prohibits any amendment that could change the disproportionality of the Senate.
- schoen 11y agoTechnically it says that "no state, without its consent, shall be deprived of its equal suffrage in the Senate" so the Senate could presumably be abolished by constitutional amendment if all states agreed. (I wonder about replacing the Senate with another legislative house and giving the existing Senate largely ceremonial responsibilities without formally abolishing it -- would that count as depriving the states of equal suffrage in the Senate?)
- pc86 11y agoPresumably any amendment that would abolish or sufficiently alter the Senate would simply remove that article as well. The phrase "the Constitution prohibits this amendment" doesn't make any sense because an amendment to the Constitution cannot by definition be unconstitutional.
- WildUtah 11y agoNorth and South Dakota are two states instead of one so that Republicans could have an extra two senators. Hawai'i and Alaska were admitted to the Union together so that neither party would gain an advantage in the Senate from the addition. So yes, you can gerrymander Senate seats. It's just harder and less reliable than House seats.
- rmc 11y agoI wonder is this one reason some in the US Establishment are opposed to Peuto Rico being a state? Since it would probably be 2 Democrats?
- Bud 11y agoThere is no question about it. Same with the District of Columbia and various other places that should arguably already be states. They'd be likely to provide Democratic Senators, so there is a gigantic roadblock to keep this from happening.
- philwelch 11y agoLikewise, the promise of 2 Democratic senators is the main reason that Democrats are pushing for DC statehood rather than the more logical outcome, which would be retrocession of the city of Washington to Maryland.
- pc86 11y agoIt's more difficult to make an argument against Puerto Rican statehood, but DC is expressly not a state, and should either remain a federal district with no voting representation or be part of Maryland (as stated elsewhere).
- pc86 11y agoIf you're willing to change the definition of the word gerrymander, sure.
- Turing_Machine 11y ago"But even when the USA sees the light on proportional representation" "Sees the light"? Proportional representation is far from a panacea. It tends to lead to a fragmented government (which is usually bad). It also privileges party over individual candidates (which can be good or bad, but those who dislike partisanship would certainly disapprove). There are other factors at play as well. Most (in)famously, the Weimar Republic used PR. That didn't end well.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoIt tends to lead to a fragmented government (which is usually bad). Already the case. It also privileges party over individual candidates Distinction without a difference. Even if the focus is on the candidates, they're all firmly partisan with little variation. Most (in)famously, the Weimar Republic used PR. That didn't end well. http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HitlerAteSugar http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HitlerAteSugar
- Turing_Machine 11y ago"http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HitlerAteSugar" http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HitlerAteSugar" No, that is not the point. Hitler eating sugar had nothing to do with his government. Proportional representation did. That's how he came to power. Look it up. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolf_Hitler#Appointment_as_chancellor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolf_Hitler#Appointment_as_ch... "Hindenburg reluctantly agreed to appoint Hitler as chancellor after two further parliamentary elections—in July and November 1932—had not resulted in the formation of a majority government." They had large number of splinter parties, all of whom hated each other's guts, and which were unable to form an effective government. The Nazis were not a majority (no one was), but were a large, well-disciplined bloc. The rest is, as they say, history.
- vojvod 11y agoWhat alternative electoral system would have kept the Nazis out of power in spite of their huge lead in vote share in three successive elections?
- LordKano 11y agoI kind of like approval voting but there's one big problem. How to we enact it? I also see a small problem. Party representatives stand outside of polling places and present voters with lists of party endorsed candidates. People who currently vote solely on the basis of party will just approve only candidates who are on the party provided list. The two major parties control virtually every legislative body in the country and the current system serves them best. Knee-jerk answers like "Vote the bums out" isn't realistic. I'm thinking back to when the people of Washington DC voted back into office as their mayor, a man who was videotaped smoking crack cocaine. Even when it should be a simple matter, party politics trumps common sense.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> How to we enact it? (And this applies to any electoral reform that there is resistance to by incumbents, not just approval voting, which I don't particular prefer.) In states with citizen initiative processes that bypass incumbent office holders, by that method. Elsewhere, by building support in the electorate and then running candidates on a platform of doing that, and keeping organized in the electorate to hold those candidates accountable.
- specialist 11y agoLow hanging fruit. Join your local party and sneak it into your platform. Use it whenever it makes sense. I used approval voting for feature planning and triaging bugs. Our study group uses it to choose dinner. Etc.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoI see no appeal in proportional representation. The idea that I can only vote for a party, and that they get to choose which people actually hold those seats... it is repulsive and sickening.
- emergentcypher 11y agoAny belief you have that the present system works any differently is a fiction.
- dragonwriter 11y agoYou aren't describing PR, you are describing party list systems, which are one method of achieving PR. Single Transferrable Vote in multimember districts also achieved proportionality of representation, but involves directly voting for candidates. MMP mixes elements of FPTP and party list proportional. And there are a bunch of other mechanisms for achieving PR.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> But even when the USA sees the light on proportional representation, there will continue to be winner takes all elections. Executive positions (president, governor, mayor), senators, judges, ballot issues, etc. Maybe, maybe not. Most of those don't fundamentally have to be single-winner elected things, e.g., executive positions don't have to be single-winner systems; multiseat executives do exist, after all -- even many US states have multiseat executives, but do those by single-winner election with seats allocated by portfolio (see, e.g., California's "Constitutional officers".) > In those cases, approval voting is the correct answer. Approval voting is, IMO, generally a poor choice for most elections (its good for elections in groups where disapproval or approval is tied to some substantive commitment -- e.g., if you are voting on where to go to for lunch, and "approve" on an option means "I will go if this option is chosen".) It doesn't make a lot of sense for most other purposes (because "approval" doesn't mean the same thing across different ballots -- this is actually true, though to a far lesser degree, of systems that require a forced ranking ballot, which is why I prefer ranked voting systems that can use unforced rankings) -- for ballot props that potentially might conflict, a system that merges features of majority and approval makes some sense (that is, it takes a majority to pass, but in the case of conflict the larger majority trumps the smaller one) and is, in fact, already used in some places (e.g., its what California already uses for ballot props.) > Easy to explain, easy to tabulate, most mathematically fair, hardest to game. IRV isn't much worse on any of those, and is if anything more familiar (and if you are using STV for multiseat elections, IRV is identical, so even though its a little harder to explain on its own, if you are using STV elsewhere, IRV for single-seat elections is pretty much free in terms of complexity, either of explanation or administration.)
- specialist 11y agoIRV isn't much worse on any of those... I was an active IRV proponent. Then I figured out they require computerized tabulation (for non trivial elections, such as my jurisdiction) and are infeasible to audit.