4 ms·
Haystack Is Now Sortfolio: A Trademark Issue
- cmelbye 17y agoInteresting. I think the new name is actually a bit better, as it better represents the service's main feature which is sorting through thousands of designers.
- bretpiatt 17y agoAgreed, haystack, from the "needle in a haystack" may work well for native English speakers but expressions like that don't always translate well. Sortfolio will be much more clear to a global audience needing design.
- slavingia 17y agoThe combination of two English words may be harder to comprehend than just one idiom.
- prawn 17y agoI think Haystack is the better name of the two - stronger and punchier. Because the domain has a perception of greater value, I think the operators are perceived as more professional. Sortfolio could be any old weekend 2.0 start-up that threw together two keywords and found a spare domain. Still, I absolutely admire their ability (with the original concept) to leverage their brand and audience, create business leads for customers, and (most significantly) succeed with a stale, done-to-death idea (directory of businesses).
- icefox 17y agoShouldn't a blog entry talking about how they have to do a bunch of promotion include a sentence about what Sortfolio is?
- mixmax 17y ago"Over the next few weeks we traded a few emails back and forth. We didn’t agree with their claim, but we didn’t want to get into a protracted legal battle either. Any time you can avoid lawyers is a good time. They agreed." Nice to see that disputes can actually be solved without laywers.
- lionhearted 17y ago> Nice to see that disputes can actually be solved without laywers. Sort of - they solved the dispute without lawyers by capitulating. Usually you can avoid a legal fight by backing down and doing what the other side wants. That said, still probably the correct course of action. They didn't have any real brand equity built up in Haystack, so moving on now means they don't run any risk of getting shut down later. More importantly, they've got a small team and no legal department, so making this not on the minds of their team is very valuable. That said, Haystack was a very catchy name, and I don't dig on Sortfolio as much. Still a decent name and important to not run the risk and waste the brainpower of their team though. I like to think I'd have made the same decision, but I wonder if I'd have gone on an ego trip and gotten ready for war. Something for me to consider and meditate on, and seems like a pretty enlightened and safe call by the 37S team.
- mixmax 17y agoI don't think they capitulated as much as they just realised that prolonged battles in court don't add any value to customers. As you say, they didn't really have any brand equity in the name, and so didn't really lose that much.
- lionhearted 17y ago> I don't think they capitulated as much as they just realised that prolonged battles in court don't add any value to customers. That's a very good point, you put it really well there. It's easy to get caught up in "are we the good guys?", "can we win the fight?", harder to ask - "What's best for our customers?" Insightful comment, I agree with you.
- snprbob86 17y agoI didn't realize 37signals had a service called Haystack. I assumed this post was about Facebook's Haystack photo storage system.
- jmatt 17y agoAlso modular search for django - http://haystacksearch.org/ http://haystacksearch.org/
- throw_away 17y agoalso a storage engine used internally at cnet for something called webshots: http://martingreen.typepad.com/forward_looking_statement/2006/06/more_on_haystac.html http://martingreen.typepad.com/forward_looking_statement/200...
- taitems 17y agoHaystack.com over the years and its various owners: - 1996: http://web.archive.org/web/19961105183402/http://www.haystack.com/ http://web.archive.org/web/19961105183402/http://www.haystac... - 2002 (redirect): http://web.archive.org/web/20020802105208/www.nai.com/ http://web.archive.org/web/20020802105208/www.nai.com/ - 2006: http://web.archive.org/web/20060818061259/http://www.haystack.com/ http://web.archive.org/web/20060818061259/http://www.haystac...